There are 190 users in the forums

"The Joe Show" - Joe Staley Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online ⇨
Originally posted by NinerPrideinNJ:
Maybe he and McGlinchey should stop all the ass grabbing and Disney singing and start working on technique again.

Sad when Skule and Bruns played like the first rounders against far better fronts

The sad part is Skule and Bruns had the entire line playing better in the games they were gone than in the games Staley and Joe played in earlier in the year.

It's tough because it's not just individual components on the line but how they work together. If Staley and mglintch both suck we should expect the entire rest of the line to play bad also. :/
Staley has always been overrated in my opinion. And as an ND fan I wasn't a big fan of Mcglinchy either. It's very telling that some late round and un-drafted players have outperformed them.
[ Edited by Irish40Niner on Nov 13, 2019 at 6:46 AM ]
  • Kyzen
  • Member
  • Posts: 3,117
Need to change the name of this thread to "Joe has to go show".
Staley looked like a rookie out there.
  • mayo49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 48,118
Originally posted by Kyzen:
Need to change the name of this thread to "Joe has to go show".

Amen.
Originally posted by Kyzen:
Need to change the name of this thread to "Joe has to go show".

You guys are ridiculous.

He had a bad game after being out of action for a long time. I didn't see what part of the game he hurt his finger, playing injured could've made the rust even worse.

He's one of our best players and a great guy. Shame on everyone talking chit about the guy for a poor game.
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by Kyzen:
Need to change the name of this thread to "Joe has to go show".

You guys are ridiculous.

He had a bad game after being out of action for a long time. I didn't see what part of the game he hurt his finger, playing injured could've made the rust even worse.

He's one of our best players and a great guy. Shame on everyone talking chit about the guy for a poor game.

He's getting outplayed by Skule. At what point do you go with the younger hot-hand? After Jimmy get's destroyed and our run game is obsolete?
  • jcs
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 31,563
Originally posted by Irish40Niner:
Staley has always been overrated in my opinion. And as an ND fan I wasn't a big fan of Mcglinchy either. It's very telling that some late round and un-drafted players have outperformed them.

So your saying that 3x all pro and 6x probowl OT Joe staley is overrated?

Originally posted by jcs:
So your saying that 3x all pro and 6x probowl OT Joe staley is overrated?


No, we are saying he's not the same player he once was, and was outplayed by undrafted and late round draft picks. That's the point. His time may have passed; he hasn't been the same the last couple of years, actually.
Originally posted by Scottie15:
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by Kyzen:
Need to change the name of this thread to "Joe has to go show".

You guys are ridiculous.

He had a bad game after being out of action for a long time. I didn't see what part of the game he hurt his finger, playing injured could've made the rust even worse.

He's one of our best players and a great guy. Shame on everyone talking chit about the guy for a poor game.

He's getting outplayed by Skule. At what point do you go with the younger hot-hand? After Jimmy get's destroyed and our run game is obsolete?

He's not getting outplayed by Skule in the same game. Clowney was in rare form this game and Joe was coming back from a long absence. If you feel more confident with Skule squaring up vs Chandler Jones then I'm not sure what to say to you.

Ya'll folks crying and overreacting realize Staley hasnt played since week f**king 2 and in his 1st game back got matched up against jadaveon clowney, not no damn cassius marsh
  • Rascal
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 13,170
Originally posted by MBNINER90266:
Originally posted by jcs:
So your saying that 3x all pro and 6x probowl OT Joe staley is overrated?


No, we are saying he's not the same player he once was, and was outplayed by undrafted and late round draft picks. That's the point. His time may have passed; he hasn't been the same the last couple of years, actually.

I would go one step further, may be is time for Joe to retire. You cannot defeat father time.

But, I would agree with the original comment that McGlinchey is overrated though.

Either way, we can't field an O-line like we did in that Seahawks game. If backups are playing better, then we will have to field them.
Originally posted by jcs:
So your saying that 3x all pro and 6x probowl OT Joe staley is overrated?


I am saying exactly that. He was a good player for awhile, but has been overrated for quite some time. You can't live off of past reputation forever... It's time to start looking for his replacement.
Speedy recovery Staley! Rest up & get ready for the playoff run
Originally posted by Irish40Niner:
Originally posted by jcs:
So your saying that 3x all pro and 6x probowl OT Joe staley is overrated?


I am saying exactly that. He was a good player for awhile, but has been overrated for quite some time. You can't live off of past reputation forever... It's time to start looking for his replacement.
this gonna replace the Alex thread?
Share 49erswebzone