Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by WestCoast:
Originally posted by excelsior:
It makes no logical sense to trade ANY pick for Kolb, if you can resign Alex and not give up any picks. Compare Kolb's and Alex's stats this last year, and ask your self who appears to be the better QB. And remember that Kolb was supported by a superior OC and OL.
Don't let your intense hatred of Alex lead you into irrational proposals.
other than the fact that kolb had way less starts and actually beat alex and 9ers in sf? kolb is better.
Not to mention Kolb's mechanics, footwork, release and delivery are far better than Smiths. I also like the fact that Kolb has been in the WCO for a few years. But yah, hes not worth a 1st round pick IMO.
He also had better options to throw to and better coaching but hey not like that matters. I'm not even for keeping Alex or anything, I don't really care honestly. But Kolb was supposed to replace McNabb in Philly and started the season off like s**t before he got injured. Then Vick comes in and starts rapin everybody out there and their offense takes off. This dude has a career passer rating of like friggin 73 guys, and last year he was at 76 despite having Reid as coach, recievers Jackson, Maclin, and Celek, and a good pass catching running back in McCoy. To put that in perspective, the guy you all hate(Alex Smith) had a rating of 82.
I dont really care to bring Alex back unless Harbaugh really wants him, but why anyone would trade a 1st round pick for this guy blows my flippin mind. Seriously, he's NOT THAT GOOD. There is definitely no guarantee he'd be even an average QB for us, I don't think he's even worth a 2nd rounder honestly(but some team will overpay and probably give the Beagles what they want), but why do some of the people on here want to trade a first round pick for this guy, the 7th pick in the draft, for a guy who is not even guaranteed to be average? You can get the same production out of Kyle Orton(better actually) and you'd have to trade less, or you can just sign a vet and get similar production and then draft a guy in the 2nd or 3rd like Ponder or Stanzi.