Solid B grade.
Lance - Fields was my shadow pick. However, Lance is the best projection in Shanahan's scheme because he played in the WCO and thrived in that scheme. He is a passer first with talented running ability. Now is he worth 2 firsts + 3rd to swap 1sts to snag him? Time will tell. We'll need 3 years to fully evaluate this trade. But it sounds like the 49ers did a lot of research in ensuring Lance was the right selection. B overall. B+ for the player, C for the trade.
Banks - My hunch was OL or DB for round 2, and I frickin love Banks at RG for us. Radunz was my shadow pick. However, Banks is a beast and should be a top 10 RG day 1. If he can lose some of his belly weight without giving up the anchor power in the run game, I see him really becoming a top 10 overall guard in the league. I think this pick was fueled by Watt and Donald in our division, but it's a good sign Lynch and Shanahan recognize RG was been a rotating position for us long-term. A+ here w. the trade down.
Serman - The 49ers traded 2 fourth round picks to snag Serman at the front end of the bottom half of the 3rd round. Head scratcher for me initially. Serman reminds me of a hybrid Tevin Coleman meets Carlos Hyde. He's got initial burst, good field vision, plays a role in the passing game, and can break tackles. This is clearly a pick for the future as the RB 1 when Lance takes over at QB. Personally, I would have held on to both 4th rounders - plenty of talent at RB, CB, and WR for selection with 2 picks. B for the player, D for the value.
Thomas - Assuming the 49ers are starting to shift to a more classic Schwartz 4-3 scheme with more zone, I love this pick. What he lacks in size he makes up in physical agility and ability skills. Sub 4.4 with good playmaking skills. I think the 49ers didn't expect a run on CBs before they selected. I truly think Adebo or St. Juste would have been the preferred guys. That's where the 5th or 6th rounder could have been used for a trade up. However, Thomas is a good pick. B+ for the player.
Moore - Double interior OLs in the draft is an interesting move. Similar to Lance and Serman, this is likely a pick for the future to succeed Laken at LG. He offers flex at LT and OG. This was a popular pick for me and the zone. For year 1, he'll likely replace Coleman or Skule on the depth chart. Cheaper and an upgrade. A grade for this selection.
Lenior - One of the last remaining tier 3 guys in my book, Lenior should offer upside as a developmental NB and ST ace. Love his physicality and tackling ability. If he develops, I could see him succeeding KK at NB. B+ grade for this selection.
Hufanga - Good college player that's really hard to project in the pros. Dime DB or LB, ST ace, or base LB, he could end up as a jack of all trades, master of none. But when you are this late in the 5th round, it's a wild guess. You ain't going to always strike gold like the Kittle selection. B grade for this selection. Will fight for the last safety spot on the depth chart.
Mitchell - Perhaps he was too good to pass up, but this pick makes no damn sense unless Wilson or Mostert are on the trade block. 4.3 speed that can be a developmental prospect, but hard to see if he does make the roster. Iron sharpens iron here, but Shi Smith would have been a no brainer selection for me at this spot. B for the player, D for value.
There are 847 users in the forums
Draft Grade
Draft Grade
May 2, 2021 at 8:47 AM
- GEEK
- Veteran
- Posts: 19,435
May 2, 2021 at 8:49 AM
- JDTical
- Veteran
- Posts: 136
B-. I have the sense that Lynch got stuck in a couple of spots. I'm sure they like Banks at 48, but it just seemed like the trade back was gambling on Samuel being there still. At 102, Thomas is okay- but there were two superior DB's taken right before. Mitchell was another place where I think they were caught out a bit.
If Banks and one of the other later picks can contribute right away, that would be a great start.
If Banks and one of the other later picks can contribute right away, that would be a great start.
May 2, 2021 at 8:58 AM
- SlowDownBoy
- Veteran
- Posts: 652
Call me crazy but this felt like a Mike Shanahan draft.
May 2, 2021 at 8:59 AM
- TheWooLick
- Veteran
- Posts: 44,775
Dynamic FQB and a stud OL
May 2, 2021 at 9:03 AM
- CatchMaster80
- Veteran
- Posts: 21,166
I gave them a B+. They addressed most of the spots they needed to so now it comes down to whether the guys they picked work out. If they don't that doesn't mean it was a bad pick. It just means the player was a bust. If Lance doesn't become a top tier QB it doesn't make the pick bad. The pick is fine but the player has to step up and be the player he's projected to be.
