49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 742 users in the forums

2017 QB draft class

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Taj Boyd has done squat at the NFL level and Chad Kelly was hardly involved with anything to do with Dabo Swinney. BTW I asked what QB from Swinney has had success in the NFL, the simple answer that people refuse to say is simple.....none.

And yes, let's throw out level of competition, I mean if that's the case then why didn't AJ McArron, Landry Jones and Aaron Murray become 1st and 2nd round picks? And why did Ben Roethelisberger, Carson Wentz and Blake Bortles become top 10 picks if level of competition has so much importance in a prospects stock?

Why does Graham get thrown out, well take away the Air Raid offense that he came from, look at his arm strength, physical stature, mobility and Passes that would translate to NFL accuracy? He just doesn't score high in any of those categories or traits. Honestly, Graham compares to Ken Dorsey more than he does to any 1st round QB or even 2nd round for that matter.

I simply said who has been his qbs that's all relax, I'm always gonna throw in level of competition for ANY prospect you don't have to but I will.

Once again the reason I brought up Graham was because dtg brought up stats about attempts vs INTs which someone WHO WAS in Leach's system (like falk) had very few of.

System does play a part when it comes to accuracy and INT vs TDs you complain about Watson not going through reads but what do you think the air raid offense is?
[ Edited by NYniner85 on Nov 18, 2016 at 6:29 AM ]
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by TheBlueHell:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Falk has thrown for 70 attempts twice and has only came away with only one INT. So I'm going with the QB who makes better decisions and more of them, in terms of reads or progressions.

And it's not just me saying these things like he stares down reads, it's other websites too, it's funny how I only get accused of this.

You honestly know nothing about Leach's system or the concept of reading defenses if you are holding Falk up as some example of going through progressions. His Air Raid is as simple and one read as it gets in football.

So now you're gonna tell me that single reads are much better than ANY reads in a Mike Leach system.....correct? And that you're more capable of throwing interceptions in a Swinney offense than a Leach offense....correct??

Luke Falk is flying under the radar mainly because he played on a below average Washington State team that hasn't warranted any national attention. Things are likely to change this year as the team is better overall, but mainly because Falk is an elite talent. The first thing that I noticed while watching Falk's tape is that Mike Leach's offense features more intermediate throws than the other spread systems in college football. Things like wide receiver screens and read-option are only a small part of the attack. This is important because it has given Falk the ability to attack over the middle, along the sideline and down the field. He also has plenty of opportunities to read the defense and go through progressions. Falk does a great job remaining balanced in the pocket, working across the field and tying his feet to his eyes when searching for an open target. Many college offenses ask the quarterback to make one read or just focus on one side of the field. The fact that Falk can work through his progressions is something that will help ease his transition to the NFL.

http://withthefirstpick.com/2016/05/05/2017-nfl-draft-washington-state-luke-falk-scouting-report/

Falk (6-foot-4, 216 pounds, per school measurements) stands tall in the pocket and has no problem seeing over the defensive line. Of all his positive attributes, the most important might be his poise. Falk doesn't rattle easily when the pocket gets noisy -- he plays with an unusual amount of patience. Falk rarely rushes his throws and is more than willing to wait for receivers running crossing routes to sail into the clear before throwing it their way. Falk does an excellent job of getting through his progressions and the tape shows he's willing to scan the entire field rather than just one half of it.

http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap3000000740209/article/dare-to-compare-nfl-comp-for-washington-state-qb-luke-falk

While the statistics are surely impressive, Falk also has the tape and intangibles to validate his status as a legit NFL QB prospect. Falk's best traits are his fantastic decision-making at the QB position and his ability to progress through multiple reads.

http://stillcurtain.com/2016/09/10/steelers-nfl-draft-watch-washington-state-qb-luke-falk/

Do I need to post more for you?
[ Edited by Kolohe on Nov 18, 2016 at 8:44 AM ]
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Taj Boyd has done squat at the NFL level and Chad Kelly was hardly involved with anything to do with Dabo Swinney. BTW I asked what QB from Swinney has had success in the NFL, the simple answer that people refuse to say is simple.....none.

And yes, let's throw out level of competition, I mean if that's the case then why didn't AJ McArron, Landry Jones and Aaron Murray become 1st and 2nd round picks? And why did Ben Roethelisberger, Carson Wentz and Blake Bortles become top 10 picks if level of competition has so much importance in a prospects stock?

