What will Jimmy's trade value be in the offseason?

They got too many picks and too big a void at the position. Make it happen.

https://www.ninersnation.com/2022/3/23/22992020/49ers-in-five-how-possible-is-houston-for-jimmy-garoppolo-news-trade

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by 4ML:
Jimmy is a QB who is in the last year of his contract. Any team trading for him will want to renegotiate a new contract with him. It doesn't matter whether he is elite or average. If a team is willing to shell out 2 2nd round picks (you can say he is average but 2 2nd round picks are pretty valuable) - the team will like to know if Jimmy plans to stay with them beyond this year.

It is well within Jimmy's right to say - I will not re-sign with you as a FA. Jimmy has every right to say where he will NOT play when he becomes a FA. Nothing to do with elite or average and nor does it have anything to do with him dictating anything. He is just exercising his right as a FA in 2023.

Yup. One rough aspect is the injury history. Really didn't have an extensive injury history when we gave him the $137m. Now he does. And he's older. Any club may want $15m / year range that Winston was around, and he may totally balk at that as it's a 40% pay cut. Who here would sign up for losing 40% of your check? JL got his work cut out gotta get JG on board with any trade, JG's agent, a new club, get the proper comp, real challenge, he's up to it though imo.

Not really. He can either get Jimmy on board OR the team on board. If the team only wants him for a year or two, to ̶g̶r̶o̶o̶m̶ keep the team afloat for his eventual replacement, they may be fine with the current contract and one possible Franchise tender. Jimmy, on the other hand, can be sad about it, but he's not going to hold out, nor would it be wise to do so.

I mean get JG on board in the sense that if he isn't on board he can say he won't extend there which may cause the team offering picks to pull back their offer. Not concerned about his feelings he's got $137m and his own sandwich he'll be fine. I see what you are saying tho they could tag didn't consider that.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
They got too many picks and too big a void at the position. Make it happen.

https://www.ninersnation.com/2022/3/23/22992020/49ers-in-five-how-possible-is-houston-for-jimmy-garoppolo-news-trade

IMO Panthers make a lot of sense too. They can easily finish at 2 in their division with Jimmy and possibly 1 if father time starts to catch up with Brady. They can draft a QB and groom him behind Jimmy for a year - maybe 2 if Jimmy plays well - since there are no elite prospects - there will be no pressure to start them in year 2. Their HC is going into year 3 of his contract and may be under some pressure to at least contend for a playoff spot.

Originally posted by 4ML:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
They got too many picks and too big a void at the position. Make it happen.

https://www.ninersnation.com/2022/3/23/22992020/49ers-in-five-how-possible-is-houston-for-jimmy-garoppolo-news-trade

IMO Panthers make a lot of sense too. They can easily finish at 2 in their division with Jimmy and possibly 1 if father time starts to catch up with Brady. They can draft a QB and groom him behind Jimmy for a year - maybe 2 if Jimmy plays well - since there are no elite prospects - there will be no pressure to start them in year 2. Their HC is going into year 3 of his contract and may be under some pressure to at least contend for a playoff spot.

My guess is Carolina is drafting Willis at 6 or they will trade down with the Seahawks and still draft Pickett or someone.

Originally posted by Waterbear:

Originally posted by 4ML:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
They got too many picks and too big a void at the position. Make it happen.

https://www.ninersnation.com/2022/3/23/22992020/49ers-in-five-how-possible-is-houston-for-jimmy-garoppolo-news-trade

IMO Panthers make a lot of sense too. They can easily finish at 2 in their division with Jimmy and possibly 1 if father time starts to catch up with Brady. They can draft a QB and groom him behind Jimmy for a year - maybe 2 if Jimmy plays well - since there are no elite prospects - there will be no pressure to start them in year 2. Their HC is going into year 3 of his contract and may be under some pressure to at least contend for a playoff spot.

My guess is Carolina is drafting Willis at 6 or they will trade down with the Seahawks and still draft Pickett or someone.

Yea I have read that too. I think it's way too high but that has never QB needy teams to reach for a QB. So, it is quite possible. I still think they can offer a 2nd in 2023 draft and trade for Jimmy for this year and keep Willis on the training wheels for a year and see where things are at the end of the season.

Or maybe they're smart and will play their high draft pick and not waste valuable cap space on Jimmy.

Originally posted by 4ML:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
They got too many picks and too big a void at the position. Make it happen.

https://www.ninersnation.com/2022/3/23/22992020/49ers-in-five-how-possible-is-houston-for-jimmy-garoppolo-news-trade

IMO Panthers make a lot of sense too. They can easily finish at 2 in their division with Jimmy and possibly 1 if father time starts to catch up with Brady. They can draft a QB and groom him behind Jimmy for a year - maybe 2 if Jimmy plays well - since there are no elite prospects - there will be no pressure to start them in year 2. Their HC is going into year 3 of his contract and may be under some pressure to at least contend for a playoff spot.

With Panthers would love to see a deal. My understanding reading up on them they are really taking a long hard look at the draft. They may simply draft early a QB and go rookie probably starting and Darnold as a fallback if the rook isn't ready. That's how I see it trending as of now if I had to guess their plan. This is not what I would be doing but it's what I am seeing from them. If they were to draft a rook behind JG we would need to take on Darnold ala the Peter King trade. Just someone inform Peter King that Darnold is not an asset we would need additional comp to eat that bad contract.

Imo it would be stupid for the Panthers to rely on a rookie QB to save Rhule and the GMs job. Rhule might not even make it through the season. He has to be banging the table for a veteran QB. Rather that is Jimmy or Baker. If I was him I would have been going hard after the other QBs who were already signed/traded. I'm sure he was but no QB wants him as their coach, he is Joe Judge level of bad. If they get decent QB play they probably make the playoffs in the weak NFC

Originally posted by 4ML:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Kolohe:
So by your logic Jimmy should've waived his NTC cause he's not on par with Wilson and Watson and instead should choose to go to a s**tty organization?? So much fail in your post and biased opinion.

Also no one wants Jimmy because of his shoulder injury not because of the player he is. How you people can't process that is beyond me, you guy act like he didn't do s**t to help the team get to the Super Bowl and playoffs.

This fanbase is getting to be embarrassing. No wonder they call us whiners.

Stop saying Jimmy has a no-trade clause to waive he never had that for this season. Stop bringing it up.

if someone really really wanted him he would be on another team. His injury would not make a team pass on some great QB….I mean if Watson was coming off the same injury you think no one would have gotten in line to trade for him lol? Stop. Teams were lining up for him even while being a sexual predator.

If Watson was in his last year of his contract and told interested teams - you can trade for me but I will not re-sign with you next summer - do you think those teams would still be lining up for him?

Jimmy's agent pulled a fast one on this FO. He negotiated a NTC in 2021 and he got essentially another NTC in 2022 without having to negotiate for it - bc he can dictate where he will play by saying - I won't re-sign with you in 2023. Smart move by the agent.

There isn'ta no trade clause for this year but what I believe tire referring to is that Jimmy can just say that he won't sign long term deal with the new team essentially enforcing a sort of no trade clause. The thing is that most players on last year deal either agree to a long term deal with new team or they are a one and done. This isn't like some new thing.

Von Miller traded to Rams. One and done moved on to Bills etc.

Jimmy's trade value is probably a 5th rounder or whatever a backup QB is traded for because Jimmy is officially now Lance's backup.

Originally posted by Joecool:
Jimmy's trade value is probably a 5th rounder or whatever a backup QB is traded for because Jimmy is officially now Lance's backup.

Where is that official?

Just cut him already, let's move on ! Use that $ to sign a slot CB, 1 of Steven Nelson, Bryce Callahan or Tavon Young would be nice.

Originally posted by 4ML:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Kolohe:
So by your logic Jimmy should've waived his NTC cause he's not on par with Wilson and Watson and instead should choose to go to a s**tty organization?? So much fail in your post and biased opinion.

Also no one wants Jimmy because of his shoulder injury not because of the player he is. How you people can't process that is beyond me, you guy act like he didn't do s**t to help the team get to the Super Bowl and playoffs.

This fanbase is getting to be embarrassing. No wonder they call us whiners.

Stop saying Jimmy has a no-trade clause to waive he never had that for this season. Stop bringing it up.

if someone really really wanted him he would be on another team. His injury would not make a team pass on some great QB….I mean if Watson was coming off the same injury you think no one would have gotten in line to trade for him lol? Stop. Teams were lining up for him even while being a sexual predator.

If Watson was in his last year of his contract and told interested teams - you can trade for me but I will not re-sign with you next summer - do you think those teams would still be lining up for him?

Jimmy's agent pulled a fast one on this FO. He negotiated a NTC in 2021 and he got essentially another NTC in 2022 without having to negotiate for it - bc he can dictate where he will play by saying - I won't re-sign with you in 2023. Smart move by the agent.

I'm not sure why this is so hard for people to understand.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by Joecool:

Jimmy's trade value is probably a 5th rounder or whatever a backup QB is traded for because Jimmy is officially now Lance's backup.

Where is that official?

Originally posted by Strwy2Hevn:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by Joecool:
Jimmy's trade value is probably a 5th rounder or whatever a backup QB is traded for because Jimmy is officially now Lance's backup.

Where is that official?

Somebody didn't get the memo.

Originally posted by Joecool:

Originally posted by Strwy2Hevn:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by Joecool:
Jimmy's trade value is probably a 5th rounder or whatever a backup QB is traded for because Jimmy is officially now Lance's backup.

Where is that official?

Somebody didn't get the memo.

I'm wondering did they put something out recently?