Like when they picked Thomas with the 3rd overall pick. It may have been a slight reach but most football experts felt it was a good pick. The fact that he didn't work out is on him, not the team. Unless a team really reaches for a player or uses a high pick on a position they don't need, I never really say it was a bad pick. As long as they are picking players at positions of need I'm okay with it. If they don't work out then welcome to the NFL. Over half the draft won't be in the league in 3 years.
Like when they picked Thomas with the 3rd overall pick. It may have been a slight reach but most football experts felt it was a good pick. The fact that he didn't work out is on him, not the team. Unless a team really reaches for a player or uses a high pick on a position they don't need, I never really say it was a bad pick. As long as they are picking players at positions of need I'm okay with it. If they don't work out then welcome to the NFL. Over half the draft won't be in the league in 3 years.
May 2, 2021 at 9:11 AM
- lamontb
- Veteran
- Posts: 33,648
B
May 2, 2021 at 9:28 AM
- ChaunceyGardner
- Q46 Draft Winner
- Posts: 23,988
A+
They made a bold move for a FQB
Followed a board, let the draft come to them. Didn't force any picks. Very good group of players. Thought they got value and fit, took their guys. This roster doesn't have many open spots
They made a bold move for a FQB
Followed a board, let the draft come to them. Didn't force any picks. Very good group of players. Thought they got value and fit, took their guys. This roster doesn't have many open spots
May 2, 2021 at 9:39 AM
- Ark49er
- Veteran
- Posts: 6,342
Solid B/B- grade for me. We got one of the two QBs that I wanted but what really excited me is drafting the 2 OL that I believe will be long time contributors. Aaron Banks should start and with him plus Lake and Williams we have some big nasties in the trenches.
The thing that kept this from being an A and up there with the Cardinals who gets the highest grade in our division, is that I really thought the team should have gotten some speed at WR. We didn't address that in the draft and had plenty of opportunity to do so.
The thing that kept this from being an A and up there with the Cardinals who gets the highest grade in our division, is that I really thought the team should have gotten some speed at WR. We didn't address that in the draft and had plenty of opportunity to do so.
May 2, 2021 at 9:47 AM
- zeppfan1
- Veteran
- Posts: 10,018
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Dynamic FQB and a stud OL
Love that movie
May 2, 2021 at 9:55 AM
- 808niner4lyphe
- Veteran
- Posts: 7,611
Originally posted by ChaunceyGardner:
A+
They made a bold move for a FQB
Followed a board, let the draft come to them. Didn't force any picks. Very good group of players. Thought they got value and fit, took their guys. This roster doesn't have many open spots
That alone made this draft a A+
Kyle finally got to pick his own Lamborghini without anyone's input (maybe a little from Lynch).
May 2, 2021 at 9:58 AM
- Giedi
- Veteran
- Posts: 35,228
Originally posted by SlowDownBoy:
Call me crazy but this felt like a Mike Shanahan draft.
Agree, it kind of does. In the after draft interview, John did say he talked a lot more to Mike Shanahan this time around than prior drafts, and so did the rest of the personnel department.
May 2, 2021 at 10:00 AM
- DimezandDots
- Member
- Posts: 65
I give them a B+ because they addressed the key positions. The one pick I didn't like was Aaron Banks, I feel like we could have not traded down and selected Asante Samuel Jr.
May 2, 2021 at 10:01 AM
- Giedi
- Veteran
- Posts: 35,228
Originally posted by 808niner4lyphe:
Originally posted by ChaunceyGardner:
A+
They made a bold move for a FQB
Followed a board, let the draft come to them. Didn't force any picks. Very good group of players. Thought they got value and fit, took their guys. This roster doesn't have many open spots
That alone made this draft a A+
Kyle finally got to pick his own Lamborghini without anyone's input (maybe a little from Lynch).
Agree, I rewatched some more of his game. Finally watched till the end of all his college throws, last time I only watched the first half of a 3 hour video. I come off even more impressed as towards the latter half of 2019, he was hitting long bombs regularly with his WRs. This guy is going to be special.
May 2, 2021 at 10:03 AM
- DimezandDots
- Member
- Posts: 65
Instead of taking Eli Mitchell, I think we should have picked Trill Williams instead.
May 2, 2021 at 10:05 AM
- NC49er
- Veteran
- Posts: 1,605
Originally posted by father49er:
Originally posted by goldlame2013:
Qb, two OL, two RB. They trying build a bully. Like the old Harbaugh teams.
Getting bigger to reduce injuries. Let's hope we won't lose speed advantage.
They now have both options, milk that clock with a slow grind & score, so our D rests while giving little time for an opponent comeback, or bring in Most and JW when they want the speed.