Ted Ginn Jr or Kyle Williams?

ginn sucks, he's yesterdays news

Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
ginn sucks, he's yesterdays news

That's what many said about Crabtree. I tend not to listen to idiots.

Good night. Not wasting anymore time here tonight.

We are lucky to have both of them

deactivate and get the rook goin. Williams looks faster and way more aggressive, I think Ginn is worried about getting hurt..Should be interesting watching Williams return against the Giants next Sunday, bet he does waaaaaaaaaay better. I hated him, but now I wuv him, life is fickle like that.

Ted Ginn Jr. has 3 Kick Return Touchdowns and 3 Punt Return touchdowns so far in his career. He also is a smart special teams player. Did you see him jump on the ball after the punt hit a 9ers player today? He scored 2 special teams touchdowns in 1 game last year against the Seahawks. He played a HUGE role in field position last year. Ginn is one of the best kick/punt returners in the game.

Originally posted by DirtyP:
We are lucky to have both of them

That's another sentiment that I keep overlooking, because it's so easy to forget. We have depth, depth, depth. It's incredible.

This ST is far different from the studs they were last year, even Ginn is finding it hard to get going. But I feel in the case of Ginn its just rust that he needs to shake off. The more plays the better he'll be I hope.

Williams is playing with a chip on his shoulder and he's hungry. However, every time Ginn catches a punt or kickoff with a little space I hold my breath because he can go just like that.

Originally posted by ace49ers:
This ST is far different from the studs they were last year, even Ginn is finding it hard to get going. But I feel in the case of Ginn its just rust that he needs to shake off. The more plays the better he'll be I hope.

losing costanzo and jones hurt us bad.

Williams because he's a much better WR. If Kyle breaks a return or two, this isn't even a discussion. Ginn is just holding Jenkins' roster spot.

This poll shows how fickle this board is. About 8 months ago, people wanted this guy drawn and quartered. To answer the question why both? Randy Moss will be gone after this season, leaving us with Crabtree, Manningham, Jenkins, Williams, and Ginn. There is no reason for us to not bring Ginn back longterm because I think he will finally begin to see that he is a return specialist. That leaves us with 4 capable receivers (assuming Jenkins pans out) and we still have a great group of running backs, an O-line that is beginning to dominate, and Vernon Davis. Besides Ted Ginn being a pretty good returner, he also makes a lot of smart, heads up plays out there. It seems he just knows what to do with the ball in every situation.

I've always backed KW. But yea, 90+ % of the board wanted him gone up until recently. The only other WR that could've pulled off that comeback route, then pulled away from the defender so quickly, would be manningham. KW is a solid WR and a more than adequate return man.

WOW, during training camp and before cut-downs people like me were saying that Ginn should be cut and I was nearly run out of the Zone for it.

Originally posted by 49erswillbeback:
Good night. Not wasting anymore time here tonight.

Your boyfriend is terrible as a wide receiver...period

Comparing Ginn to Crabtree is ridiculous. Crabs is younger and infinitely more talented. Ginn is a burner but can't catch and can't play in traffic...someone you don't "all of a sudden" develop. I can send you a list of CFL receivers I would rather field than Ginn