Locker v. Luck, The Great QB Debate

Locker!

The more athletic guy.

Originally posted by Chief:
Locker!

The more athletic guy.

Sarcasm?

Originally posted by SybErkRimInAL:
is this voting biased since Luck is from Stanford?

I hate Stanford!

Originally posted by SourdoughDan:

Originally posted by Chief:
Locker!

The more athletic guy.

Sarcasm?

no, thats reality. why cant anyone answer my question?

[ Edited by communist on Oct 14, 2010 at 05:29:56 ]

Originally posted by communist:

Originally posted by SourdoughDan:

Originally posted by Chief:
Locker!

The more athletic guy.

Sarcasm?

no, thats reality. why cant anyone answer my question?

what is ur question?

I think Luck will declare when his agent show him how much $$$$$ he will be making when he is the #1 pick.

Originally posted by Kalen49ers:
I think Luck will declare when his agent show him how much $$$$$ he will be making when he is the #1 pick.

if theres a lockout he wont come out for sure

Originally posted by communist:

Originally posted by SourdoughDan:

Originally posted by Chief:
Locker!

The more athletic guy.

Sarcasm?

no, thats reality. why cant anyone answer my question?

So what was your question?

Originally posted by Antix:
Luck has absolutely everything I want in our QB. I hope to God we get him.

Makes quick reads, fires with confidence, nice arm, smart as sh*t and MAKES PLAYS!

If we get Luck that will make me feel pretty good. Then we're just a real, experienced coaching staff away from being where we need to be.

luck doesnt have a good arm though
i mean if ur expecting luck to throw over 250 yds a game with 2 tds ur gonna be disspointed trust me

however he is smart accurate and a good game manager

Originally posted by 49ersalldaway126:

Originally posted by Antix:
Luck has absolutely everything I want in our QB. I hope to God we get him.

Makes quick reads, fires with confidence, nice arm, smart as sh*t and MAKES PLAYS!

If we get Luck that will make me feel pretty good. Then we're just a real, experienced coaching staff away from being where we need to be.

luck doesnt have a good arm though
i mean if ur expecting luck to throw over 250 yds a game with 2 tds ur gonna be disspointed trust me

however he is smart accurate and a good game manager

His arm looked pretty good to me against USC and Oregon. We don't need him to have a cannon arm, but we would be successful with his accuracy, his game managing, and his quick reads/release.

I do like Locker though. I know he's going to be more of a project, but he does have a good strong arm and a lot of athleticism. The guy is a real competitor and once he gets more time and coaching under the pro-style offense, he'll be a star.

Here's a couple cool videos for the battle of the QBs.

Jake Locker


Andrew Luck


I don't know why, but when I look at the two of these QBs, it reminds me of the Eli Manning vs. Ben Roethlisberger debate. Luck's play looks a bit like Manning's while Locker looks like a more athletic Roethlisberger.

Luck seems more accurate, and he leads his receivers better.

I want Harbauh and Luck sooooooooooooo badly......

Pipe dream I know, but this awful team pushes one to those limits....

Originally posted by WINiner:
Luck seems more accurate, and he leads his receivers better.

I want Harbauh and Luck sooooooooooooo badly......

Pipe dream I know, but this awful team pushes one to those limits....

Me too...

I've said it once and I'll say it again. Ponder will be the best Qb coming out of this draft class. I hope we manage to trade for an extra first rounder. Prince and Ponder 2011.

Originally posted by Byisgod:
I've said it once and I'll say it again. Ponder will be the best Qb coming out of this draft class. I hope we manage to trade for an extra first rounder. Prince and Ponder 2011.

Ponder has only thrown over 200 yds one time this season. No thanks.