Jimmy Garoppolo, QB, Los Angeles Rams

Originally posted by okdkid:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by mattster03:

Originally posted by okdkid:
15-4 TD to Int ratio, top 10 in most relevant QB metrics and people still hating. Goes to show that people are irrational and will not alter a viewpoint in the presence of new information.

"hE iS wHo He iS"

Yeah a dope top 10 QB in 2022.

Brain. Plasticity.

1.Josh Allen
2. Mahomes
3. Lamar
4. Joe Cool
5. Herbert
6. Hurts
7. Rodgers
8. Brady
9. Prescott
10. Tua

This is not a 2022 list. Rodgers? Brady? Sure. Three years ago. This is a social media list. Not a list of the best performing QBs in 2022.

I'll take Rodgers over Jimmy G can't believe we are in a spot where that's a bold claim.

Originally posted by picklejuice:

Listen, as the conductor of the Jimmy Hater train since week 1 of 2018, if I can recognize he's playing well, perhaps even his best ball, then you can too.

— Rich (@richjmadrid) November 23, 2022

:O

He is playing his best ball. I've never seen him play better.

it's just another opinion but even Rich Eisen just said that if Jimmy wins the SB he's not going anywhere. says Jed will see the trophy being worth way more than three draft picks and run it back.

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by TheRickestRick:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by mattster03:

Originally posted by okdkid:
15-4 TD to Int ratio, top 10 in most relevant QB metrics and people still hating. Goes to show that people are irrational and will not alter a viewpoint in the presence of new information.

"hE iS wHo He iS"

Yeah a dope top 10 QB in 2022.

Brain. Plasticity.

1.Josh Allen
2. Mahomes
3. Lamar
4. Joe Cool
5. Herbert
6. Hurts
7. Rodgers
8. Brady
9. Prescott
10. Tua

This seems like a combination of last year with this year. Im still waiting for Jimmy G to Jimmy G it up but he has outplayed at least a 3rd of those QBs on that list this year. Now talent-wise, I get it. But you failed to expand on your rankings and the deciding factors. For example Jackson has a 16/7 TD/Int ratio, Jimmy 15/4 with more yards and a higher completion percentage.Now Jackson can run the balls off a horse but just saying as a passer, he is beating a few players on this list... but so is Geno Smith lol. Preconceptions are a thing.

I'm still holding my breath everytime he drops back and throws it past 10 yards but the man should get his due. Last time he played this well was against the saints in 2019, take it for what its worth. But in this season, he's doing his job.

Yeah I'm for sure giving credit for previous success. Unless people wanna say Geno Smith is a top 5 QB in the league.

Then 100% I agree, or maybe 99%. I would just say Tua may not be top 10 but I guess after the top 9... who is left that separates themselves. Rodgers is missing passes this year but he is working with crap, Hurts is killing it but still not sold he can be consistent for years to come so maybe the back half of the ten. Prescott probably higher but whatever its all subjective, 9/10 of those names I agree with 100%.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
We gotta pump the brakes on this stuff I saw the same posts a year ago at this time.. it's like we don't learn from history / the past.. one game at a time ppl

Yeah, and you were leading the charge...and for many months prior to that, until the NFL spoke and you changed your tune, moving the goal posts like a construction crew getting paid double time if they could complete the job prior to the deadline.

Originally posted by dj43:
The reason I don't think the Jets would make that move is the same reason the 49ers might force Jimmy to leave while turning over the keys to Lance: they are too invested in draft capital at this point to admit they made a mistake. To that point, neither side has seen enough of their draft pick to make a major jump to another option. It is a catch-22 for both sides.

I would hope, and believe, the 49ers' staff is professional enough to admit, if they made a mistake with Lance, to own that mistake and not look at the future of the team as a sunk cost with Lance. If Lance is not the guy (in their eyes - and I do not know how you make that determination in four games), go with Jimmy. But as Faithful alluded to above, I think a lot of fans are putting the cart before the horse right now. Let's see where we are in Feb.

Originally posted by Waterbear:
I truly believe that the 49ers feel a lot better about Lance than the Jets feel about Wilson, and that these opinions of resigning Jimmy would seem ridiculous had Trey not been injured.

That's a Texas size 10-4, good buddy.

Originally posted by boast:
it's just another opinion but even Rich Eisen just said that if Jimmy wins the SB he's not going anywhere. says Jed will see the trophy being worth way more than three draft picks and run it back.

I'm no Himmy super fan but if we win a super bowl I'll be saying we shouldn't break up a good thing. Not the most talented QB but if he gets the job done then let's run it back.

Originally posted by boast:
it's just another opinion but even Rich Eisen just said that if Jimmy wins the SB he's not going anywhere. says Jed will see the trophy being worth way more than three draft picks and run it back.

Even if the 9ers make it to the Super Bowl I don't think he should go anywhere. Its not easy getting, many have tried and failed.

Originally posted by boast:
it's just another opinion but even Rich Eisen just said that if Jimmy wins the SB he's not going anywhere. says Jed will see the trophy being worth way more than three draft picks and run it back.

I love Rich Eisen, but any football opinion that removes all analysis of a players film is not a good opinion.

Otherwise, we should pay big bucks for Joe Flacco or Nick Foles next season to be our backup.

