Originally posted by Dshearn:
Originally posted by Memphis9er:
People that think Rodgers would have done any better here than Smith makes my stomach hurt...good lord folks, can you not understand how bad the Niners were compared to the packers? Can you not understand that Rodgers was developed the right way, whereas Smith was thrown to the wolves? I know some of the Cal guys are looking at the situation through the lenses of bias for the hometown boy, but to think that Rodgers wouldn't have struggled in the same situation, or that Smith wouldn't have shined in Rodgers situation is just lacking in comprehension, reasoning, and logic.
Shaun HILL HAS DONE BETTER THEN A SMITH
KEN DORSEY HAS DONE BETTER THEN A SMITH
there is not a SINGLE SEASON were MORE then 1 QB has started for the 49ers were SOME OTHER QB has NOT DONE BETTER THEN A SMITH
f**k YES , Rodgers would have done better then A Smith
SMITH SUCKS ASS
When Smith cant beat out Tim Rattay or Shaun hill to start , there is no way in HELL he could have beat out a FRANCHISE QB like A. rodgers
[sigh]. You miss the point. Rogers wasn't a franchise qb. He was developed into a franchise qb by his club. Now, neither you nor I know if they could have done that with Smith, although I suspect they would, but one thing we can be sure of, the 49ers at that time couldn't. Not with Smith, not with Rogers.