Originally posted by nickbradley:
If we weren't a piss-poor organization, we would have drafted the quick-thinking, local, 49er-loving Rodgers who was willing to take less money to play for us.
Rodgers ran a hybrid pro/spread offense at Cal that was much more conducive to the NFL. I think the fact that Rodgers had a better environment is overblown. Urban Meyer said that Alex Smith would be awful until he's mastered an offense. And you know what? He never did! Although he's very smart, Alex simply cannot process what's happening on the field fast enough to be an effective NFL quarterback. Watch the highlights below to see how quickly Aaron responds to adversity. At about a minute into the video, Okeafor is well off sides and right in his face -- Aaron jukes him and throws a big strike downfield. Alex would have just taken the sack and the 5-yard penalty.
I think Shaun Hill processes information very quickly on the field, but he does not have the physical tools to make the defense pay.
Now re-visit the 2005 draft, turn the tables.... say Alex Smith got drafted by Green Bay having the opportunity to sit and learn behind Bret Farve and Arron Rodgers got drafted by the 9ers starting as a rookie on our horrible 2005, 2006, 2007 team's and then please tell us what do you think would have happen with Alex Smith and Arron Rodgers ?