Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 577 users in the forums

2017 QB draft class

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Falk has thrown for 70 attempts twice and has only came away with only one INT. So I'm going with the QB who makes better decisions and more of them, in terms of reads or progressions.

And it's not just me saying these things like he stares down reads, it's other websites too, it's funny how I only get accused of this.

I'm not accusing you I've just seen him go through progressions. I like Falk as well and have no problem drafting him (I do think Watson is more pro ready) I hate waiting on a position because you think someone you prefer might be there lower in the draft.

There's 32 teams drafting and we have no idea who they want...your rolling the dice on waiting on qb IMO.

All it takes is one team that thinks he's a 1st rd pick and he's gone.

I'd rather draft BPA in the first and give NE our 2nd for Jimmy G and be done with it.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Falk has thrown for 70 attempts twice and has only came away with only one INT. So I'm going with the QB who makes better decisions and more of them, in terms of reads or progressions.

And it's not just me saying these things like he stares down reads, it's other websites too, it's funny how I only get accused of this.

I'm not accusing you I've just seen him go through progressions. I like Falk as well and have no problem drafting him (I do think Watson is more pro ready) I hate waiting on a position because you think someone you prefer might be there lower in the draft.

There's 32 teams drafting and we have no idea who they want...your rolling the dice on waiting on qb IMO.

All it takes is one team that thinks he's a 1st rd pick and he's gone.

I'd rather draft BPA in the first and give NE our 2nd for Jimmy G and be done with it.

I'm fairly unimpressed with many of the QBs listed at the top early this year. Guys like Falk, Trubisky and Mahomes seem to be really interesting prospects. Watson (27-13; 387-3077) has twice the interceptions on half the throws as Falk (33-6; 479-3610) and Mahomes (34-8; 509-4247); and similar attempts as Trubisky (22-4; 350-3004). Stats = TD-Int & Att-Yds. Kizer has 22 TDs, 8 Ints; 296-2470.

Obviously this will look different by years end and it doesn't necessarily correlate with wins and losses, but I particularly like the TD/Int ratio. But quality of OLs, WRs, RBs...so many variables to consider!
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
I'm fairly unimpressed with many of the QBs listed at the top early this year. Guys like Falk, Trubisky and Mahomes seem to be really interesting prospects. Watson (27-13; 387-3077) has twice the interceptions on half the throws as Falk (33-6; 479-3610) and Mahomes (34-8; 509-4247); and similar attempts as Trubisky (22-4; 350-3004). Stats = TD-Int & Att-Yds. Kizer has 22 TDs, 8 Ints; 296-2470.

Obviously this will look different by years end and it doesn't necessarily correlate with wins and losses, but I particularly like the TD/Int ratio. But quality of OLs, WRs, RBs...so many variables to consider!

Good stuff! I'd have to add in level of constant competition.

I'd also throw in systems as well...look at leach's old qbs and the stats they put up.

I mean Graham Harrell had over 15,600 yards 134 TDs and only 34 INTs and didn't amount to anything in the NFL.
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
I'm fairly unimpressed with many of the QBs listed at the top early this year. Guys like Falk, Trubisky and Mahomes seem to be really interesting prospects. Watson (27-13; 387-3077) has twice the interceptions on half the throws as Falk (33-6; 479-3610) and Mahomes (34-8; 509-4247); and similar attempts as Trubisky (22-4; 350-3004). Stats = TD-Int & Att-Yds. Kizer has 22 TDs, 8 Ints; 296-2470.

Obviously this will look different by years end and it doesn't necessarily correlate with wins and losses, but I particularly like the TD/Int ratio. But quality of OLs, WRs, RBs...so many variables to consider!

Good stuff! I'd have to add in level of constant competition.

I'd also throw in systems as well...look at leach's old qbs and the stats they put up.

I mean Graham Harrell had over 15,600 yards 134 TDs and only 34 INTs and didn't amount to anything in the NFL.

Just curios but what QB's have Dabo Swinney ever been successful in the NFL?

I also think we can throw out the "level of competition" credential, that bares hardly any measure on how a QB will translate to the next level or else Ken Dorsey and Craig Krenzel would've been hall of famers.

And let's not bring Graham Harrell into the discussion, he would've been a 7th round pick at best in ANY system. Why doesn't anyone use Jared Goff in the argument when talking about the Air Raid, after Sonny Dykes was a OC in that system, then again he's a question mark right now in the NFL.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Just curios but what QB's have Dabo Swinney ever been successful in the NFL?

I also think we can throw out the "level of competition" credential, that bares hardly any measure on how a QB will translate to the next level or else Ken Dorsey and Craig Krenzel would've been hall of famers.

And let's not bring Graham Harrell into the discussion, he would've been a 7th round pick at best in ANY system. Why doesn't anyone use Jared Goff in the argument when talking about the Air Raid, after Sonny Dykes was a OC in that system, then again he's a question mark right now in the NFL.

He had Boyd and Chad Kelly for a hot min he's been the HC since 2009...level comp can be thrown out? Stop that. Then I guess we can say every qb in division II or the MAC that's throwing up crazy stats is legit.

Why does Graham get thrown out especially when the poster I was talking to brought up stats? He completed 70% of his passes, never threw INTs, had have two 5000+ passing seasons with another 4500+ season under leach.

I'm not saying falk is awful or anything but it's hard to evaluate someone coming out of that offense.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Just curios but what QB's have Dabo Swinney ever been successful in the NFL?

I also think we can throw out the "level of competition" credential, that bares hardly any measure on how a QB will translate to the next level or else Ken Dorsey and Craig Krenzel would've been hall of famers.

And let's not bring Graham Harrell into the discussion, he would've been a 7th round pick at best in ANY system. Why doesn't anyone use Jared Goff in the argument when talking about the Air Raid, after Sonny Dykes was a OC in that system, then again he's a question mark right now in the NFL.

He had Boyd and Chad Kelly for a hot min he's been the HC since 2009...level comp can be thrown out? Stop that. Then I guess we can say every qb in division II or the MAC that's throwing up crazy stats is legit.

Why does Graham get thrown out especially when the poster I was talking to brought up stats? He completed 70% of his passes, never threw INTs, had have two 5000+ passing seasons with another 4500+ season under leach.

I'm not saying falk is awful or anything but it's hard to evaluate someone coming out of that offense.

With a guy like Harrell you have to take the scheme into account. Cody Hodges set records at TTech with Harrell as his back up and then the latter took over for Hodges as a sophomore. So you look at Hodges and see that he played for the Fort Wayne Fusion and realize that all record setters are not equal. Remember Sonny Cumbie? He was the third straight QB to lead the nation in yardage for Leach's TTech team in 2004.

So context is important...as we all agree.

Edit: This might make me nervous about Falk...another Leach QB.
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Nov 17, 2016 at 6:04 PM ]
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
With a guy like Harrell you have to take the scheme into account. Cody Hodges set records at TTech with Harrell as his back up and then the latter took over for Hodges as a sophomore. So you look at Hodges and see that he played for the Fort Wayne Fusion and realize that all record setters are not equal. Remember Sonny Cumbie? He was the third straight QB to lead the nation in yardage for Leach's TTech team in 2004.

So context is important...as we all agree.

Edit: This might make me nervous about Falk...another Leach QB.

That's my whole point
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Good stuff! I'd have to add in level of constant competition.

I'd also throw in systems as well...look at leach's old qbs and the stats they put up.

I mean Graham Harrell had over 15,600 yards 134 TDs and only 34 INTs and didn't amount to anything in the NFL.

Harrell was also undrafted, so he did about as well as expected.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
He had Boyd and Chad Kelly for a hot min he's been the HC since 2009...level comp can be thrown out? Stop that. Then I guess we can say every qb in division II or the MAC that's throwing up crazy stats is legit.

Why does Graham get thrown out especially when the poster I was talking to brought up stats? He completed 70% of his passes, never threw INTs, had have two 5000+ passing seasons with another 4500+ season under leach.

I'm not saying falk is awful or anything but it's hard to evaluate someone coming out of that offense.


There's a reason why Goff went #1 overall coming out of an Air Raid offense and Harrell went undrafted. NFL scouts largely don't pay attention to passing stats for QB's as much they look for traits that can help that guy become successful at the next level. Being successful at the college level is largely irrelevant if it doesn't translate well to the next level.


Falk and Harrell are world's apart in terms of their overall talent and skillset.
[ Edited by Phoenix49ers on Nov 17, 2016 at 6:17 PM ]
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Harrell was also undrafted, so he did about as well as expected.

And the previous poster brought up stats hence why I brought up his stats...I'm not saying Harrell was good but he played in a offense that could pump up his stats. Much like falk and goff...I'm not saying neither of them could turn out to be FQB.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Falk has thrown for 70 attempts twice and has only came away with only one INT. So I'm going with the QB who makes better decisions and more of them, in terms of reads or progressions.

And it's not just me saying these things like he stares down reads, it's other websites too, it's funny how I only get accused of this.

You honestly know nothing about Leach's system or the concept of reading defenses if you are holding Falk up as some example of going through progressions. His Air Raid is as simple and one read as it gets in football.
[ Edited by TheBlueHell on Nov 17, 2016 at 6:22 PM ]
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
There's a reason why Goff went #1 overall coming out of an Air Raid offense and Harrell went undrafted. NFL scouts largely don't pay attention to passing stats for QB's as much they look for traits that can help that guy become successful at the next level. Being successful at the college level is largely irrelevant if it doesn't translate well to the next level.


Falk and Harrell are world's apart in terms of their overall talent and skillset.

Not as much to do with how many yards as the INT to pass attempts ratio that dtg was bringing up. That's another reason I brought up Harrell in leach's system
chip uses plenty of air raid concepts himself. nothing wrong with it.
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Just curios but what QB's have Dabo Swinney ever been successful in the NFL?

I also think we can throw out the "level of competition" credential, that bares hardly any measure on how a QB will translate to the next level or else Ken Dorsey and Craig Krenzel would've been hall of famers.

And let's not bring Graham Harrell into the discussion, he would've been a 7th round pick at best in ANY system. Why doesn't anyone use Jared Goff in the argument when talking about the Air Raid, after Sonny Dykes was a OC in that system, then again he's a question mark right now in the NFL.

He had Boyd and Chad Kelly for a hot min he's been the HC since 2009...level comp can be thrown out? Stop that. Then I guess we can say every qb in division II or the MAC that's throwing up crazy stats is legit.

Why does Graham get thrown out especially when the poster I was talking to brought up stats? He completed 70% of his passes, never threw INTs, had have two 5000+ passing seasons with another 4500+ season under leach.

I'm not saying falk is awful or anything but it's hard to evaluate someone coming out of that offense.

Taj Boyd has done squat at the NFL level and Chad Kelly was hardly involved with anything to do with Dabo Swinney. BTW I asked what QB from Swinney has had success in the NFL, the simple answer that people refuse to say is simple.....none.

And yes, let's throw out level of competition, I mean if that's the case then why didn't AJ McArron, Landry Jones and Aaron Murray become 1st and 2nd round picks? And why did Ben Roethelisberger, Carson Wentz and Blake Bortles become top 10 picks if level of competition has so much importance in a prospects stock?

Why does Graham get thrown out, well take away the Air Raid offense that he came from, look at his arm strength, physical stature, mobility and Passes that would translate to NFL accuracy? He just doesn't score high in any of those categories or traits. Honestly, Graham compares to Ken Dorsey more than he does to any 1st round QB or even 2nd round for that matter.
Originally posted by TheBlueHell:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Falk has thrown for 70 attempts twice and has only came away with only one INT. So I'm going with the QB who makes better decisions and more of them, in terms of reads or progressions.

And it's not just me saying these things like he stares down reads, it's other websites too, it's funny how I only get accused of this.

You honestly know nothing about Leach's system or the concept of reading defenses if you are holding Falk up as some example of going through progressions. His Air Raid is as simple and one read as it gets in football.

The "if you don't agree with me, you know nothing," argument needs to go away. Falk goes through progressions with his eyes; you can see that much by watching him. IDK if he's reading the routes or the coverage, but he's reading something, and he frequently moves from covered routes to open ones. Are his passing windows big a lot of the time? Yes. Does he throw to his 1st read, based on presnap alignment? Yes, often. Does he move off of that read if the look changes after the snap? Yes, often.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone