Luck or Kaepernick?

I really think Harbaugh would pick Kaepernick. He really believed in him and had big plans. It's too bad he couldn't build the team he wanted. I had my full trust with Harbaugh and I was very confident that he could've assembled a heck of a team with the players that bought in to his system.

Everyone saying give Luck our Defense, well give Kap the AFC North and TY Hilton, Reggie Wayne and that OL.

Originally posted by gold49digger:
Luck in the regular season, kap in the playoffs.

That works too.

seriously, let Kaep play the way he can and then lets do the comparison.

Originally posted by titan:
I really think Harbaugh would pick Kaepernick. He really believed in him and had big plans. It's too bad he couldn't build the team he wanted. I had my full trust with Harbaugh and I was very confident that he could've assembled a heck of a team with the players that bought in to his system.

then why didn't he do that over the last two years? seriously, i think harbaugh had reached the peak of what he could do w/ the team. he was figured out.

Originally posted by deepniner:

Originally posted by titan:

I really think Harbaugh would pick Kaepernick. He really believed in him and had big plans. It's too bad he couldn't build the team he wanted. I had my full trust with Harbaugh and I was very confident that he could've assembled a heck of a team with the players that bought in to his system.

then why didn't he do that over the last two years? seriously, i think harbaugh had reached the peak of what he could do w/ the team. he was figured out.

Why didn't Harbaugh assemble the team that he wants? Where have you been this entire time during the power struggle for control?This year we were devastated with injuries and suspensions along with ridiculous media controversy. Other than not winning the SB Harbaugh and the entire coaching staff have been outstanding. The passing may have taken a step back, but that is also due to some cry babies in the OL,WR and TE position. But since Harbaugh and Kaep are such a terrible combo...Now we can enjoy the Baalke and Tomsula show. I hope I am wrong, but I have a feeling I will be really annoyed paying for my DirectTV this next several years.

Originally posted by LisaTwelve:

Correction, CK has 'out-rushed' RW and AL in the playoffs.
As for passing in the postseason . . .

QB - record - rating - TD/INT - Y/A
CK ....4-2 .......87.3 ......7/5 .....8.48
AL ....3-3 .......70.8 ......9/12 ....7.03
RW ...6-1 .......96.3 .....10/5 .....8.69

How many road wins? 1, correct.. And how many wins without the #1 defense and lynch with #1 rushing.

Originally posted by VDpwndMjenkins:

How bout you throw their rushing numbers up there as well?? I think when he said "outplayed", he was looking at total production. If after doing so, Frodo's numbers are still better, so be it, no problem.

Originally posted by jeepzilla:

Originally posted by LisaTwelve:

Correction, CK has 'out-rushed' RW and AL in the playoffs.
As for passing in the postseason . . .

QB - record - rating - TD/INT - Y/A
CK ....4-2 .......87.3 ......7/5 .....8.48
AL ....3-3 .......70.8 ......9/12 ....7.03
RW ...6-1 .......96.3 .....10/5 .....8.69

How many road wins? 1, correct.. And how many wins without the #1 defense and lynch with #1 rushing.

Originally posted by VDpwndMjenkins:

How bout you throw their rushing numbers up there as well?? I think when he said "outplayed", he was looking at total production. If after doing so, Frodo's numbers are still better, so be it, no problem.

You can't punish a guy for not needing to play on the road. If anything it means they are doing better during the regular season. while Wilson had the #1 D, Kap had the #2...that argument is a wash.

Originally posted by jreff22:
You can't punish a guy for not needing to play on the road. If anything it means they are doing better during the regular season. while Wilson had the #1 D, Kap had the #2...that argument is a wash.

Thanks - that's what I was going to reply

Originally posted by jreff22:

Originally posted by jeepzilla:

Originally posted by LisaTwelve:
Correction, CK has 'out-rushed' RW and AL in the playoffs.
As for passing in the postseason . . .

QB - record - rating - TD/INT - Y/A
CK ....4-2 .......87.3 ......7/5 .....8.48
AL ....3-3 .......70.8 ......9/12 ....7.03
RW ...6-1 .......96.3 .....10/5 .....8.69

How many road wins? 1, correct.. And how many wins without the #1 defense and lynch with #1 rushing.

Originally posted by VDpwndMjenkins:
How bout you throw their rushing numbers up there as well?? I think when he said "outplayed", he was looking at total production. If after doing so, Frodo's numbers are still better, so be it, no problem.

You can't punish a guy for not needing to play on the road. If anything it means they are doing better during the regular season. while Wilson had the #1 D, Kap had the #2...that argument is a wash.

Originally posted by LisaTwelve:
Thanks - that's what I was going to reply

But no reply to what I asked though??

Originally posted by VDpwndMjenkins:
But no reply to what I asked though??

I already said in my original post that Kap out-rushed them . . .

but, here are the total yards: AL = 1971, CK = 1881, RW = 1789