Why does Graham get thrown out, well take away the Air Raid offense that he came from, look at his arm strength, physical stature, mobility and Passes that would translate to NFL accuracy? He just doesn't score high in any of those categories or traits. Honestly, Graham compares to Ken Dorsey more than he does to any 1st round QB or even 2nd round for that matter.

I simply said who has been his qbs that's all relax, I'm always gonna throw in level of competition for ANY prospect you don't have to but I will.

Once again the reason I brought up Graham was because dtg brought up stats about attempts vs INTs which someone WHO WAS in Leach's system (like falk) had very few of.

System does play a part when it comes to accuracy and INT vs TDs you complain about Watson not going through reads but what do you think the air raid offense is?

See post up above, and you guys question me whether if I watch Watson or not?

But yes, I'm relaxed and well rested thank you.
  • okdkid
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 23,729
Just saw a Fanspeak 7 round mock draft from Matt Miller that had the Niners taking Myles Garrett at #2 (Kizer went #1) and Watson in the 2nd. A dream scenario to say the least.
  • Jcool
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 44,549
A longtime former NFL general manager reached out this week to ask me about the top quarterback prospects and share notes. Here's what he told me on the Big Four:

1. "[Deshaun] Watson's interceptions are going to crush him. And he's small. He's a lot like your guy [Teddy] Bridgewater, actually."

2. "I would advise [DeShone] Kizer to leave because I don't think [head coach] Brian Kelly is helping him, but you really wish he had another season of experience under his belt. He could be the one we all fall in love with between now and April."

3. "Why do you like [Mitch] Trubisky? One-year starter who couldn't beat out that Williams kid [Marquise]? Stop looking at his stats."

4. "He's so skinny and that back-foot throwing he does scares me, but at least he's the smartest of the crop." — on University of Miami (FL) quarterback Brad Kaaya

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/2676618-matt-millers-week-11-nfl-scouting-notebook
Originally posted by Jcool:
A longtime former NFL general manager reached out this week to ask me about the top quarterback prospects and share notes. Here's what he told me on the Big Four:

1. "[Deshaun] Watson's interceptions are going to crush him. And he's small. He's a lot like your guy [Teddy] Bridgewater, actually."

2. "I would advise [DeShone] Kizer to leave because I don't think [head coach] Brian Kelly is helping him, but you really wish he had another season of experience under his belt. He could be the one we all fall in love with between now and April."

3. "Why do you like [Mitch] Trubisky? One-year starter who couldn't beat out that Williams kid [Marquise]? Stop looking at his stats."

4. "He's so skinny and that back-foot throwing he does scares me, but at least he's the smartest of the crop." — on University of Miami (FL) quarterback Brad Kaaya

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/2676618-matt-millers-week-11-nfl-scouting-notebook

lol I was just reading this...the new mock has us taking Myles
  • Jcool
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 44,549
Originally posted by NYniner85:
lol I was just reading this...the new mock has us taking Myles

My favorite part:

Former head coach of the San Francisco 49ers, Mike Nolan, made the Tweet of the Week.

Mike Nolan ✔@MikeNolanNFL
Every QB in the NFL is a system QB. It's called good coaching when the system matches the QB skill set. Quit knocking the system & player.

Nolan is right. Too often we simply say a quarterback is good or bad without considering the context around the player. How does he fit the scheme being ran? Has the front office put a plan in place to develop the quarterback? What about skill-position support?

Marcus Mariota is a great example of a player being developed with a plan. The Titans invested in improving the offensive line and run game—the two best friends of a young quarterback—and are allowing him to grow on the job while putting an offense in place that plays to his strengths.

As Cleveland, San Francisco and other teams begin thinking about how to identify and then develop a franchise quarterback, the examples in Tennessee and Dallas with Dak Prescott are great ones to follow.


http://bleacherreport.com/articles/2676618-matt-millers-week-11-nfl-scouting-notebook
Originally posted by Jcool:
A longtime former NFL general manager reached out this week to ask me about the top quarterback prospects and share notes. Here's what he told me on the Big Four:

1. "[Deshaun] Watson's interceptions are going to crush him. And he's small. He's a lot like your guy [Teddy] Bridgewater, actually."

2. "I would advise [DeShone] Kizer to leave because I don't think [head coach] Brian Kelly is helping him, but you really wish he had another season of experience under his belt. He could be the one we all fall in love with between now and April."

