There are 88 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

Poll: Peyton or Alex?

Poll: Peyton or Alex?

  • vaden
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 3,588
Originally posted by danimal:
Peyton. SB or Bust.

Alex. Mediocrity, 2011 was our peak.


Yes, because 32 TD/8 INT, 17-7 record, 92.6 qb rating in last 24 starts is mediocre
Originally posted by Jesu80ncleats:
Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Change it to "Peyton at 30 million per year" or "Peyton for approx. 60 million over two years".

Where are you getting this from???
http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2012/03/16/peyton-manning-wants-his-new-contract-to-match-his-old-contract/#comments

Its speculation.
Originally posted by Gore_21:
Peyton Manning 35 year old, injured, bad OL, new system and WRs vs Alex Smith younger, mobile, knows the system... AT THE SAME COST.... Peyton Manning

Peyton Manning at 5 years 90 million vs Alex Smith at 3 years 30 million........ Alex Smith

hes injured?
I choose Smitty! Write it down, take a picture, I don't give a fak!
Originally posted by Loco49er:
I choose Smitty! Write it down, take a picture, I don't give a fak!

We are only going to need a qb for 2-3 years while harbaugh grooms kap. I think manning would be a great short term answer for esp since it makes us a super bowl contender asap


18 as long as the contract protects the team
Originally posted by vaden:
Originally posted by danimal:
Peyton. SB or Bust.

Alex. Mediocrity, 2011 was our peak.


Yes, because 32 TD/8 INT, 17-7 record, 92.6 qb rating in last 24 starts is mediocre

we already have an Alex Smith thread. Why can't people just respond to these polls and not quote others

No need to argue in here. I think Alex is mediocre, you don't, big deal.
what r we even doing in the manning race? we dont have the cap space to sign him, I dont think. I may be wrong but manning will command at the very least low or mid 20s. We would have to restructure contracts and cut some people. wheres AB when you need him? id like to get his intake on our cap space situation if we sign manning
hahah people are retarded, actually voting for Alex Smith, damn man straight stupid.
IF Manning is healthy and the Doc doesn't have serious worries about his ability to play and take hits, AND his cap hit doesn't exceed 18 million in any given year then Peyton.

Smith is not a mediocore, he's a very good QB. He hasn't put up a lot of TDs in any given year but that's been as much a product of the systems and the other players on offense. When he's ben asked to turn it loose he's looked great and could have been a guy who puts up 30+ TDs.

Either way I'm ok.
Originally posted by shinndiesel:
We are only going to need a qb for 2-3 years while harbaugh grooms kap. I think manning would be a great short term answer for esp since it makes us a super bowl contender asap

I'm not sold on CK nor any athletic QB who ran a pistol offense. I think Tolzien has a better shot than CK honestly.
Totally depends on the $

If we do sign him, I see us trading the 1st for Wallace. He'd be a great teacher for Kap & Tolzien.
some of you Alex Smith supporters still can't get it past yourself.
if Peyton Manning is healthy and ready to go, you cannot in your right mind take Smith over Manning
Dude we have 19 million this year I say give him 12mill in 20112, 15 mill in 2013, 25 mill in 2014 when the new contracts with the tv netwroks supposeably come into effect. Thats 42 million over three years all garuanteed. On average to what Den is paying over five. And he would be garuanteeing himself a better team.