Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 739 users in the forums

2017 QB draft class

Browse 49ers books and videos
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
See post up above, and you guys question me whether if I watch Watson or not?

But yes, I'm relaxed and well rested thank you.

I'm not saying Falk is a bad qb at all just have questions because of his system and that can't be thrown out the window...there has never been a successful air raid qb in the NFL

http://www.sbnation.com/college-football/2016/4/21/11473382/jared-goff-nfl-draft-2016-cal-air-raid

One thing they do in the air raid is split the OL out which creates passing lanes that makes going through progressions easier and avoid INTs.

Kind of contradicting yourself right here.

System does play a part when it comes to accuracy and INT vs TDs you complain about Watson not going through reads but what do you think the air raid offense is?
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Kind of contradicting yourself right here.

System does play a part when it comes to accuracy and INT vs TDs you complain about Watson not going through reads but what do you think the air raid offense is?

.excuse me his reads and not sure what I'm contradicting? Every qb has some sort of progression and a air raid system's are relatively simplistic based on easy throwing lanes.

I'm not trying to say he's sucks as a qb just I have my questions with any qb coming out of those type of systems and when someone brings into the equation stats I'm gonna raise my hand.

I think that's a fair assessment...if you don't agree well we can just leave it at that
  • okdkid
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 23,729
Originally posted by NYniner85:
.excuse me his reads and not sure what I'm contradicting? Every qb has some sort of progression and a air raid system's are relatively simplistic based on easy throwing lanes.

I'm not trying to say he's sucks as a qb just I have my questions with any qb coming out of those type of systems and when someone brings into the equation stats I'm gonna raise my hand.

I think that's a fair assessment...if you don't agree well we can just leave it at that

Brother, the people have made their mind up on Falk. Anything approaching an opposing viewpoint will be passionately discredited.

Falk is the 'zones new Goff. Air raid QB, white, lacking mobility, pocket passer, big college stats. He's only missing the "we must trade away our future 1st round pick for this guy" hype. All in due time. Falk is the 'zones great white hope this year. There must be one. Every year.
Originally posted by okdkid:
Brother, the people have made their mind up on Falk. Anything approaching an opposing viewpoint will be passionately discredited.

Falk is the 'zones new Goff. Air raid QB, white, lacking mobility, pocket passer, big college stats. He's only missing the "we must trade away our future 1st round pick for this guy" hype. All in due time. Falk is the 'zones great white hope this year. There must be one. Every year.

Lol true...I'm not saying I wouldn't mind him at all but the system he's in has to be talked about especially when bringing up stats.

I don't see him as a 2nd rd pick either.
Originally posted by okdkid:
Brother, the people have made their mind up on Falk. Anything approaching an opposing viewpoint will be passionately discredited.

Falk is the 'zones new Goff. Air raid QB, white, lacking mobility, pocket passer, big college stats. He's only missing the "we must trade away our future 1st round pick for this guy" hype. All in due time. Falk is the 'zones great white hope this year. There must be one. Every year.




Dude the only one who has made up their mind on Falk is you. You constantly set up these strawmen that you like to shadow box and then act like they represent what anyone with a different opinion must believe.


Its fine to have an opinion on something or disagree with others but in your arrogance you presume to think for other people.


Comments like "great white hope" don't serve any sort of useful purpose beyond enflaming the discussion and mocking anyone who thinks otherwise because clearly they must be holding out hope for a white QB and not simply because they like a player based on his particular merits.




Just give it a rest and stop trying to speak for anyone who doesnt fall in line with your opinions on things.
[ Edited by Phoenix49ers on Nov 18, 2016 at 1:02 PM ]
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by okdkid:
Brother, the people have made their mind up on Falk. Anything approaching an opposing viewpoint will be passionately discredited.

Falk is the 'zones new Goff. Air raid QB, white, lacking mobility, pocket passer, big college stats. He's only missing the "we must trade away our future 1st round pick for this guy" hype. All in due time. Falk is the 'zones great white hope this year. There must be one. Every year.




Dude the only one who has made up their mind on Falk is you. You constantly set up these strawmen that you like to shadow box and then act like they represent what anyone with a different opinion must believe.


Its fine to have an opinion on something or disagree with others but in your arrogance you presume to think for other people.


Comments like "great white hope" don't serve any sort of useful purpose beyond enflaming the discussion and mocking anyone who thinks otherwise because clearly they must be holding out hope for a white QB and not simply because they like a player based on his particular merits.




Just give it a rest and stop trying to speak for anyone who doesnt fall in line with your opinions on things.