Originally posted by TheRickestRick:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by TheRickestRick:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by mattster03:

Originally posted by okdkid:
15-4 TD to Int ratio, top 10 in most relevant QB metrics and people still hating. Goes to show that people are irrational and will not alter a viewpoint in the presence of new information.

"hE iS wHo He iS"

Yeah a dope top 10 QB in 2022.

Brain. Plasticity.

1.Josh Allen
2. Mahomes
3. Lamar
4. Joe Cool
5. Herbert
6. Hurts
7. Rodgers
8. Brady
9. Prescott
10. Tua

This seems like a combination of last year with this year. Im still waiting for Jimmy G to Jimmy G it up but he has outplayed at least a 3rd of those QBs on that list this year. Now talent-wise, I get it. But you failed to expand on your rankings and the deciding factors. For example Jackson has a 16/7 TD/Int ratio, Jimmy 15/4 with more yards and a higher completion percentage.Now Jackson can run the balls off a horse but just saying as a passer, he is beating a few players on this list... but so is Geno Smith lol. Preconceptions are a thing.

I'm still holding my breath everytime he drops back and throws it past 10 yards but the man should get his due. Last time he played this well was against the saints in 2019, take it for what its worth. But in this season, he's doing his job.

Yeah I'm for sure giving credit for previous success. Unless people wanna say Geno Smith is a top 5 QB in the league.

Then 100% I agree, or maybe 99%. I would just say Tua may not be top 10 but I guess after the top 9... who is left that separates themselves. Rodgers is missing passes this year but he is working with crap, Hurts is killing it but still not sold he can be consistent for years to come so maybe the back half of the ten. Prescott probably higher but whatever its all subjective, 9/10 of those names I agree with 100%.

Yeah I'd say he's close to breaking into the top 10 and he continues to ball out for sure. But Cousins is playing good ball this year. Derek Carr is inconsistent but when he has a good game it's impressive. Deshaun Watson will finally be back on the field soon but I don't think he will look very good with how much time off he's had.

Originally posted by Waterbear:

Originally posted by boast:
it's just another opinion but even Rich Eisen just said that if Jimmy wins the SB he's not going anywhere. says Jed will see the trophy being worth way more than three draft picks and run it back.

I love Rich Eisen, but any football opinion that removes all analysis of a players film is not a good opinion.

Otherwise, we should pay big bucks for Joe Flacco or Nick Foles next season to be our backup.

im pretty sure Eisen watches games. you make it sound like it's based all on emotion.

Rich knows how the NFL operates.

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by boast:
it's just another opinion but even Rich Eisen just said that if Jimmy wins the SB he's not going anywhere. says Jed will see the trophy being worth way more than three draft picks and run it back.

Even if the 9ers make it to the Super Bowl I don't think he should go anywhere. Its not easy getting, many have tried and failed.

I could easily see winning another NFC Championship as enough of a resume to get a new contract as well.

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by boast:
it's just another opinion but even Rich Eisen just said that if Jimmy wins the SB he's not going anywhere. says Jed will see the trophy being worth way more than three draft picks and run it back.

I'm no Himmy super fan but if we win a super bowl I'll be saying we shouldn't break up a good thing. Not the most talented QB but if he gets the job done then let's run it back.

I really don't see a scenario where they bring back Jimmy G for 2023. He's played really well the last month, but he still is not a QB that is going to will his team to victory as an off schedule playmaker, which is often needed in the playoffs, and that's the intrigue and potential with Lance.

Here's the two ways this plays out IMO, and they both lead to Jimmy being gone in 2023:

1. 49ers don't win the SB. Even if Jimmy continues to play really well, if they don't win the SB it's hard to see them sticking with him when they want to see Lance bring that extra level that will get them over the top. Pressure still there on Shanalynch, so gotta see if Lance can be that final piece, so need to get him the experience sooner rather than later.

2. 49ers win the SB. Okay, they pull it out. Guess what? That means even more patience is available for Lance since the team has made it to the top, and Lance longterm has the most potential to keep that top level for years to come, so gotta get him playing time to reach that level sooner rather than later. Less pressure on Shanalynch, so why not use that to their advantage to get Lance going?

The logical choice in either scenario is to bring the future into the present and start Lance in 2023.

Originally posted by boast:
it's just another opinion but even Rich Eisen just said that if Jimmy wins the SB he's not going anywhere. says Jed will see the trophy being worth way more than three draft picks and run it back.

jed loves kyle and will jump off a bridge if he tells him to. if kyle wants to move on then they will.

Originally posted by DonnieDarko:

Originally posted by boast:
it's just another opinion but even Rich Eisen just said that if Jimmy wins the SB he's not going anywhere. says Jed will see the trophy being worth way more than three draft picks and run it back.

jed loves kyle and will jump off a bridge if he tells him to. if kyle wants to move on then they will.

It also helps that Lance is universally praised as the model young player. He's the type of player that invites front office and coaching investment in him.

Jimmy is also a class act. His only fault is that he doesn't have that additional x-factor in his play that the tip top guys have. Well, that and his age compared to Lance. Lance, if he turns out to be the right guy, could be that guy for 15 years.

We can win 2 superbowls with Jimmy and posters will still be asking to improve the qb position.

It makes no sense