Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 619 users in the forums

2017 QB draft class

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
That's why I emphasised impact players. Garrett is likely the best percentage to be an elite guy, but after that they even out. So if they don't get Garrett and Kelly likes a QB who will be around in the second they are clear to trade back and still get quality with quantity. We always have to keep in mind that QBs tend to rise as the draft approaches so a guy like Kizer listed at 31st might be mid-first.

My whole premise regarding trades is to get high quality in a position of need rather than, for instance, another safety with #2 in the first round. Getting the best ILB and a top NT would really help this defense and really is necessary going forward.

My issue is outside of Garrett who are these teams moving up for? who are they gonna give up high end picks for so that we can move down? We need impact players more than any other team and if there is one we should draft them instead of move down IMO.

And the whole wait until the 2nd rd for a QB is great in theory, but you don't know if they will be there when your picking.

I hope whomever is our GM does some wheeling and dealing to get the players we want I just don't want to see another 10 players drafted I would be more than fine with them getting 5 GOOD players and get some vets.
Originally posted by LVJay:
Yup... we're already loaded with depth (2nd / 3rd string talent) and we need (badly) solid, day-one starters via draft and FA.

exactly...I'd rather move up to 1 and get Garrett if need be.
Originally posted by DaveWilcox:
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
There will be a lot of studs in the top 2 rounds. Loading up on #2s in this draft wouldn't be a bad idea. any #3s could be used to move ahead from a @ we acquired. Getting Foster, Davis/Ross, Falk, Butt, Fields would be insane. I could spend day 3 of the draft without panic and rage, for once.

Loading up on 2's with Baalke calling the shots is a bad plan.. he would draft medical redshirts and CBs that will be cut later

Your guy Falk could go in the 2nd, and I think that'd be a hell of a pick. Just hope enough teams tell the draft advisory board they'd take him in the first, so he comes out.
Falk is going to be a mid 1st rounder by the time the draft rolls around if he declares. He has size, production, intelligence and intangibles.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
My issue is outside of Garrett who are these teams moving up for? who are they gonna give up high end picks for so that we can move down? We need impact players more than any other team and if there is one we should draft them instead of move down IMO.

And the whole wait until the 2nd rd for a QB is great in theory, but you don't know if they will be there when your picking.

I hope whomever is our GM does some wheeling and dealing to get the players we want I just don't want to see another 10 players drafted I would be more than fine with them getting 5 GOOD players and get some vets.

Depending on needs, Peppers is considered perhaps the best all around athlete/football player in the draft. The niners don't need a safety/OLB tweener as much as they need LBs and a QB so it would be logical to trade out of the 2nd or 3rd spot if Peppers is listed in the top three. Jonathan Allen is listed by CBS at #1 currently and the niners do not need a DE as much as these other positions. Humphrey is currently the top CB and some drafts have the niners taking a CB high, but that would be a luxury pick in my opinion.

Of the top ten players on CBS's chart I see the niners taking only a few of these guys with the second pick...and they could trade back to get a couple. Trubisky, Fournette, and Garrett are elite players the niners could use, with Fournette being a bit of a luxury as well. Let me add Mike Williams to that list as he has popped up to #10. So the order I would set if Kelly likes all these guys equally:

  1. OLB Garrett
  2. QB Trubisky
  3. RB Fournette
  4. WR Williams

Why? There are more good QBs in this draft than OLB pass rushers. RB and WR are secondary needs at this point. The problem analyzing drafts is that you can't know how Kelly/Baalke see these guys. Kelly might like Falk more than any other QB in the draft and so would wait until the second round to draft him, taking whoever is left from the other three in the first.

But are any of the luxury picks elite enough to ignore trade back possibilities? I doubt it. Getting an ILB, OLB, QB, and WR seem like really high priorities this year. Free agency might change this list considerably! Most likely positions to find a FA? ILB, WR and then OLB. Few quality QBs available.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Depending on needs, Peppers is considered perhaps the best all around athlete/football player in the draft. The niners don't need a safety/OLB tweener as much as they need LBs and a QB so it would be logical to trade out of the 2nd or 3rd spot if Peppers is listed in the top three. Jonathan Allen is listed by CBS at #1 currently and the niners do not need a DE as much as these other positions. Humphrey is currently the top CB and some drafts have the niners taking a CB high, but that would be a luxury pick in my opinion.

