Originally posted by Apples:
Both were #1 overall picks.
I wanna say Carr, just because it was believed that he would be great, a lot of people had doubts about Alex.
Smith still has a chance to change his course because he is younger. Carr just seems like a lost cause.
BUST than either one of those guys, and perhaps THE
BIGGEST BUST of All-Time, in my opinion, is Ryan Leaf
He was only a #2 overall pick, but because of all of the hype that surrounded Leaf and Manning that year, I think he was definitely the bigger disappointment. There was even talk as to which QB should go #1 that year!
Some NFL Scouts thought that Leaf would make the better Pro. And many felt that the Chargers would have still picked Leaf if they would have had the #1 Pick instead of the Colts.
And just look at these horrendous Career Stats he managed in his 4 seasons.
1998-2001..... TD:14..... Int:36..... Yds:3,666..... Rating:50.0