Originally posted by BirdmanJr:Originally posted by danimal:Originally posted by BirdmanJr:
Big Ben is the most overrated QB in the NFL? Really?
then wtf is Alex Smith
I don't mean to make fun of Smith but damn
You know the definition of overrated don't ya. Anybody can be overrated. A 3rd string safety could be overrated
Now if you are asking me who is the most overrated QB in the NFL based on a poll of webzoners...I would definitely say Alex Smith.
But I was speaking nationally. Many fans think Big Ben is better than he actually is...IMHO.....thus I think he is the most overrated QB in the NFL. I also think Favre is really overrated these days.
I don't care if he's overrated by fans.
He is a franchise QB who wins games. Sure he might not be a flashy guy like Brees but he still gets the job done.
He will s**t on any QB we have and if he's available (which I really doubt they just will s**t him away) then I would like to see us at least try.
We all have hopes and dreams of Smith becoming a great QB and I support it but with our luck he's gonna fail. Then what? Draft another QB? I dunno I just wanna win a SB and Big Ben has done it twice. Sure he sucked in his first one but he still made it there.
You do realize we are not the Pittsburgh Steelers right.
You do realize there is a concept that sometimes a player is made to look better by his teammates and coaches right.
Peyton on the Niners. LOVE IT
Brady on the Niners. LOVE IT
Brees on the Niners. LOVE IT
Roethlisberger on the Niners. Hmm.
You see my point.
Trust me, I know he would be better than Alex Smith. Ben > Alex on all 32 teams. I get that. So then you have to measure how much of an upgrade he would be over Alex vs. the cost(which should be viewed as a total team negatory)
Thats where I am not sure it is a good move for us.
Don't get me wrong, I would be stoked. But I wouldn't be surprised if it flopped also.