  • Jcool
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 44,549
Originally posted by Kolohe:

  • okdkid
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 23,729
There it is.
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Kind of contradicting yourself right here.

System does play a part when it comes to accuracy and INT vs TDs you complain about Watson not going through reads but what do you think the air raid offense is?

.excuse me his reads and not sure what I'm contradicting? Every qb has some sort of progression and a air raid system's are relatively simplistic based on easy throwing lanes.

I'm not trying to say he's sucks as a qb just I have my questions with any qb coming out of those type of systems and when someone brings into the equation stats I'm gonna raise my hand.

I think that's a fair assessment...if you don't agree well we can just leave it at that

Didn't you just insinuate that Falk makes one-reads in an Air Raid offense in your two replies up above, looks like it to me?

And I'm not trying to say that you said Falk sucks, but posting things like "Oh passing for 70 attempts you're bound to throw INT's" and "you complain about Watson not going through reads but what do you think the air raid offense is?" can be argued. And I've posted many links how Falk does in fact scan the field and go through reads. Now it's "Oh now they split OL's making it go through progressions a lot easier", so how does that hurt a QB rather than helping him? So a QB that is goes to his first read and often runs is more Pro ready than a QB who stands in the pocket, makes reads and delivers accurate passes??

For the record, I'm high on a few QB's in this draft and NOT just Luke Falk. But Luke Falk is just the #1 QB I'd want the 49ers to draft.
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by Jcool:
Originally posted by Kolohe:


Yah cause okdkid just knows what everyone wants as their QB, even though names like Kizer, Watson and Trubisky an next years draft Jake Browning, Josh Rosen have been thrown around numerous times.

  • Jcool
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 44,549
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Yah cause okdkid just knows what everyone wants as their QB, even though names like Kizer, Watson and Trubisky an next years draft Jake Browning, Josh Rosen have been thrown around numerous times.


Even before some of the top QB's this year faltered, I saw a lot of people saying we should pass on a QB in round 1 and take Falk in round 2 or 3. I also got push back when i questioned Falk and compared him to others QB's in that system. Obviously he isn't the only QB being talked about, but he is the current QB people have latched in on to prove their QB knowledge.
Originally posted by Jcool:
Even before some of the top QB's this year faltered, I saw a lot of people saying we should pass on a QB in round 1 and take Falk in round 2 or 3. I also got push back when i questioned Falk and compared him to others QB's in that system. Obviously he isn't the only QB being talked about, but he is the current QB people have latched in on to prove their QB knowledge.



Or you know, people might just like him as a player. Doesn't make them wrong or right. The reality is that we have no idea who ultimately will be successful and who won't be. People identify traits they like in various players and offer their opinions on how those players project out.


I have no idea how Falk will turn out but I do agree that its faulty logic to compare him to most other Air Raid QBs that were either undrafted or drafted very late. Like comparing him to Graham Harrell. Totally different caliber of prospect.

Disagreeing with that comparison doesn't mean that you believe that Falk is the second coming of Tom Brady or anything like that.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Didn't you just insinuate that Falk makes one-reads in an Air Raid offense in your two replies up above, looks like it to me?

And I'm not trying to say that you said Falk sucks, but posting things like "Oh passing for 70 attempts you're bound to throw INT's" and "you complain about Watson not going through reads but what do you think the air raid offense is?" can be argued. And I've posted many links how Falk does in fact scan the field and go through reads. Now it's "Oh now they split OL's making it go through progressions a lot easier", so how does that hurt a QB rather than helping him? So a QB that is goes to his first read and often runs is more Pro ready than a QB who stands in the pocket, makes reads and delivers accurate passes??

For the record, I'm high on a few QB's in this draft and NOT just Luke Falk. But Luke Falk is just the #1 QB I'd want the 49ers to draft.

I'm explaining why people hate on the air raid scheme because yes it does make things much much easier for a qb...spacing out the OL does create better passing lanes which makes his reads easier and raise his accuracy...why do you think qbs in air raid offenses have such good TD/INT ratios and great completion %?

Why do 99% of all air raid qbs fail in the NFL? Because those open lanes and easy reads just aren't there. I'm not saying he will fail at the next level at all, in fact I wouldn't be upset if he was the pick, but he's not close to being ready for the NFL IMO (which all that is, my opinion) I don't think you should draft a qb in the 2nd rd that's not ready to play at the next level when you have nothing ahead of him to hold the fort down for a yr or two.

Just my two cents and if he is the pick and we get him that high I hope I'm wrong.

Edit: I think at this point he's not a 2nd round pick that's all, I could very well change my opinion on that though.
[ Edited by NYniner85 on Nov 18, 2016 at 3:44 PM ]
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Kind of contradicting yourself right here.

System does play a part when it comes to accuracy and INT vs TDs you complain about Watson not going through reads but what do you think the air raid offense is?

.excuse me his reads and not sure what I'm contradicting? Every qb has some sort of progression and a air raid system's are relatively simplistic based on easy throwing lanes.

I'm not trying to say he's sucks as a qb just I have my questions with any qb coming out of those type of systems and when someone brings into the equation stats I'm gonna raise my hand.

I think that's a fair assessment...if you don't agree well we can just leave it at that

Didn't you just insinuate that Falk makes one-reads in an Air Raid offense in your two replies up above, looks like it to me?

And I'm not trying to say that you said Falk sucks, but posting things like "Oh passing for 70 attempts you're bound to throw INT's" and "you complain about Watson not going through reads but what do you think the air raid offense is?" can be argued. And I've posted many links how Falk does in fact scan the field and go through reads. Now it's "Oh now they split OL's making it go through progressions a lot easier", so how does that hurt a QB rather than helping him? So a QB that is goes to his first read and often runs is more Pro ready than a QB who stands in the pocket, makes reads and delivers accurate passes??

For the record, I'm high on a few QB's in this draft and NOT just Luke Falk. But Luke Falk is just the #1 QB I'd want the 49ers to draft.

I also like Falk. I like his work ethic and skill development. Some of the points made against him have merit. It is true that QBs have wider throwing lanes in an Air Raid offense, and it is reasonable to suggest that an Air Raid QB would need time to acclimatize to narrow lanes and tighter NFL coverage. It is not reasonable to watch Falk play and conclude that he does not scan the field and move through progressions to find open receivers. I don't care who you like as your QB. Everyone is entitled to their own opinions, and no one here has any influence on the actual choice. No need to make sh!t up or condescend to make a point, though. That's what I take issue with from some of the dudes here.
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Kind of contradicting yourself right here.

System does play a part when it comes to accuracy and INT vs TDs you complain about Watson not going through reads but what do you think the air raid offense is?

.excuse me his reads and not sure what I'm contradicting? Every qb has some sort of progression and a air raid system's are relatively simplistic based on easy throwing lanes.

I'm not trying to say he's sucks as a qb just I have my questions with any qb coming out of those type of systems and when someone brings into the equation stats I'm gonna raise my hand.

I think that's a fair assessment...if you don't agree well we can just leave it at that

Didn't you just insinuate that Falk makes one-reads in an Air Raid offense in your two replies up above, looks like it to me?

And I'm not trying to say that you said Falk sucks, but posting things like "Oh passing for 70 attempts you're bound to throw INT's" and "you complain about Watson not going through reads but what do you think the air raid offense is?" can be argued. And I've posted many links how Falk does in fact scan the field and go through reads. Now it's "Oh now they split OL's making it go through progressions a lot easier", so how does that hurt a QB rather than helping him? So a QB that is goes to his first read and often runs is more Pro ready than a QB who stands in the pocket, makes reads and delivers accurate passes??

For the record, I'm high on a few QB's in this draft and NOT just Luke Falk. But Luke Falk is just the #1 QB I'd want the 49ers to draft.

I also like Falk. I like his work ethic and skill development. Some of the points made against him have merit. It is true that QBs have wider throwing lanes in an Air Raid offense, and it is reasonable to suggest that an Air Raid QB would need time to acclimatize to narrow lanes and tighter NFL coverage. It is not reasonable to watch Falk play and conclude that he does not scan the field and move through progressions to find open receivers. I don't care who you like as your QB. Everyone is entitled to their own opinions, and no one here has any influence on the actual choice. No need to make sh!t up or condescend to make a point, though. That's what I take issue with from some of the dudes here.

Gotta make my replies quick and hopefully to the point, gotta a lot of work to do.

But that's my main point too, it's no secret Watson does go to and stare down his first read. But to say Falk is doing the same and you know nothing about this or that offense is pretty absurd. I'm not trying to change anyone's mind on the QB they prefer, but like you said let's not start making up crap about other QB's.

First it was Falk also stares down his first read (which was pretty much said) to now Air Raid's split their OL's to make it easier to go through progressions. I mean which is it, does he go through his progressions or not. Honestly I'd admit I was wrong in a heartbeat after all I don't remember the Webzone handing out prizes for proving people wrong.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone