There are 56 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

Top 3 underrated and overrated 49ers

Originally posted by BubbaParisMVP:
Originally posted by dugo:
Overrated
Tim Mc Donald
Ricky Watters
Dexter Carter


Underrated
Harris Barton
Kenna Turner
Joe Perry

Nice! Can't argue with any of that--except Bubba Paris should be on underrated list.

And, dugo, if I ever catch you saying the name "Dexter Carter" again, I swear to the Great Pumpkin, I'll find you and you will pay! ;)

In other Disaster Carter related news, our equipment manager needs to be fired ASAP for issuing Adams with the number 35. Same number, same pitiful result. That number should be banned from use for anyone that might field punt or kick returns.

hahahahaha...yeah your rite Bubba Paris was definitely underrated tho
[ Edited by dugo on Sep 22, 2010 at 7:13 PM ]
Originally posted by Shaj:
Originally posted by leakyfausett:
Overratted

Chilo Rachal
M. Crabtree ( for Now)
Terrel Brown


Underrated
Josh Morgan
Ray McDonald
Delanie Walker
[b]Shaq (for being able to hold onto a monster dump just to make it to halftime)[/b]
I have added a should be cut or at least benched group also
M Norris (cut)
Payrs Haralson (benched)
Chilo Rachal (benched)

Winner!!!

I asked Monday in the game thread shortly after halftime that someone should go check on Shaq. Afraid you might have some veins popping out of your neck and forehead.
Overrated
Staley
Heitmann
Tarrell Brown
(on this forum) Nate Davis, Chris Carr, Troy Smith, any backup to Alex Smith


Underrated
Alex Smith, hes not a BAD QB hes an average QB
Josh Morgan
Takeo Spikes
Ahmad Brooks
Spencer (he had a bad week 1 though)
[ Edited by CrAnKD4TCRabTree on Sep 22, 2010 at 8:08 PM ]
Overrated:
Goldson
Baas
Rachal

Underrated:
Sopoaga
Takeo
Ray Mac
Over rated:
Crabtree- terrible hands so far
Parys- last time he made a play was?
Gore- I love him but convert short yardage and hold onto the ball

Under rated
Morgan- always does his job
Lawson- besides pass rush stud in every other aspect
Bowman- just watch Sunday
  • HERN
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 403
underrated
ray macdonald
takeo spikes
issac sapoaga

overrated
nate clements
joe staley
delani walker
UNDERRATED- D. WALKER
J. MORAGAN
J. NEDNEY

OVERRATTED- A. SMITH
M. CRABBYTREE
D. GOLDSON
Overrated

Joe Staley
Delanie Walker
Michael Lewis

Underrated

Anthony Dixon
Nate Clements
Jed York
Overrated: Eric Heitman, Dashon Goldson, Taylor Mays
Underrated: Manny Lawson, Michael Lewis, Nate Clements
Overrated:
Dashon Goldson
Chilo Rachal
Parys Haralson

Underrated:
Josh Morgan
Shawntae Spencer
Anthony Davis
Originally posted by TexasNiner84:
Overrated:
Dashon Goldson
Chilo Rachal
Parys Haralson

Underrated:
Josh Morgan
Shawntae Spencer
Anthony Davis

I don't know that Parys is overrated, and Shawntae certainly isn't underrated the talk of him being a shutdown corner on here is ridiculous.
Over: Delanie Walker, Boone, Zeigler (Sorry, but saying he should be the #1 or #2? .. easy pick here)

Under: Heitmann, Brooks, Sopoaga
Originally posted by 49erRider:
Overrated:

1. Manny Lawson - Can't shed a block to save his life
2. Dashon Goldson - Liability in coverage
3. Joe Nedney - No longer has range

Underrated:

1. Dominique Zeigler - Always makes the catch
2. Ricky Jean-Francois - Played great when Franklin was holding out
3. Frank Gore - No matter how much credit he gets, he deserves more

Frank Gore - No matter how much credit he gets, he deserves more---> DEF THIS!!!!
...