Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by tjd808185:
If you want to talk about what makes Seattle's d tick just remember it turned into complete dog sh after Earl Thomas got hurt. Their secondary drives the d and if you go to their SB year they held opposing qb's to a stupid 63 qb rating. That's 13 points better than our spectacular d that year. Bennett and Avril are great but Seattle had a great d before they entered the picture. Most are built thru the line but their gold mine is the secondary. The d line is just one piece of the puzzle and having to spend high picks on Thomas and then a Leo afterwards is going to damper what we can do elsewhere. BTW if we don't land Cousins hold onto your butts because it's going to be a long rebuild.
No doubt he's a huge piece to the D, but that was never part of the discussion in here. It was who's more important a LEO like Bruce Irvin or a DE like Micheal Bennett.
When Bennett was out this yr 3 out of the 5 teams they played scored 20+ vs that defense.
Having a strong front on the DL and OL is the building blocks to a having a solid team. I'll add if all you need is one stud DE in this 4-3 why did the Jags pay top dollar for Campbell when they already had Jackson? Todd Walsh is running the same defense that we will be?
This argument amounts to the chicken or the egg applied to football. One model was SF's which had a dominant front with the Smith combo (J and A), Willis and Bowman, and the other is one that has a secondary capable of single high/man such as Seattle's. Both work, and it depends on personnel.
Relating this back to the draft you have to take the guy you believe will have the most impact at the next level, it's that simple. I don't think drafting Earl Thomas, Eric Berry or Ed Reed in the top 10 would've hurt those clubs any. Why? Because those are f'ing great players. The point is that if you are drafting in the top 5, they have to be impact players wherever they happen to be. If you
really believe Malik Hooker is the next Ed Reed, you draft him at 2 and don't look back. Personally, my top 5 are:
1. Garrett
2. Allen
3. Fournette
4. Hooker
5. Adams
In reality, a QB is going to sneak into the top 5 come draft day so this isn't a reflection of where I think they will be drafted.
[ Edited by bzborow1 on Mar 16, 2017 at 10:58 AM ]