He is wildly inconsistent. It is hard to even describe him as mediocre. For the TWO games a year he plays well, he has at least three games like he had today against the 49ers. He had a Superbowl appearance YEARS ago. But how is that relevant today? How does a Superbowl appearance make him a quality QB today?
Saying he is better than other QBs in the NFC West doesn't really make him an NFL quality guy.
Aside from the Cardinals and Panthers...does he represent and upgrade for anybody? Sorry, I wouldn't take him over what we got...as horrible as that sounds. He just doesn't have it anymore. The Jake Delhomme of the year.