There are 95 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

Who on the current team will not be on the 2012 49ers?

Originally posted by Joecool:
Originally posted by 49erRider:
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by Joecool:
Who is more important, Goldson or Rogers? I can't stop thinking about how our defense was in games 1 and 2 with Reggie Smith at FS.

Reggie Smith needs to be gone that dude is hot garbage. Not sure who is more important but Goldson has been playing really well. Rogers does have a lot Ints but he also does give up a lot passes also.

Rogers is the most important man in the entire secondary. If it came down to him or Goldson, I'd pack Goldson's bags myself.

Rogers didn't look so good when Goldson wasn't playing.

I recall many plays which he broke up in 1 on 1 coverage, but you're right, it must have been Goldson coming from the other side of the field and transforming into #22 to break up those passes.
Spencer
Braylon
Goldson
B. Edwards will probably not be back. The team will extend J. Morgan (cause he is just as good and cheaper) and will probably add a WR in the draft (I'd say round 2).

S. Spencer will probably get cut or traded. He is too expensive to keep.

P. Haralson is another guy that could get the boot. Not that he hasn't played well. But with Aldon Smith and A. Brooks playing so well, I think Haralson is the odd man out. He gets paid too much to be the 3rd OLB.

A. Smith will be resigned. It remains to be seen how good Alex can really be. In any case though, it is VERY unlikely that we can get a better QB for 2012. I want any QB we draft to EARN the starting spot. They must prove that they are better than Alex. Until that time, we should keep Alex Smith as our QB.

The entire secondary will likely get shuffled (except for D. Whitner). Rogers will most likely be resigned with a big contract. That means Goldson could be on the fence since he will probably want a big contract too. If the coaches are happy with Culliver as the other CB, they may draft Goldson's replacement. If they aren't happy with Culliver, then a CB will get drafted and Goldson may be safe. Personally I would like to see Rogers and Goldson extended and a CB drafted in round 1. Downside to that is that would make for a very expensive secondary.
Originally posted by Joecool:
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by Joecool:
Who is more important, Goldson or Rogers? I can't stop thinking about how our defense was in games 1 and 2 with Reggie Smith at FS.

Reggie Smith needs to be gone that dude is hot garbage. Not sure who is more important but Goldson has been playing really well. Rogers does have a lot Ints but he also does give up a lot passes also.

And if you look at most of Rogers INT's, they are all underneath coverage with FS over the top. I think having that FS that can cover a lot of ground is vital to a CB trusting to play underneath. Goldson gets to spots in a hurry.

On top of that, we have Culliver, Brown and Spencer who will cost FAR less than what Rogers will want.

Rogers is the best CB we have had in a long time. I think alot will depend on what happens in the playoffs this year.... if we play Green Bay in the NFC championship and we loose because our secondary gets torched I think the team will be much more willing to invest more in the secondary.
I don't see Haralson as being out. He makes less than 3 million this year, which is a pretty good deal for a starting OLB.
Rogers gets the contract, goldson walks
Snyder resigns- Rachal walks- thank god
Braylon/Ted Ginn re sign- Josh Morgan is not offered a contract after the big praise he received- spoiler alert
Moran Norris
Spencer
Witner
Originally posted by overthemiddle:
Witner

srsly? wtf?
Originally posted by overthemiddle:
Witner

Norris, Rachal, Spenser, Harrylson
Braylon will be back. Resigned before the playoffs starts.

Players gone

Norris
Spencer
Reggie Smith
Anythony Dixon
Madeua Williams

Guy on the fence (depending on draft and FA)
Parys Haralson
Terrell Brown
[ Edited by krizay on Nov 18, 2011 at 12:39 PM ]
Norris, Ginn, A.Dixon,, Edwards, Shawntae Spencer, and either Brooks or Parys
What about Culliver at FS?
I'd hate to see Goldson go
i think dashon and/or carlos might be gone. both playin lights out and both want $$.