QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by riverrunzthruit:

Originally posted by mayo49:
I need some goddamn, Dirty elbow recovery news.

jus gonna post this...

I see it shaking out now:
Starter - Big Cock Brock
Sideline Play Signaler - Sammy boy
Scout QB and Game Day Active Pinerider - DTR

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by Montana:
Nothing small sample size about BCB imo. Lolol. The only reason BCB is not the long term guy rn is obviously his injury. Trey would defo been a backup. I bet anything we would have won against Philly had there not been such a cluster cluck of events. And a Mahomes/Brock showdown would have been awesome. So damn close.

The only reason why he isn't the clear #1 is because of his injury. His play last year earned the right to be QB1, but his injury changes that.

Until Sam or Trey prove to be better the injury hasn't changed anything

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by Montana:

Nothing small sample size about BCB imo. Lolol. The only reason BCB is not the long term guy rn is obviously his injury. Trey would defo been a backup. I bet anything we would have won against Philly had there not been such a cluster cluck of events. And a Mahomes/Brock showdown would have been awesome. So damn close.

The only reason why he isn't the clear #1 is because of his injury. His play last year earned the right to be QB1, but his injury changes that.

Until Sam or Trey prove to be better the injury hasn't changed anything

If Purdy can't throw a football, he is still QB1?

Is Brock your brother? Son? Not everything people say about Purdy that isn't rainbows and sunshine is a slight dude. I am just as big a Purdy fan as you are. I just like to live in reality.

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by Montana:
Nothing small sample size about BCB imo. Lolol. The only reason BCB is not the long term guy rn is obviously his injury. Trey would defo been a backup. I bet anything we would have won against Philly had there not been such a cluster cluck of events. And a Mahomes/Brock showdown would have been awesome. So damn close.

The only reason why he isn't the clear #1 is because of his injury. His play last year earned the right to be QB1, but his injury changes that.

Until Sam or Trey prove to be better the injury hasn't changed anything

If Purdy can't throw a football, he is still QB1?

Is Brock your brother? Son? Not everything people say about Purdy that isn't rainbows and sunshine is a slight dude. I am just as big a Purdy fan as you are. I just like to live in reality.

If he can't throw a football to start the season a backup will play until QB1 is ready. If said backup plays better than Brock did he will earn the QB1 job.

When has a player ever been demoted by injury alone? They have to get Wally Pipped to lose their spot. You're acting like that has already happened, which isn't reality

Originally posted by Waterbear:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by Montana:

Nothing small sample size about BCB imo. Lolol. The only reason BCB is not the long term guy rn is obviously his injury. Trey would defo been a backup. I bet anything we would have won against Philly had there not been such a cluster cluck of events. And a Mahomes/Brock showdown would have been awesome. So damn close.

The only reason why he isn't the clear #1 is because of his injury. His play last year earned the right to be QB1, but his injury changes that.

Until Sam or Trey prove to be better the injury hasn't changed anything

If Purdy can't throw a football, he is still QB1?

Is Brock your brother? Son? Not everything people say about Purdy that isn't rainbows and sunshine is a slight dude. I am just as big a Purdy fan as you are. I just like to live in reality.

If he can't throw a football to start the season a backup will play until QB1 is ready. If said backup plays better than Brock did he will earn the QB1 job.

When has a player ever been demoted by injury alone? They have to get Wally Pipped to lose their spot. You're acting like that has already happened, which isn't reality

.

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by Waterbear:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by Montana:
Nothing small sample size about BCB imo. Lolol. The only reason BCB is not the long term guy rn is obviously his injury. Trey would defo been a backup. I bet anything we would have won against Philly had there not been such a cluster cluck of events. And a Mahomes/Brock showdown would have been awesome. So damn close.

The only reason why he isn't the clear #1 is because of his injury. His play last year earned the right to be QB1, but his injury changes that.

Until Sam or Trey prove to be better the injury hasn't changed anything

If Purdy can't throw a football, he is still QB1?

Is Brock your brother? Son? Not everything people say about Purdy that isn't rainbows and sunshine is a slight dude. I am just as big a Purdy fan as you are. I just like to live in reality.

If he can't throw a football to start the season a backup will play until QB1 is ready. If said backup plays better than Brock did he will earn the QB1 job.

When has a player ever been demoted by injury alone? They have to get Wally Pipped to lose their spot. You're acting like that has already happened, which isn't reality

.

Our offense scored more points and gained more yards with Kap than Alex. Alex's injury only opened the door, it's not the reason he lost the job

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by Waterbear:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by Montana:

Nothing small sample size about BCB imo. Lolol. The only reason BCB is not the long term guy rn is obviously his injury. Trey would defo been a backup. I bet anything we would have won against Philly had there not been such a cluster cluck of events. And a Mahomes/Brock showdown would have been awesome. So damn close.

The only reason why he isn't the clear #1 is because of his injury. His play last year earned the right to be QB1, but his injury changes that.

Until Sam or Trey prove to be better the injury hasn't changed anything

If Purdy can't throw a football, he is still QB1?

Is Brock your brother? Son? Not everything people say about Purdy that isn't rainbows and sunshine is a slight dude. I am just as big a Purdy fan as you are. I just like to live in reality.

If he can't throw a football to start the season a backup will play until QB1 is ready. If said backup plays better than Brock did he will earn the QB1 job.

When has a player ever been demoted by injury alone? They have to get Wally Pipped to lose their spot. You're acting like that has already happened, which isn't reality

.

Our offense scored more points and gained more yards with Kap than Alex. Alex's injury only opened the door, it's not the reason he lost the job

Alex still lost his job due to injury

the way Kaep fizzled out, should have kept Alex

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by Montana:
Nothing small sample size about BCB imo. Lolol. The only reason BCB is not the long term guy rn is obviously his injury. Trey would defo been a backup. I bet anything we would have won against Philly had there not been such a cluster cluck of events. And a Mahomes/Brock showdown would have been awesome. So damn close.

The only reason why he isn't the clear #1 is because of his injury. His play last year earned the right to be QB1, but his injury changes that.

Until Sam or Trey prove to be better the injury hasn't changed anything

If Purdy can't throw a football, he is still QB1?

Is Brock your brother? Son? Not everything people say about Purdy that isn't rainbows and sunshine is a slight dude. I am just as big a Purdy fan as you are. I just like to live in reality.

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by Waterbear:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by Montana:
Nothing small sample size about BCB imo. Lolol. The only reason BCB is not the long term guy rn is obviously his injury. Trey would defo been a backup. I bet anything we would have won against Philly had there not been such a cluster cluck of events. And a Mahomes/Brock showdown would have been awesome. So damn close.

The only reason why he isn't the clear #1 is because of his injury. His play last year earned the right to be QB1, but his injury changes that.

Until Sam or Trey prove to be better the injury hasn't changed anything

If Purdy can't throw a football, he is still QB1?

Is Brock your brother? Son? Not everything people say about Purdy that isn't rainbows and sunshine is a slight dude. I am just as big a Purdy fan as you are. I just like to live in reality.

If he can't throw a football to start the season a backup will play until QB1 is ready. If said backup plays better than Brock did he will earn the QB1 job.

When has a player ever been demoted by injury alone? They have to get Wally Pipped to lose their spot. You're acting like that has already happened, which isn't reality

.

Our offense scored more points and gained more yards with Kap than Alex. Alex's injury only opened the door, it's not the reason he lost the job

Alex still lost his job due to injury

the way Kaep fizzled out, should have kept Alex

No he lost his job because Kap came in and played better. Alex went on to hold another SB roster back until they also dumped him. No thanks

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by Waterbear:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by Montana:

Nothing small sample size about BCB imo. Lolol. The only reason BCB is not the long term guy rn is obviously his injury. Trey would defo been a backup. I bet anything we would have won against Philly had there not been such a cluster cluck of events. And a Mahomes/Brock showdown would have been awesome. So damn close.

The only reason why he isn't the clear #1 is because of his injury. His play last year earned the right to be QB1, but his injury changes that.

Until Sam or Trey prove to be better the injury hasn't changed anything

If Purdy can't throw a football, he is still QB1?

Is Brock your brother? Son? Not everything people say about Purdy that isn't rainbows and sunshine is a slight dude. I am just as big a Purdy fan as you are. I just like to live in reality.

If he can't throw a football to start the season a backup will play until QB1 is ready. If said backup plays better than Brock did he will earn the QB1 job.

When has a player ever been demoted by injury alone? They have to get Wally Pipped to lose their spot. You're acting like that has already happened, which isn't reality

.

Our offense scored more points and gained more yards with Kap than Alex. Alex's injury only opened the door, it's not the reason he lost the job

Alex still lost his job due to injury

the way Kaep fizzled out, should have kept Alex

No he lost his job because Kap came in and played better. Alex went on to hold another SB roster back until they also dumped him. No thanks

Alex was the most vanilla game
manager ever. I liked him but not as our qb. There is a reason why he never won anything and couldn't lead a team to a winning season without a stacked roster around him.

i was happy when kap kept the starting job, kap just fizzled out.

alex was horrible on third downs. Lol i think he was like 1/13 in the NFCC or something like that. He is the ultimate example of doesnt make players around him better. Great guy though. I just hate QBs like him. So boring and unreliable.

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by Waterbear:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by Montana:
Nothing small sample size about BCB imo. Lolol. The only reason BCB is not the long term guy rn is obviously his injury. Trey would defo been a backup. I bet anything we would have won against Philly had there not been such a cluster cluck of events. And a Mahomes/Brock showdown would have been awesome. So damn close.

The only reason why he isn't the clear #1 is because of his injury. His play last year earned the right to be QB1, but his injury changes that.

Until Sam or Trey prove to be better the injury hasn't changed anything

If Purdy can't throw a football, he is still QB1?

Is Brock your brother? Son? Not everything people say about Purdy that isn't rainbows and sunshine is a slight dude. I am just as big a Purdy fan as you are. I just like to live in reality.

If he can't throw a football to start the season a backup will play until QB1 is ready. If said backup plays better than Brock did he will earn the QB1 job.

When has a player ever been demoted by injury alone? They have to get Wally Pipped to lose their spot. You're acting like that has already happened, which isn't reality

.

Our offense scored more points and gained more yards with Kap than Alex. Alex's injury only opened the door, it's not the reason he lost the job

Alex still lost his job due to injury

the way Kaep fizzled out, should have kept Alex

No he lost his job because Kap came in and played better. Alex went on to hold another SB roster back until they also dumped him. No thanks

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

Originally posted by 9moon:

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:
It isn't the wishful thinking that's the problem. It's a the LUDICROUS notion that Brock isn't worth MULTIPLE first round picks, let alone not even one.

I don't think that's a ludicrous notion. Every team scouted him as a udfa a year ago. He played at an extreme high level for short duration, on a loaded team. His throw arm is now jacked. I think many teams wouldn't even touch, thanks to the injury question, let alone part with a first, let alone part with multiple ones. The injury needs clarity.

Honestly, other than the injury, that same attitude is why people thought Mahomes would be a third round project: people don't trust their eyes. It's not like his success was because no one had ever seen the zone-read before. He had success playing standard QB. Worst case scenario he'll be an average starter, and a starting QB who has played at least half a season is worth at least a one. Let alone a guy who played at a very high level for basically half a season.

He had the same team as Jimmy and outplayed him. Jimmy, who we got for a second after two games of play. And Brock does not have the weakness Jimmy does (mediocre vision and improvisation).

Not to mention, his value to the 49ers. He is why Jimmy was let go. There is not a chance the 49ers will embrace uncertainty at the position without at least two firsts.

Brock is at minimum worth a one, and given the 49ers situation without him (uncertainty as t the QB position), he's going nowhere without two firsts round picks at minimum.

BROCK has only played 7 games? as much as he played very well, there is no way you can say he's better than Grappy already..

I knew Mahomes was better than Jimmy before he was drafted, so yeah, I can. Brock stepped into the same team and that same team produced ten more points per game. Moreover, one of the main reasons why the team scored more points is because Purdy repeatedly saw people open that Jimmy never would have even looked at.

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by Waterbear:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by Montana:

Nothing small sample size about BCB imo. Lolol. The only reason BCB is not the long term guy rn is obviously his injury. Trey would defo been a backup. I bet anything we would have won against Philly had there not been such a cluster cluck of events. And a Mahomes/Brock showdown would have been awesome. So damn close.

The only reason why he isn't the clear #1 is because of his injury. His play last year earned the right to be QB1, but his injury changes that.

Until Sam or Trey prove to be better the injury hasn't changed anything

If Purdy can't throw a football, he is still QB1?

Is Brock your brother? Son? Not everything people say about Purdy that isn't rainbows and sunshine is a slight dude. I am just as big a Purdy fan as you are. I just like to live in reality.

If he can't throw a football to start the season a backup will play until QB1 is ready. If said backup plays better than Brock did he will earn the QB1 job.

When has a player ever been demoted by injury alone? They have to get Wally Pipped to lose their spot. You're acting like that has already happened, which isn't reality

.

Our offense scored more points and gained more yards with Kap than Alex. Alex's injury only opened the door, it's not the reason he lost the job

Alex still lost his job due to injury

the way Kaep fizzled out, should have kept Alex

No he lost his job because Kap came in and played better. Alex went on to hold another SB roster back until they also dumped him. No thanks

No ? If Alex didn't get injured, no Kaep. there's no way around it