There are 179 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

Would Peyton have been a better fit than Alex?

Originally posted by AmpLee:
Originally posted by boomer49er:
2012 Alex Smith > 2012 Peyton Manning

Manning just doesn't have the incredible arm strength thathe used to have. It's really showing.

I didn't see the game tonight, but there were a couple throws last week that made me cringe how soft and flat they looked. It looked like a changeup coming out of his hand. I noted it in case it becomes a recurring theme.

didnt have a tight spiral....looked like a Shaun Hill pass a few times

after watching the 2nd one I called my lil bro (an Atl fan) and said someting is wrong with Manning
  • Wodwo
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 8,104
Originally posted by jreff22:
didnt have a tight spiral....looked like a Shaun Hill pass a few times

after watching the 2nd one I called my lil bro (an Atl fan) and said someting is wrong with Manning

Originally posted by Wodwo:
Originally posted by jreff22:
didnt have a tight spiral....looked like a Shaun Hill pass a few times

after watching the 2nd one I called my lil bro (an Atl fan) and said someting is wrong with Manning


yep

maybe the Doctors were wrong
Originally posted by Wodwo:
Originally posted by AmpLee:
Originally posted by boomer49er:
2012 Alex Smith > 2012 Peyton Manning

Manning just doesn't have the incredible arm strength thathe used to have. It's really showing.

I didn't see the game tonight, but there were a couple throws last week that made me cringe how soft and flat they looked. It looked like a changeup coming out of his hand. I noted it in case it becomes a recurring theme.



All 3 of those, especially that last pass, are just fugly. Thank God we didn't get him
  • MarkD
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 939
No not at any point ever. Can we lock this up now plz
Hey, he almost has as many interceptions that Alex Smith had last year.
Originally posted by MarkD:
No not at any point ever. Can we lock this up now plz

noooo... this thread could be "historic" at the end of the season.

such as the game against Philly in 2010... and the kevin kolb thread too.... and the comparisons alex vs mcnabb, batch, bulger, volek... aikman
2 games in

alex is the best qb in nfl (based soley on these 2 games)
Alex has gotten better under Harbaugh ,but not Peyton or even Eli better. But thats ok we're doing just fine with him leading this awsome team.
[ Edited by 16to87 on Sep 17, 2012 at 10:45 PM ]
Originally posted by Youngb:
Hey, he almost has as many interceptions that Alex Smith had last year.
You got to look at the totality of thier careers, no comparison
Manning almost came back. 4 picks but that was it. He needs to slow it down a bit with the hurry up so quickly.
Maybe this game will bring him back down to earf and not have to pass every friggin down. But hey, I'm no Broncos fan, so in the end, not a single is given.
Originally posted by Youngb:
Hey, he almost has as many interceptions that Alex Smith had last year.

Originally posted by 49ersalldaway126:
2 games in

alex is the best qb in nfl (based soley on these 2 games)


It's f**king strange to say that isn't it
i think denver wants a refund, this dude looks like s**t, he went from being peyton manning to old age brett favre. have fun with that s**t denver while we enjoy alex entering what will be known as his rise to power!!!
Originally posted by 49ersalldaway126:
2 games in

alex is the best qb in nfl (based soley on these 2 games)

Actually I think Matt Ryan has been better. Ryan has the best QB Rating so far in 2012.

Alex... the second best QB Rating in 2012.

And what's funny? Their stats are eerily similar.
Originally posted by ElDannMann:
Originally posted by 49ersalldaway126:
2 games in

alex is the best qb in nfl (based soley on these 2 games)

Actually I think Matt Ryan has been better. Ryan has the best QB Rating so far in 2012.

Alex... the second best QB Rating in 2012.

And what's funny? Their stats are eerily similar.

Their playoff stats aren't lol