Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 773 users in the forums

2017 QB draft class

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
i'm prone to taking BPA of the impact variety. Garrett is a top OLB candidate--a position of need. There are quite a few QBs of close value so I'd wait and take one in the second if Kelly liked them--Falk, Watson, Kizer, Mahomes...whoever. If Garrett is gone and they like a QB in the second then an impact player at a skill position would be my choice, or trading way back to get a top ILB (Cuningham or Foster) and still a top WR (Ross, Smith-Shuster, etc). Right now, CBS has Kizer at 31, Corey Davis at 40,

In other words they need to try and maximize picks without giving up impact players. If Kelly really likes Trubisky (or any other QB) they should grab him.

So if Myles is gone (which is a good possibility) and we do in fact have a top 3 pick and we can't find a trade partner your going with Mitch?

Like you said it's way too soon to be figuring out who's gonna go when but I think it's good to look at all the prospects in the top 5 where we will most likely be picking.

CBS prospects has this as it's top 5 currently.

1: Allen
2: peppers
3: Garrett
4: Fournette
5: Humphrey
Originally posted by NYniner85:
So if Myles is gone (which is a good possibility) and we do in fact have a top 3 pick and we can't find a trade partner your going with Mitch?

Like you said it's way too soon to be figuring out who's gonna go when but I think it's good to look at all the prospects in the top 5 where we will most likely be picking.

CBS prospects has this as it's top 5 currently.

1: Allen
2: peppers
3: Garrett
4: Fournette
5: Humphrey

I'm going with whoever Kelly likes at QB if that is the best pick. But he may very well like a later pick so all options are open. Imagine trading down and getting:

ILB: Foster, 6'1" 236
WR: Corey Davis, 6'3" 213
QB: Falk, 6'3 214
DT: best NT available to replace Williams? A free agent would be a wise addition as well
OLB: free agent, unless there is a quality guy available if they Garrett is gone.

These three are rated in the first two rounds but Foster is the highest on CBS at #15. So a trade down and up would put these guys in reach if the team has reasonable trading partners. There are a lot of other guys but this would help with the middle of the defense and skill players on offense. Then they could concentrate on OLBs in free agency.

Edit: I see some mocks placing Fournette with the niners as Kelly does like his RBs.
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Nov 16, 2016 at 3:19 PM ]
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
I'm going with whoever Kelly likes at QB if that is the best pick. But he may very well like a later pick so all options are open. Imagine trading down and getting:

ILB: Foster, 6'1" 236
WR: Corey Davis, 6'3" 213
QB: Falk, 6'3 214
DT: best NT available to replace Williams? A free agent would be a wise addition as well
OLB: free agent, unless there is a quality guy available if they Garrett is gone.

These three are rated in the first two rounds but Foster is the highest on CBS at #15. So a trade down and up would put these guys in reach if the team has reasonable trading partners. There are a lot of other guys but this would help with the middle of the defense and skill players on offense. Then they could concentrate on OLBs in free agency.

Edit: I see some mocks placing Fournette with the niners as Kelly does like his RBs.

I wouldn't hate a trade down to pickup players like you mentioned issue is it's gonna cost a team quite a bit to move up to say the 2nd overall pick and without a no brainer qb who are these people moving up for?

So say we move down to 10 according to draft value chart that's a difference of 1,300 points which is basically that teams 2nd 3rd 4th and 2nd next yr lol...that's a lot to give up for say Allen or one of these qbs.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
I wouldn't hate a trade down to pickup players like you mentioned issue is it's gonna cost a team quite a bit to move up to say the 2nd overall pick and without a no brainer qb who are these people moving up for?

So say we move down to 10 according to draft value chart that's a difference of 1,300 points which is basically that teams 2nd 3rd 4th and 2nd next yr lol...that's a lot to give up for say Allen or one of these qbs.

I can see move-downs in increments...#2 for a #5 and a second rounder, trade #5 for a #10 and another second...you never know until you are in the moment. Someone may really like Peppers or Allen, who the niners really don't need.
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Nov 16, 2016 at 3:56 PM ]
Originally posted by Murphys1:
MD, or anyone else, what are your thoughts on Baker Mayfield? Super accurate, but small. Has he got the goods? No one really talks about him much, but 70% accuracy and almost 11 yards per attempt are a good combination.

