Originally posted by Amir:NOBODY can be right all the time, we all get that. Our issue with you is that you won't admit when you're wrong. For example, you rated Gabbert higher than Cam and Andy. Let's be real. I know it's only been a year but Gabbert is looking like a bust and Cam and Andy look like they're gonna be great players. Again, I'll give you a few more years for you to try and be correct about that. But instead of saying you may have been wrong about Gabbert, you say how you and OTC and other GM's had Gabbert rated higher than Cam so therefore we can't rag on you because other people were wrong.
If you're gonna bring up the times you're right, don't get butt-hurt when we bring up the times you're wrong. Simple as that. And don't say you don't bring up the times you would have been right. You did it in this very thread.
Nobody is butt hurt and nobody is right or wrong at this point. I think a lot of fans were personally hurt that I did not give a glowing grade to Aldon and CK and they made it a personal issue. Instead of arguing the merits of cases, they went on personal attacks, or attempts to discredit me through a pick or two from the hundreds I have analyzed over the years on the board. They demanded that I admit I was wrong, that I apologize, and a lot of other silly things.
As stated before, I dont apologize for an honest evaluation, and I don't admit fault or error within a few games or a year of a player's performance. I have readily admitted dozens of times, to angry board members that I undervalued how Aldon would do his first year, and he appears to be on the way to a successful career. But nobody is right or wrong about a first year player. CK cold end up better than Newton or Dalton, but as of right now, it doesnt look good, just like it doesn't for Gabbert. Nobody is right or wrong. My pick, Watt, had a great first year, but he could end up being a bust. A late round WR could emerge better than ProBowler AJ Green, who I had on the top of my board.
People just take things way too seriously. This is for fun.