Coaches Film Analysis: 2017 Season

Originally posted by AlexCat49er:

Originally posted by Niners816:


Here you go.....compliments of thl408. This is what a slant-flat looks like when the LBer interferes with the Z receiver. The DPI was so bad that the Z had to adjust his slant.

The refs, people paid to make these calls for a living, disagreed.

Originally posted by AlexCat49er:

Originally posted by jonnydel:
You didn't respond to my re: the league rulebook on OPI. I have seen nothing about the league backing the OPI call.....link? Anyone other than, "top beat write......"I'm sorry, I can't finish that sentence because the absurdity reaches levels I can't even repeat.....

I don't have time to dig up some dusty tome with all of the archaic rules of the NFL, but I'm pretty sure WRs can't go around shoving down every defender they please, especially if they're doing so to free up another receiver to catch the ball. I haven't watched the play since I saw it live, but it was clear as day OPI.

Originally posted by defenderDX:

Originally posted by AlexCat49er:

Originally posted by jonnydel:
You didn't respond to my re: the league rulebook on OPI. I have seen nothing about the league backing the OPI call.....link? Anyone other than, "top beat write......"I'm sorry, I can't finish that sentence because the absurdity reaches levels I can't even repeat.....

I don't have time to dig up some dusty tome with all of the archaic rules of the NFL, but I'm pretty sure WRs can't go around shoving down every defender they please, especially if they're doing so to free up another receiver to catch the ball. I haven't watched the play since I saw it live, but it was clear as day OPI.

are you a 49er fan?

Originally posted by defenderDX:
are you a 49er fan?

Originally posted by AlexCat49er:

Originally posted by defenderDX:
are you a 49er fan?

I'm probably the biggest 49er fan here, which isn't to say that everyone else here isn't a big 49er fan. I think everyone on these forums loves the 49ers, but that shouldn't unquestioning loyalty to the people running the team. You can be a loyal American and dislike the president, you can be a loyal 49er fan and hate everything that they're doing.

Originally posted by Thorhawk:

Originally posted by AlexCat49er:

Originally posted by defenderDX:

are you a 49er fan?

I'm probably the biggest 49er fan here, which isn't to say that everyone else here isn't a big 49er fan. I think everyone on these forums loves the 49ers, but that shouldn't unquestioning loyalty to the people running the team. You can be a loyal American and dislike the president, you can be a loyal 49er fan and hate everything that they're doing.

I certainly have my doubts

Originally posted by AlexCat49er:

Originally posted by defenderDX:
are you a 49er fan?

I'm probably the biggest 49er fan here, which isn't to say that everyone else here isn't a big 49er fan. I think everyone on these forums loves the 49ers, but that shouldn't involve unquestioning loyalty to the people running the team. You can be a loyal American and dislike the president, you can be a loyal 49er fan and hate everything that they're doing.

Originally posted by swoosh6996:

Originally posted by AlexCat49er:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

so who else besides , sus, cc, 9re, chz , ital ?

You don't consider the officials that are paid to officiate experts? Mike Pereira is in the media now because he was no good at his job, but the officials who made the call (correctly) considered it to be OPI and the league has backed them up on it.

Also, the top beat-writer for the 49ers, Grant Cohn, also said it was OPI.

Originally posted by defenderDX:

Originally posted by AlexCat49er:

Originally posted by defenderDX:

are you a 49er fan?

I'm probably the biggest 49er fan here, which isn't to say that everyone else here isn't a big 49er fan. I think everyone on these forums loves the 49ers, but that shouldn't involve unquestioning loyalty to the people running the team. You can be a loyal American and dislike the president, you can be a loyal 49er fan and hate everything that they're doing.

sorry, but im a fan and also quite critical myself. and the fact you spew b******t claiming "9 out of 10" experts say that was the right call is b******t in itself. still have yet to provide any sources. so yeah, you dont sound like much of a fan and more of a troll. but no need to get personal.

Originally posted by NCommand:

This guy was saying Bo was having a great game while he had just given up a TD in coverage and was missing two keys tackles on another drive.

It's safe to say he doesn't watch football?

Originally posted by defenderDX:

sorry, but im a fan and also quite critical myself. and the fact you spew b******t claiming "9 out of 10" experts say that was the right call is b******t in itself. still have yet to provide any sources. so yeah, you dont sound like much of a fan and more of a troll. but no need to get personal.

Originally posted by AlexCat49er:

Originally posted by NCommand:

This guy was saying Bo was having a great game while he had just given up a TD in coverage and was missing two keys tackles on another drive.

It's safe to say he doesn't watch football?

You mean the game where Bow led all players in tackles after only being signed 3 days ago?

Originally posted by AlexCat49er:

How many sources do you need? The officials on the field thought it was the right call, the league office agreed with them, and our most knowledgeable beat-writer also agreed. I tabulated the ratio of actual experts (no has beens like Mike Pereira in my list sorry) and it came out to be around 9/10 (actual number is 86%).

Originally posted by AlexCat49er:
I'm probably the biggest 49er fan here, which isn't to say that everyone else here isn't a big 49er fan. I think everyone on these forums loves the 49ers, but that shouldn't involve unquestioning loyalty to the people running the team. You can be a loyal American and dislike the president, you can be a loyal 49er fan and hate everything that they're doing.