Stud for a smallish QB. The kid is a winner, and is going to compete right away for a backup spot. He just needs an opportunity to play and see if there is anything there at the pro level. Late round flier QB
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
I can see move-downs in increments...#2 for a #5 and a second rounder, trade #5 for a #10 and another second...you never know until you are in the moment. Someone may really like Peppers or Allen, who the niners really don't need.

It would actually cost more than a 2nd to move from 5 to 2 got to throw a 3rd in there to get close to even value.

IMO I want quality over quantity getting the extra picks could help with getting who we really want or it could be us drafting a s**t ton of players when we already have a s**t ton of young players.
  • LVJay
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 27,847
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
I can see move-downs in increments...#2 for a #5 and a second rounder, trade #5 for a #10 and another second...you never know until you are in the moment. Someone may really like Peppers or Allen, who the niners really don't need.

It would actually cost more than a 2nd to move from 5 to 2 got to throw a 3rd in there to get close to even value.

IMO I want quality over quantity getting the extra picks could help with getting who we really want or it could be us drafting a s**t ton of players when we already have a s**t ton of young players.

Yup... we're already loaded with depth (2nd / 3rd string talent) and we need (badly) solid, day-one starters via draft and FA.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
I can see move-downs in increments...#2 for a #5 and a second rounder, trade #5 for a #10 and another second...you never know until you are in the moment. Someone may really like Peppers or Allen, who the niners really don't need.

It would actually cost more than a 2nd to move from 5 to 2 got to throw a 3rd in there to get close to even value.

IMO I want quality over quantity getting the extra picks could help with getting who we really want or it could be us drafting a s**t ton of players when we already have a s**t ton of young players.

That's why I emphasised impact players. Garrett is likely the best percentage to be an elite guy, but after that they even out. So if they don't get Garrett and Kelly likes a QB who will be around in the second they are clear to trade back and still get quality with quantity. We always have to keep in mind that QBs tend to rise as the draft approaches so a guy like Kizer listed at 31st might be mid-first.

My whole premise regarding trades is to get high quality in a position of need rather than, for instance, another safety with #2 in the first round. Getting the best ILB and a top NT would really help this defense and really is necessary going forward.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
I'm going with whoever Kelly likes at QB if that is the best pick. But he may very well like a later pick so all options are open. Imagine trading down and getting:

ILB: Foster, 6'1" 236
WR: Corey Davis, 6'3" 213
QB: Falk, 6'3 214
DT: best NT available to replace Williams? A free agent would be a wise addition as well
OLB: free agent, unless there is a quality guy available if they Garrett is gone.

These three are rated in the first two rounds but Foster is the highest on CBS at #15. So a trade down and up would put these guys in reach if the team has reasonable trading partners. There are a lot of other guys but this would help with the middle of the defense and skill players on offense. Then they could concentrate on OLBs in free agency.

Edit: I see some mocks placing Fournette with the niners as Kelly does like his RBs.

I wouldn't hate a trade down to pickup players like you mentioned issue is it's gonna cost a team quite a bit to move up to say the 2nd overall pick and without a no brainer qb who are these people moving up for?

So say we move down to 10 according to draft value chart that's a difference of 1,300 points which is basically that teams 2nd 3rd 4th and 2nd next yr lol...that's a lot to give up for say Allen or one of these qbs.

Allen and Garret are both worth trading up for for almost any team in the league; they'd just need to be willing to pay the asking price. Both are scheme-versatile; both are freaking monsters. Falling to the 3rd pick in the draft would potentially hurt our trade leverage, imo.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
I can see move-downs in increments...#2 for a #5 and a second rounder, trade #5 for a #10 and another second...you never know until you are in the moment. Someone may really like Peppers or Allen, who the niners really don't need.

It would actually cost more than a 2nd to move from 5 to 2 got to throw a 3rd in there to get close to even value.

IMO I want quality over quantity getting the extra picks could help with getting who we really want or it could be us drafting a s**t ton of players when we already have a s**t ton of young players.

There will be a lot of studs in the top 2 rounds. Loading up on #2s in this draft wouldn't be a bad idea. any #3s could be used to move ahead from a @ we acquired. Getting Foster, Davis/Ross, Falk, Butt, Fields would be insane. I could spend day 3 of the draft without panic and rage, for once.
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
I'm going with whoever Kelly likes at QB if that is the best pick. But he may very well like a later pick so all options are open. Imagine trading down and getting:

ILB: Foster, 6'1" 236
WR: Corey Davis, 6'3" 213
QB: Falk, 6'3 214
DT: best NT available to replace Williams? A free agent would be a wise addition as well
OLB: free agent, unless there is a quality guy available if they Garrett is gone.

These three are rated in the first two rounds but Foster is the highest on CBS at #15. So a trade down and up would put these guys in reach if the team has reasonable trading partners. There are a lot of other guys but this would help with the middle of the defense and skill players on offense. Then they could concentrate on OLBs in free agency.

Edit: I see some mocks placing Fournette with the niners as Kelly does like his RBs.

I wouldn't hate a trade down to pickup players like you mentioned issue is it's gonna cost a team quite a bit to move up to say the 2nd overall pick and without a no brainer qb who are these people moving up for?

So say we move down to 10 according to draft value chart that's a difference of 1,300 points which is basically that teams 2nd 3rd 4th and 2nd next yr lol...that's a lot to give up for say Allen or one of these qbs.

Allen and Garret are both worth trading up for for almost any team in the league; they'd just need to be willing to pay the asking price. Both are scheme-versatile; both are freaking monsters. Falling to the 3rd pick in the draft would potentially hurt our trade leverage, imo.

Not according to MadDog who thinks Allen will fall to the 7-12 range (looking forward to reading his rationale for that). I do think some people are overreacting to Allen being bumped to #1 on CBS's board and Kizer being knocked down to #31. Allen isn't likely to be a top 2 pick and Kizer will be taken in the top 15 picks in my opinion (and in almost every recent mock I've seen).

Falling to the 3rd pick hurts our leverage either way because it puts another team in front of us that someone can trade with if they like a certain player. Even if that player is available at 3, teams look at the draft value chart to a certain degree and won't always offer the same package to trade up to #3 as they would to trade up to #2.

Picking later in every round wouldn't be ideal - dropping from the 2nd pick in every round to the 3rd pick in every round is the equivalent of losing a mid-2nd round pick according to the draft value chart (~421 points). Dropping to the 4th pick would be the equivalent of losing the 20th or 21st pick in the draft based on the chart.
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
Allen and Garret are both worth trading up for for almost any team in the league; they'd just need to be willing to pay the asking price. Both are scheme-versatile; both are freaking monsters. Falling to the 3rd pick in the draft would potentially hurt our trade leverage, imo.

Then why wouldn't we just draft either of them? I get the more picks route but we are stock full of youth I'd rather get impact players and bring in a couple vets in then end up with a ton of picks.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
Allen and Garret are both worth trading up for for almost any team in the league; they'd just need to be willing to pay the asking price. Both are scheme-versatile; both are freaking monsters. Falling to the 3rd pick in the draft would potentially hurt our trade leverage, imo.

Then why wouldn't we just draft either of them? I get the more picks route but we are stock full of youth I'd rather get impact players and bring in a couple vets in then end up with a ton of picks.

Garrett, yes, but Allen is a wasted pick for us, imo. 2 overall isn't value for a NT, and he's too damn active and athletic to waste soaking up 2 or 3 blockers. We need help at ILB, WR, QB, OLB, NT, and I think there's starter talent at those spots through the 1st 2 rounds. It's a potential strategy.
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
Garrett, yes, but Allen is a wasted pick for us, imo. 2 overall isn't value for a NT, and he's too damn active and athletic to waste soaking up 2 or 3 blockers. We need help at ILB, WR, QB, OLB, NT, and I think there's starter talent at those spots through the 1st 2 rounds. It's a potential strategy.

No I agree there's talent at those spots I just don't see a team moving up for Allen or one of these QBs.
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
There will be a lot of studs in the top 2 rounds. Loading up on #2s in this draft wouldn't be a bad idea. any #3s could be used to move ahead from a @ we acquired. Getting Foster, Davis/Ross, Falk, Butt, Fields would be insane. I could spend day 3 of the draft without panic and rage, for once.

Loading up on 2's with Baalke calling the shots is a bad plan.. he would draft medical redshirts and CBs that will be cut later
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone