Originally posted by jojomellon:Originally posted by 49ersalldaway126:
he would be the worst gm ever
got rid of franchise qb and WR within 2 years
used a first on alphonso smith who got released next year
Didnt even release Smith, traded him to Det for a 7th round TE, only for Smith to start for Detroit and pick off 5 passes.(admittedly hes still not great in coverage, but still, 1 year?)
Not to mention either, Kyle Orton had a very decent 2008 for the Bears, a Bears team with nothing at the WR position.
Signed Jarvis Green to a 4 yr 20 mil deal in march. Released him in September. whoops!
One more, he signed JJ Arrington in 2009 in March, only for him to be cut in May after failing a physical. Yes, he signed a guy who needed microfracture surgery and didnt bother to check.
Not all of this falls of Josh however, Brian Xanders is to shoulder some of this blame as well.
Alphonso Smith got eaten alive by the Patriots and Tom Terrific. I'm sure you remember that afternoon