Originally posted by Midbay:
Post #26073 on page 1739 (crazy numbers!) has the video chunk.
I watched the clip (and edited my post).
I'm not sure JD is correctly applying what the CBA says to his analysis of the situation. An example: there doesn't seem to be any situation in which the 49ers would be able to recoup his entire 23m dollar signing bonus (though they would be able to recoup a significant percentage of it if he were to remain on the left squad/reserve list for the next 3 years). From the CBA:
'Maximum Forfeitable Salary.
Under this Section, and without limitation, under no circumstances may a player be required to forfeit more than 100% of his Forfeitable Salary Allocations for each League Year in which he commits a Forfeitable Breach. With respect to roster bonus, option bonus and reporting bonus, a forfeiture may only occur if the Forfeitable Breach occurs in the same League Year in which the bonus is scheduled to be earned.'
Another example: In the video JD mentioned if Aiyuk misses the preseason the 49ers would be able to go after 25 percent of his signing bonus (5m). This is misstated. They would be able to go after a portion of the prorated bonus amount for this league year, not the total bonus… which is a much smaller number.
[ Edited by SmokeyJoe on Aug 19, 2026 at 11:29 AM ]
Niner Talk » Brandon Aiyuk is a Quitter! Pick #25, 2020 NFL Draft