There are 265 users in the forums

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by Furlow:
I don't think Tommy John is off the table yet. Depends on the extent of the damage and where the tear is. Not sure if they even decide before they go in, or while they're in there. Where's that surgeon from yesterday? Dude called it smh...

With Mullens they didn't know until they had gone in for the surgery.
Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
No. roll with jimmy for 1.5 years until brock comes back. We will be in playoffs both years. if we sign a RIGHT TACKLE.

Jimmy's not going to come back when a team will offer him a long term starting job.

Also, where are we going to sign a RT for a reasonable price. It's going to hard to resign McGlinchey (who is average at best).
Originally posted by SLCNiner:
Originally posted by leakyfausett:
Where are the idiots from the game day thread that were saying Brock didn't have any fight or didn't have enough heart. Or the injury didn't look bad and he was just soft. Feel free to insert your foot in your mouth or better yet insert it up your A$$.

It's usually randos on the game day thread that spew that kind of trash. I'm thrilled they aren't here on a daily basis.

Yeah, not true fans and probably drunk out of their minds to reason.
  • Furlow
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 25,440
Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
Originally posted by Furlow:
Originally posted by Oscar8325:
Originally posted by goldlame2013:
Well, time to give the 🐐 a phone call. Or Aaron Rodgers a phone call. Otherwise, we're screwed

No! Either one would demand 20-30+ Mil. We need $$ to sign Aiyuk, Bosa and CMC. Having 2 capable QB's on rookie salaries is what is going to keep our Super Bowl window open for a while. We just need a backup for Trey while Purdy recovers and hopefully it's a 100% recovery, which I fully expect. Most baseball pitchers come back from this I don't see any reason for Brock to be any different.

Agreed. f**k those old dinosaurs. Just roll with Trey if Purdy's not ready week 1. Draft another QB with an elite 10 yard split and fast processing/decision making lol.

No. roll with jimmy for 1.5 years until brock comes back. We will be in playoffs both years. if we sign a RIGHT TACKLE.

Jimmy will likely get starter money ($25M-$35M/year) elsewhere. No way. Now if there's no market for him and he's willing to sign for under $15M, maybe. Even then I'd probably still roll with Trey and just see what he's got. Purdy will be back next season one way or another.
Originally posted by riverrunzthruit:
Tommy John is a graft surgery, a repair would be to reattach the ligament to the bone.

But if it's a complete tear as described, don't they have to reconnect point a to point b ? Reattaching to the bone is a detachment right ?
Originally posted by ninersrule4:
This f**king sucks. This team is so God damn cursed

It really is......well....f**ked up.
  • Furlow
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 25,440
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by Furlow:
I don't think Tommy John is off the table yet. Depends on the extent of the damage and where the tear is. Not sure if they even decide before they go in, or while they're in there. Where's that surgeon from yesterday? Dude called it smh...

With Mullens they didn't know until they had gone in for the surgery.

What I was thinking as well. Probably deciding on a doctor to do it at this point.
Originally posted by Furlow:
Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
Originally posted by Furlow:
Originally posted by Oscar8325:
Originally posted by goldlame2013:
Well, time to give the 🐐 a phone call. Or Aaron Rodgers a phone call. Otherwise, we're screwed

No! Either one would demand 20-30+ Mil. We need $$ to sign Aiyuk, Bosa and CMC. Having 2 capable QB's on rookie salaries is what is going to keep our Super Bowl window open for a while. We just need a backup for Trey while Purdy recovers and hopefully it's a 100% recovery, which I fully expect. Most baseball pitchers come back from this I don't see any reason for Brock to be any different.

Agreed. f**k those old dinosaurs. Just roll with Trey if Purdy's not ready week 1. Draft another QB with an elite 10 yard split and fast processing/decision making lol.

No. roll with jimmy for 1.5 years until brock comes back. We will be in playoffs both years. if we sign a RIGHT TACKLE.

Jimmy will likely get starter money ($25M-$35M/year) elsewhere. No way. Now if there's no market for him and he's willing to sign for under $15M, maybe. Even then I'd probably still roll with Trey and just see what he's got. Purdy will be back next season one way or another.

Both on our roster until Brock can throw. 2024. Jimmy starts trey bkup. No more bs.
Originally posted by Oscar8325:
No! Either one would demand 20-30+ Mil. We need $$ to sign Aiyuk, Bosa and CMC. Having 2 capable QB's on rookie salaries is what is going to keep our Super Bowl window open for a while. We just need a backup for Trey while Purdy recovers and hopefully it's a 100% recovery, which I fully expect. Most baseball pitchers come back from this I don't see any reason for Brock to be any different.

Or waste another year with those guys.

In your scenario, you're assuming that a guy who has barely played football in the last four years is going to come in and just light it up. What if he struggles? What if he gets injured again? What is the backup plan there?

There is no SB window if the QB position isn't squared away.
Originally posted by linkboy:
Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
No. roll with jimmy for 1.5 years until brock comes back. We will be in playoffs both years. if we sign a RIGHT TACKLE.

Jimmy's not going to come back when a team will offer him a long term starting job.

Also, where are we going to sign a RT for a reasonable price. It's going to hard to resign McGlinchey (who is average at best).

?



?
hopefully he's on the active roster by mid season

by then we'll know if we continue the season starting trey or not
Originally posted by Hoovtrain:
https://apple.news/Apz6UTGhJSA6U57xeHQzxIw

(link says an anonymous GM feels 9ers will trade Trey to Titans, Sign Brady and Brock backup)

Althought that would be a great situation for Trey and the Titans... and we'd have Brady for a year or so... we don't know how Brock is going to be when he gets back. Jimmy. I'm not talking just about arm strength (improved or not), but more so how the result of that experience will affect him a bit going forward.

Again we are in good situation having two young QBs on rookie deals.
[ Edited by Afrikan on Jan 30, 2023 at 4:04 PM ]
Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
?



?

I'd love it, but I doubt it'll happen.

Kyle should offer him the pizza oven challenge. If Kyle can throw a football into a pizza oven, Staley comes back for a year.
[ Edited by linkboy on Jan 30, 2023 at 4:05 PM ]
Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
No. roll with jimmy for 1.5 years until brock comes back. We will be in playoffs both years. if we sign a RIGHT TACKLE.

Quite a change of tone from all that you said about Jimmy just yesterday in his thread. And now you want him back?

I'm sick to my stomach.

this team is cursed
[ Edited by RiceOwensStokes on Jan 30, 2023 at 4:08 PM ]
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone