QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
The contrived controversy is making me barf. I think we can publish more interesting material for our readers. For example how many snap counts have we lost on the defensive line in free agency, and can we make it up with the Personnel we have? Can someone write a piece about that? For God's sake.

https://www.49erswebzone.com/articles/169276-have-49ers-anointed-brock-purdy-too-soon/

4 games isn't enough to know who a QB will be long term.

8 games isn't enough to know who a QB will be long term.

However you have to start somewhere and Brock played his ass off as a rookie. That's a great place to start but getting him back healthy as soon as possible is huge. Gotta try and evaluate him post injury and along Trey and even Darnold to make sure he's still the best option for the team moving forward.

I can understand people being concerned but it's not like the team is having to pay him right now the way we did with Garoppolo. As long as they don't turn blinders on to other QBs and evaluate Brock and the other guys properly to make the best decision possible then that's all we can ask.

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
The contrived controversy is making me barf. I think we can publish more interesting material for our readers. For example how many snap counts have we lost on the defensive line in free agency, and can we make it up with the Personnel we have? Can someone write a piece about that? For God's sake.

https://www.49erswebzone.com/articles/169276-have-49ers-anointed-brock-purdy-too-soon/

4 games isn't enough to know who a QB will be long term.

8 games isn't enough to know who a QB will be long term.

However you have to start somewhere and Brock played his ass off as a rookie. That's a great place to start but getting him back healthy as soon as possible is huge. Gotta try and evaluate him post injury and along Trey and even Darnold to make sure he's still the best option for the team moving forward.

I can understand people being concerned but it's not like the team is having to pay him right now the way we did with Garoppolo. As long as they don't turn blinders on to other QBs and evaluate Brock and the other guys properly to make the best decision possible then that's all we can ask.

Nobody's concerned. Nobody is continuing to evaluate Brock for the starter role. He's it. If he effs up, they'll look at others. That's the only way we'll consider a Plan B. Meanwhile we'll look at Trey and Darnolld for back up. How simple is that.

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
The contrived controversy is making me barf. I think we can publish more interesting material for our readers. For example how many snap counts have we lost on the defensive line in free agency, and can we make it up with the Personnel we have? Can someone write a piece about that? For God's sake.

https://www.49erswebzone.com/articles/169276-have-49ers-anointed-brock-purdy-too-soon/

4 games isn't enough to know who a QB will be long term.

8 games isn't enough to know who a QB will be long term.

However you have to start somewhere and Brock played his ass off as a rookie. That's a great place to start but getting him back healthy as soon as possible is huge. Gotta try and evaluate him post injury and along Trey and even Darnold to make sure he's still the best option for the team moving forward.

I can understand people being concerned but it's not like the team is having to pay him right now the way we did with Garoppolo. As long as they don't turn blinders on to other QBs and evaluate Brock and the other guys properly to make the best decision possible then that's all we can ask.

Nobody's concerned. Nobody is continuing to evaluate Brock for the starter role. He's it. If he effs up, they'll look at others. That's the only way we'll consider a Plan B. Meanwhile we'll look at Trey and Darnolld for back up. How simple is that.

8 games shouldn't make someone it. If Brock is what he looked like last season then he should win any competition.

Competition is a good thing and when a guy with only 8 games is coming off a serious injury you shouldn't just hand him the job unless of course the other guys don't show anything of worth.

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
The contrived controversy is making me barf. I think we can publish more interesting material for our readers. For example how many snap counts have we lost on the defensive line in free agency, and can we make it up with the Personnel we have? Can someone write a piece about that? For God's sake.

https://www.49erswebzone.com/articles/169276-have-49ers-anointed-brock-purdy-too-soon/

4 games isn't enough to know who a QB will be long term.

8 games isn't enough to know who a QB will be long term.

However you have to start somewhere and Brock played his ass off as a rookie. That's a great place to start but getting him back healthy as soon as possible is huge. Gotta try and evaluate him post injury and along Trey and even Darnold to make sure he's still the best option for the team moving forward.

I can understand people being concerned but it's not like the team is having to pay him right now the way we did with Garoppolo. As long as they don't turn blinders on to other QBs and evaluate Brock and the other guys properly to make the best decision possible then that's all we can ask.

Nobody's concerned. Nobody is continuing to evaluate Brock for the starter role. He's it. If he effs up, they'll look at others. That's the only way we'll consider a Plan B. Meanwhile we'll look at Trey and Darnolld for back up. How simple is that.

8 games shouldn't make someone it. If Brock is what he looked like last season then he should win any competition.

Competition is a good thing and when a guy with only 8 games is coming off a serious injury you shouldn't just hand him the job unless of course the other guys don't show anything of worth.

Except the GM/HC already have. There's nothing Trey can do this off season to derail Brock from starting once healthy. The reality is Trey just isn't in position to get a "fair tryout" here. He can help to instill confidence in QB2 though.

Health issues for Brock is the only chance he'll get in live games to turn the narrative but fortunately for Trey, he and the other 49er QB's are 49er QB's, so the odds of him getting a real in-season tryout is likely around these parts. At least at some point. Probably this year, if we're playing the odds.

Watch the games sometime. He's obviously the best QB on the roster. It's not close.

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
The contrived controversy is making me barf. I think we can publish more interesting material for our readers. For example how many snap counts have we lost on the defensive line in free agency, and can we make it up with the Personnel we have? Can someone write a piece about that? For God's sake.

https://www.49erswebzone.com/articles/169276-have-49ers-anointed-brock-purdy-too-soon/

4 games isn't enough to know who a QB will be long term.

8 games isn't enough to know who a QB will be long term.

However you have to start somewhere and Brock played his ass off as a rookie. That's a great place to start but getting him back healthy as soon as possible is huge. Gotta try and evaluate him post injury and along Trey and even Darnold to make sure he's still the best option for the team moving forward.

I can understand people being concerned but it's not like the team is having to pay him right now the way we did with Garoppolo. As long as they don't turn blinders on to other QBs and evaluate Brock and the other guys properly to make the best decision possible then that's all we can ask.

Nobody's concerned. Nobody is continuing to evaluate Brock for the starter role. He's it. If he effs up, they'll look at others. That's the only way we'll consider a Plan B. Meanwhile we'll look at Trey and Darnolld for back up. How simple is that.

8 games shouldn't make someone it. If Brock is what he looked like last season then he should win any competition.

Competition is a good thing and when a guy with only 8 games is coming off a serious injury you shouldn't just hand him the job unless of course the other guys don't show anything of worth.

The thing is, will he look the same once NFL defenses adjust to him? We are assuming he's going to look the same, but there is a chance he may come crashing down once the league figures him out. See Garoppolo and Kaepernick as examples of this.

I agree with you genus, 8 games is not enought to annoint so let them battle it out.

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Watch the games sometime. He's obviously the best QB on the roster. It's not close.

Like.. at all. lol not even the same realm. I feel like some don't realize that darnold and lances play were among the bottom of the league stats wise when they've played. If they can get in that middle of the league area, I'd be happy cause it's a big step forward.

if darnold and Lance can get to like 70-75% of what Jimmy was efficiency wise, that would be a big leap and I'd be happy. Brock needs to just get healthy and improve upon what he did last season.

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Watch the games sometime. He's obviously the best QB on the roster. It's not close.

Like.. at all. lol not even the same realm. I feel like some don't realize that darnold and lances play were among the bottom of the league stats wise when they've played. If they can get in that middle of the league area, I'd be happy cause it's a big step forward.

if darnold and Lance can get to like 70-75% of what Jimmy was efficiency wise, that would be a big leap and I'd be happy. Brock needs to just get healthy and improve upon what he did last season.

Love Brock but if he doesn't stop that same rolling out pattern that he does every time he's in trouble, his success rate will drop. The tape on him is crystal clear.

Originally posted by NCommand:
Except the GM/HC already have. There's nothing Trey can do this off season to derail Brock from starting once healthy. The reality is Trey just isn't in position to get a "fair tryout" here. He can help to instill confidence in QB2 though.

Health issues for Brock is the only chance he'll get in live games to turn the narrative but fortunately for Trey, he and the other 49er QB's are 49er QB's, so the odds of him getting a real in-season tryout is likely around these parts. At least at some point. Probably this year, if we're playing the odds.

Not true kyle said Lance can earn that QB1 spot. If Brock comes into camp and looks bad they aren't gonna just toss him out there. We all know how much kyle values practice. I agree with the idea that Brock is the leader and will more than likely be the first guy once healthy…I don't think they will allow him to play like s**t for a couple games though. I don't think it's a "it will take an injury" for Lance to get in. Brock has to maintain his play to continue…no long leashes allowed. No development allowed, since this is a Super Bowl roster and all.

Originally posted by NineFourNiner:
Love Brock but if he doesn't stop that same rolling out pattern that he does every time he's in trouble, his success rate will drop. The tape on him is crystal clear.

Go look at his spray chart on next gen. He's awful throwing to the right…don't think for one min defenses aren't gonna recognize that (or the rolling out to the left all the time). He's got work on his internal clock and throw with more anticipation as well. Now he's spending all of season getting healthy and not practicing. It's all but a waste of an off season to improve. It's a bummer for sure

Rushing Purdy back will probably end up with him getting injured again.
He will probably rush himself back if he feels like his #1 spot is in jeopardy to Lance.
This team and QB injuries, its crazy.

Originally posted by NineFourNiner:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Watch the games sometime. He's obviously the best QB on the roster. It's not close.

Like.. at all. lol not even the same realm. I feel like some don't realize that darnold and lances play were among the bottom of the league stats wise when they've played. If they can get in that middle of the league area, I'd be happy cause it's a big step forward.

if darnold and Lance can get to like 70-75% of what Jimmy was efficiency wise, that would be a big leap and I'd be happy. Brock needs to just get healthy and improve upon what he did last season.

Love Brock but if he doesn't stop that same rolling out pattern that he does every time he's in trouble, his success rate will drop. The tape on him is crystal clear.

Yeah, that's why teams like Dallas were baiting him into it. Brock isn't perfect and that fault is something he's acknowledged and said he is working on. I don't think that's something to be overly concerned about, it's fixed quite easily.

when you say "tape is crystal clear on him", are you saying he's been "figured out"? Lol cause that makes no sense, unless you mean you can stop him by destroying his UCL. Lol

chuck Pagano, a former HC and awesome DC, was asked specifically about how long it would take to figure Brock out film wise. His answer was "it takes about 2-3 games to figure a player out" and said Brock is playing like a real qb. Not some gimmick.

you could be right, but I don't think so. He has numerous areas to improve and I think he will. At least I hope so hahaha

I'm not sure that a habit developed over a dozen years or so is easily fixed. I hope he cleans it up. He's got the tools to do so.

Ladies and gentlemen the 49ers now have their very own Drew Brees....well at least by comparison!!!!

Originally posted by NDSU:
Rushing Purdy back will probably end up with him getting injured again.
He will probably rush himself back if he feels like his #1 spot is in jeopardy to Lance.
This team and QB injuries, its crazy.