3. "Why do you like [Mitch] Trubisky? One-year starter who couldn't beat out that Williams kid [Marquise]? Stop looking at his stats."

4. "He's so skinny and that back-foot throwing he does scares me, but at least he's the smartest of the crop." — on University of Miami (FL) quarterback Brad Kaaya

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/2676618-matt-millers-week-11-nfl-scouting-notebook

Watson's INT's at the next level is what worries me about him but he has been productive
Originally posted by Kolohe:
See post up above, and you guys question me whether if I watch Watson or not?

But yes, I'm relaxed and well rested thank you.

I'm not saying Falk is a bad qb at all just have questions because of his system and that can't be thrown out the window...there has never been a successful air raid qb in the NFL

http://www.sbnation.com/college-football/2016/4/21/11473382/jared-goff-nfl-draft-2016-cal-air-raid

One thing they do in the air raid is split the OL out which creates passing lanes that makes going through progressions easier and avoid INTs.
Originally posted by Jcool:
My favorite part:

Former head coach of the San Francisco 49ers, Mike Nolan, made the Tweet of the Week.

Mike Nolan ✔@MikeNolanNFL
Every QB in the NFL is a system QB. It's called good coaching when the system matches the QB skill set. Quit knocking the system & player.

Nolan is right. Too often we simply say a quarterback is good or bad without considering the context around the player. How does he fit the scheme being ran? Has the front office put a plan in place to develop the quarterback? What about skill-position support?

Marcus Mariota is a great example of a player being developed with a plan. The Titans invested in improving the offensive line and run game—the two best friends of a young quarterback—and are allowing him to grow on the job while putting an offense in place that plays to his strengths.

As Cleveland, San Francisco and other teams begin thinking about how to identify and then develop a franchise quarterback, the examples in Tennessee and Dallas with Dak Prescott are great ones to follow.


http://bleacherreport.com/articles/2676618-matt-millers-week-11-nfl-scouting-notebook

Totally agree! You could kinda see it with Wilson as well...he had a great defense and running game behind him.
Originally posted by Jcool:
A longtime former NFL general manager reached out this week



3. "Why do you like [Mitch] Trubisky? One-year starter who couldn't beat out that Williams kid [Marquise]? Stop looking at his stats."


Might be one reason why he is a former general manager. A lot of UNC fans thought that Trubisky should have been the starter last year. His numbers were exceptional whenever he did play and Fedora would bring him on certain key situations.


Williams was a better college QB, a much better runner but lacked the passing ability that Trubisky possesses which is why one went undrafted and the other will be a 1st round pick.
Not a fan of listening to Mike Nolan's advice on how to select and develop a qb. He did good job building the team in some places that wasn't one of them though
Originally posted by NYniner85:
I'm not saying Falk is a bad qb at all just have questions because of his system and that can't be thrown out the window...there has never been a successful air raid qb in the NFL

http://www.sbnation.com/college-football/2016/4/21/11473382/jared-goff-nfl-draft-2016-cal-air-raid

One thing they do in the air raid is split the OL out which creates passing lanes that makes going through progressions easier and avoid INTs.


You realize Steve Young came out of the offense that was the foundation for the Air Raid?


Hal Mumme and Mike Leach took the LaVell Edwards offense and streamlined it but philosophically it is largely the same offense as both Leach and Young have stated in the past.
[ Edited by Phoenix49ers on Nov 18, 2016 at 9:41 AM ]
Originally posted by tjd808185:
Not a fan of listening to Mike Nolan's advice on how to select and develop a qb. He did good job building the team in some places that wasn't one of them though

LOL! Using Nolan as a QB expert is stretching the bounds of reason! What kind of laminating material to use on your play sheets? That's Nolan's area of expertise!
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
You realize Steve Young came out of the offense that was the foundation for the Air Raid?


Hal Mumme and Mike Leach took the LaVell Edwards offense and streamlined it but philosophically it is largely the same offense as both Leach and Young have stated in the past.

Yes but he didn't come in a light the league on fire we can agree on that. He was well on his way to becoming a bust...we got bill Walsh coaching this team?

You draft someone like falk (who I'm fine with) we'd better have a good bridge qb because he's not gonna be ready.

I'd rather throw a 2nd at NE for Jimmy G then draft falk...I also don't see him as a 2nd rd pick.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone