Originally posted by tankle104:
You're taking the opinions of like a bunch of guys on here and making it seem like everyone that doesn't think like you perspective wise, has all of the opinions combined.
i know I've said many times I didn't expect Lance to get traded, if he does, until sometime in camp when they know what darnold looks like and how Brock is.
I never said he's terrible and can't improve. Lol once again. You just keep saying stuff that I've never said.
if you want to be taken seriously, at least accuse specific people of things they've said. Lol you can't wrap up 20 guys random opinions and bunch everyone together. Lmao
Lance won't beat out Purdy. It just won't happen. Lance didn't even look good enough in minicamp to outshine darnold for Christ sake. But don't trip, he's going to be a superstar this year.
everyone knows he can get better, especially cause he's been bad - hence the trade value and how the team feels about him, that isn't in question. Just not everyone thinks he is going to be some superstar and never has. I was optimistic but it was never something I really felt like would happen.
If he ends up playing, good, I'll root for him. If he can beat out Brock, great, even better. Those are BIG it's. I wouldn't get your life on it.
im just tired of waiting around for two years of this guy to get ANY glimmer of or showing that he can be special. Especially now that we have a young kid who just did special things. The only knock is he got injured on a freak play, one that's more unlikely than what happened to Lance. Outside of that play, he's never missed a game career wise. I don't see what the injury concern is. Lance hasn't managed to stay healthy for two years straight, he's the one I'm worried that will get reinjured
I don't have the time to match up posters to things. You know I'm not making up anything that I said. If it doesn't apply to you then don't worry about it.
And if you don't want to be lumped in with the extreme Trey bashers then don't join in with drama filled responses like claiming anyone said if Lance doesn't have all pros all around him it means he is on a terrible team.
Or make comments like the bolded above. This is the difference between you and me. I don't like to play with hypotheticals. I want to see how things play out before I make a judgement call.
I wasn't out on Jimmy until he proved his limitations time and time again and even then I wasn't eager to push him aside. Brock played great last year, I'm excited to see him come back fully healthy BUT we have seen a similar situation before with Jimmy. He looked amazing in 2017, went 5-0 and looked like we found our franchise QB. He then got hurt and suddenly we started seeing his limitations show up.
If you look at my posts here you will not find me bashing Brock in the least bit. I simply want the team to make a proper evaluation of the guys they have because getting it right is absolutely critical to our success as a franchise.
Facts are Brock is recovering from a serious injury to his throwing arm, an injury we haven' seen often to understand the recovery process very well. Am I going to put money on Trey winning QB1? No. Do I want to see an actual competition? Yes.
This is the simple fact you and others simply refuse to acknowledge for some reason. We have no idea how Brock will look after his injury. We don't have a great idea how Lance will look with the work he's put in this offseason or even how Darnold will look as he works to learn the offense.
Shanahan said the competition doesn't start til training camp. Thankfully we get media access to each practice and many are open to the public for "non biased" opinions. We will see soon enough where the guys stand.
EVERY 49ers fan should want a legit competition.