Of the top ten players on CBS's chart I see the niners taking only a few of these guys with the second pick...and they could trade back to get a couple. Trubisky, Fournette, and Garrett are elite players the niners could use, with Fournette being a bit of a luxury as well. Let me add Mike Williams to that list as he has popped up to #10. So the order I would set if Kelly likes all these guys equally:

  1. OLB Garrett
  2. QB Trubisky
  3. RB Fournette
  4. WR Williams

Why? There are more good QBs in this draft than OLB pass rushers. RB and WR are secondary needs at this point. The problem analyzing drafts is that you can't know how Kelly/Baalke see these guys. Kelly might like Falk more than any other QB in the draft and so would wait until the second round to draft him, taking whoever is left from the other three in the first.

But are any of the luxury picks elite enough to ignore trade back possibilities? I doubt it. Getting an ILB, OLB, QB, and WR seem like really high priorities this year. Free agency might change this list considerably! Most likely positions to find a FA? ILB, WR and then OLB. Few quality QBs available.

I think there are better pass rushers then qbs in this draft to be honest...and like I said I don't see a team moving up for any of these players in the top 3...I'd love a trade down if Myles is gone but I just don't see teams throwing away a bunch of picks to move up for any of these guys just don't as of right now.

I'd rather move up for Garrett if need be, trade our 2nd for Jimmy G and hit up FA.
[ Edited by NYniner85 on Nov 17, 2016 at 9:01 AM ]
  • okdkid
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 23,729
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Depending on needs, Peppers is considered perhaps the best all around athlete/football player in the draft. The niners don't need a safety/OLB tweener as much as they need LBs and a QB so it would be logical to trade out of the 2nd or 3rd spot if Peppers is listed in the top three. Jonathan Allen is listed by CBS at #1 currently and the niners do not need a DE as much as these other positions. Humphrey is currently the top CB and some drafts have the niners taking a CB high, but that would be a luxury pick in my opinion.

Of the top ten players on CBS's chart I see the niners taking only a few of these guys with the second pick...and they could trade back to get a couple. Trubisky, Fournette, and Garrett are elite players the niners could use, with Fournette being a bit of a luxury as well. Let me add Mike Williams to that list as he has popped up to #10. So the order I would set if Kelly likes all these guys equally:

  1. OLB Garrett
  2. QB Trubisky
  3. RB Fournette
  4. WR Williams
Why? There are more good QBs in this draft than OLB pass rushers. RB and WR are secondary needs at this point. The problem analyzing drafts is that you can't know how Kelly/Baalke see these guys. Kelly might like Falk more than any other QB in the draft and so would wait until the second round to draft him, taking whoever is left from the other three in the first.

But are any of the luxury picks elite enough to ignore trade back possibilities? I doubt it. Getting an ILB, OLB, QB, and WR seem like really high priorities this year. Free agency might change this list considerably! Most likely positions to find a FA? ILB, WR and then OLB. Few quality QBs available.

I like Trubisky. I think he's the top QB in the draft. But I wouldn't call him an "elite" prospect. And certainly not in the same tier as Myles Garrett or Leonard Fournette.
Originally posted by okdkid:
I like Trubisky. I think he's the top QB in the draft. But I wouldn't call him an "elite" prospect. And certainly not in the same tier as Myles Garrett or Leonard Fournette.

So who you taking if we are sitting there say at 3?
Originally posted by okdkid:
I like Trubisky. I think he's the top QB in the draft. But I wouldn't call him an "elite" prospect. And certainly not in the same tier as Myles Garrett or Leonard Fournette.

The key is...the niners need a FQB. They may need a RB as well but not as much. So if Trubisky is much better than any other QB for Kelly's system...they take him. If, on the other hand, Trubisky, Kizer, Watson, Falk, Mahomes, etc. are all deemed as project QBs then you take BPA in the first and grab whoever falls in the second. This is why I mentioned the trade potential of a #2 or #3 pick. Perhaps Foster+Falk are a much better value than Fournette alone. Fun to consider!
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
The key is...the niners need a FQB. They may need a RB as well but not as much. So if Trubisky is much better than any other QB for Kelly's system...they take him. If, on the other hand, Trubisky, Kizer, Watson, Falk, Mahomes, etc. are all deemed as project QBs then you take BPA in the first and grab whoever falls in the second. This is why I mentioned the trade potential of a #2 or #3 pick. Perhaps Foster+Falk are a much better value than Fournette alone. Fun to consider!

How about we move up if need be for Garrett and give up our 2nd for Jimmy G? There's are version of Mack/Carr
[ Edited by NYniner85 on Nov 17, 2016 at 10:59 AM ]
  • okdkid
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 23,729
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by okdkid:
I like Trubisky. I think he's the top QB in the draft. But I wouldn't call him an "elite" prospect. And certainly not in the same tier as Myles Garrett or Leonard Fournette.

