Originally posted by Wodwo:Originally posted by Furlow:
Not to mention if you have in fact been saying it all year, and do believe that our play calling is terrible, then doesn't that take away from your argument that our lack of success is all Alex's fault? You can't have it both ways...
Actually, susweel can have it both ways. You just committed a major fallacy, my friend.
They can both suck. You just can't tell for sure if one is dragging the other down with them or not.
However, it is unlikely that Mike Johnson is a genius and Alex Smith is the reason for his failure.
But you can deduce from past failures that more likely than not Alex is the one doing the dragging.
Its not like MJ's the first OC Alex has had trouble with. He's struggled in every offensive scheme he's ever played in, and one guy (Martz) didnt even want to give him a chance.