So who you taking if we are sitting there say at 3?

It's hard to say since the formal evaluation period hasn't begun. That said, assuming Garrett is off the board I'd be very happy with Fournette or Allen. Maybe the top QB prospect this year makes it in the top 3. We'll see. Also, a trade down within the top 7-8 is appealing to me as well depending upon the haul. I'm just cautious of QB hype because it inevitably gets to be out of hand and Goff-like.

I believe there are many good 1st round QB prospects this year, but nobody "elite". I really don't mind taking one of the other "good" QB prospects in the late 1st while still getting an elite offensive or defensive playmaker in the top 3.
//
Originally posted by NYniner85:
How about we move up if need be for Garrett and give up our 2nd for Jimmy G? There's are version of Mack/Carr

If they fall in love with Garrett and find him to be that special pass rusher, ala Aldon Smith, then by all means jump! Not sure they know that though...all good fun to consider!
  • okdkid
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 23,729
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by okdkid:
I like Trubisky. I think he's the top QB in the draft. But I wouldn't call him an "elite" prospect. And certainly not in the same tier as Myles Garrett or Leonard Fournette.

The key is...the niners need a FQB. They may need a RB as well but not as much. So if Trubisky is much better than any other QB for Kelly's system...they take him. If, on the other hand, Trubisky, Kizer, Watson, Falk, Mahomes, etc. are all deemed as project QBs then you take BPA in the first and grab whoever falls in the second. This is why I mentioned the trade potential of a #2 or #3 pick. Perhaps Foster+Falk are a much better value than Fournette alone. Fun to consider!

Yeah man. Like I said -- I think Trubisky is a good prospect. But I much prefer a elite offensive or defensive playmaker + late 1st round QB combo.

Simply, I just don't think there is much separation amongst the top 3-4 QBs in this draft. I'm sure people will develop very passionate feelings for one QB or another. But they're all kinda just lumped together for the most part. Trubisky/Watson/Kizer/Falk/Mahomes. They're all alright, but not great.

However, there is no denying the existence of elite offensive and defensive playmakers in the top 10 of this draft. I say take one of those guys and make a move to get a QB in the late 1st.
Originally posted by okdkid:
It's hard to say since the formal evaluation period hasn't begun. That said, assuming Garrett is off the board I'd be very happy with Fournette or Allen. Maybe the top QB prospect this year makes it in the top 3. We'll see. Also, a trade down within the top 7-8 is appealing to me as well depending upon the haul. I'm just cautious of QB hype because it inevitably gets to be out of hand and Goff-like.

I believe there are many good 1st round QB prospects this year, but nobody "elite". I really don't mind taking one of the other "good" QB prospects in the late 1st while still getting an elite offensive or defensive playmaker in the top 3.

Yeah I think Allen is a monster but it would suck to throw him in as a NT. I just don't see many players that teams would move up for if we were looking at a trade down (unless we take much less then what our pick is worth).

IMO I want to roll out of this draft with like 5 players and maybe a future pick...no more 10+ developmental picks. We need impact players and I have no problem giving up picks for them.
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Agreed issue is if Garrett isn't there who do you take?? Allen is a monster but do we go DL 3 yrs in a row?

No, I think they either trade back and/or take a skill player...maybe Fournette or Mike Williams. But they should take Trubisky if he's there.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
There's no guarantees Trubisky will be a top 3 pick like there's no guarantees that Watson is a 1st or 2nd round pick . But no I don't take Tubisky at #3, I take Garrett or trade down for Mike Williams then take Falk.

I really don't get the infatuation, give me someone who will utilize the field instead of staring down targets with his laser rocket arm. Besides I've already said how I don't like how Watson turns the ball over a bit more for my liking.

We are on different ends when it comes to Watson so I get it ...I'd expect him to have a turnover if he's asked to throw the ball 70 times a game lol.

I don't see him staring down all his reads like your saying either. Yes when a good portion of his offense is based around quick reads with few progressions, I'd get it if he was looking at his 1st read too long.

If both falk and Watson were sitting there in the 2nd I'm all over Watson, who could come right in and run this offense (don't hate falk)

What do you do if you can't trade down from 3? Takes two to tango...

Falk has thrown for 70 attempts twice and has only came away with only one INT. So I'm going with the QB who makes better decisions and more of them, in terms of reads or progressions.

And it's not just me saying these things like he stares down reads, it's other websites too, it's funny how I only get accused of this.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone