Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 587 users in the forums

Most concerning

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by Jeepzilla:
We are paying over $8 mill for a backup right now
....lol
It's all good though. It's not my money and they made these decisions with Ward and AA so hopefully one of them works out

Yes when they gave Ward that 5th yr option he was currently our starting FS....apples to oranges there
Raise your hand if you think our starting half back will be someone other than Jerick McKinnon at years end?
Originally posted by 49erphan:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Certainly some things they need to clean up in a hurry:
* Blown coverages in the defense
* Miscommunications in the secondary (Tartt)
* Consistent run game
* Crucial penalties in the RZ (repeat pattern from last year)
* Dumb penalties (repeat pattern from last year)
* RZ efficiency (TD's not FG's)
* Defending the seam pass/QB scrambling

I think that sums up most of the issues pretty well. The details behind each bullet point are probably interesting. Would you be willing to take each bullet point and expand out who seems to be most responsible for the team being too subpar in that area? Is it lack of talent in a certain position group or is it that the players or coaches aren't using their talent to its full potential to create better execution on the field? Do you have any recommendations how on to rectify each of these concerns? Is that too many questions?

Only if I start answering your questions with questions. LOL. I'll give it a go but all, feel free to chime in.

* Blown coverages in the defense
* Miscommunications in the secondary (Tartt)
--- we didn't see many blown coverages last year so the fact that we've had a few here in pre season may be an indication that we're working on some new concepts and/or just mental or communication errors. I chalk this up to a combo of both players and tryout scheme.

* Consistent run game
--- it seems like when Kyle makes it a priority to focus on, we're great. While the overall scheme is sound, it looks bad if one player misses an assignment. I chalk this up to chemistry and time needed for the OL to gel and injuries to the RB's; they all dance together in unison.

* Crucial penalties in the RZ (repeat pattern from last year)
* Dumb penalties (repeat pattern from last year)
* RZ efficiency (TD's not FG's)
--- this is a repeat pattern from last year and every time, it's a different player. This game, it was Garçon, Tomlinson, Nzeocha, Buckner, Witherspoon, Garnett, formation penalties with Goodwin, etc. Cause? Pure player concentration. Given that it still exists may be a sign Shanahan needs to tighten it up. Also personnel...if we don't have the horses for RZ success, everyone is on edge and flinching, itching to make a play or blocking illegally because of the importance being inside the RZ.

* Defending the seam pass/QB scrambling
--- in this scheme, there are two natural holes; seam routes and those sneaky running QB's. Ironically, both can be defended well with our LB's and S's, This comes down to player recognition and communication.
[ Edited by NCommand on Aug 26, 2018 at 5:00 PM ]
Originally posted by socal1632:
Honestly Richard Sherman was a bigger presence on the sideline than Saleh. He was up and down the sideline coaching the guys during the game. Sometimes out onto the field

Yea I saw that lol
Personnally and this is just me.....I don't really start worrying or formulating harden opinions until at least 4 regular season games have been played. We have no clue what the 2018 Niners personality is really gonna be.

I don't start fretting until I've seen real games. That's why I f**king hate preseason. Outside of the risk of injuries, it also gives this snap shot of something close to football but not really football. Hell, look at 2011 if you based everything on preseason we looked like 2 win team destined to be in the Andrew Luck sweepstakes. Now look at that team after 4 games, it was pretty apparent something special was going on.
[ Edited by Niners816 on Aug 26, 2018 at 6:10 PM ]
Originally posted by NCommand:
Only if I start answering your questions with questions. LOL. I'll give it a go but all, feel free to chime in.

* Blown coverages in the defense
* Miscommunications in the secondary (Tartt)
--- we didn't see many blown coverages last year so the fact that we've had a few here in pre season may be an indication that we're working on some new concepts and/or just mental or communication errors. I chalk this up to a combo of both players and tryout scheme.

* Consistent run game
--- it seems like when Kyle makes it a priority to focus on, we're great. While the overall scheme is sound, it looks bad if one player misses an assignment. I chalk this up to chemistry and time needed for the OL to gel and injuries to the RB's; they all dance together in unison.

* Crucial penalties in the RZ (repeat pattern from last year)
* Dumb penalties (repeat pattern from last year)
* RZ efficiency (TD's not FG's)
--- this is a repeat pattern from last year and every time, it's a different player. This game, it was Garçon, Tomlinson, Nzeocha, Buckner, Witherspoon, Garnett, formation penalties with Goodwin, etc. Cause? Pure player concentration. Given that it still exists may be a sign Shanahan needs to tighten it up. Also personnel...if we don't have the horses for RZ success, everyone is on edge and flinching, itching to make a play or blocking illegally because of the importance being inside the RZ.

* Defending the seam pass/QB scrambling
--- in this scheme, there are two natural holes; seam routes and those sneaky running QB's. Ironically, both can be defended well with our LB's and S's, This comes down to player recognition and communication.

Solid post NC!
  • Giedi
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 35,268
Originally posted by Niners816:
Personnally and this is just me.....I don't really start worrying or formulating harden opinions until at least 4 games have been played. We have no clue what the 2018 Niners personality is really gonna be.

I don't start fretting until I've seen real games. That's why I f**king hate preseason. Outside of the risk of injuries, it also gives this snap shot of something close to football but not really football. Hell, look at 2011 if you based everything on preseason we looked like 2 win team destined to be in the Andrew Luck sweepstakes. Now look at that team after 4 games, it was pretty apparent something special was going on.

Yeah, it's really hard to see where this team is going. Just talking specifically pass rush, I know the pocket was collapsing on Luck, but the sacks were just not there. Is that because of miscommunication or bad tackling skills? I can't tell and the 4rth pre-season game isn't going to be helpful because none of the starters are going to play and I would think the 2nds would be playing real brief. I just hope no major injuries in the 4rth game and hopefully everybody will be healthy as much as possible that first game.
Originally posted by Niners816:
Personnally and this is just me.....I don't really start worrying or formulating harden opinions until at least 4 games have been played. We have no clue what the 2018 Niners personality is really gonna be.

I don't start fretting until I've seen real games. That's why I f**king hate preseason. Outside of the risk of injuries, it also gives this snap shot of something close to football but not really football. Hell, look at 2011 if you based everything on preseason we looked like 2 win team destined to be in the Andrew Luck sweepstakes. Now look at that team after 4 games, it was pretty apparent something special was going on.

Yep, 4 games Paints a more accurate picture.
Originally posted by susweel:
That's what happens when the head coach tries to be one of the guys.

That dang blasted hippity hop music.
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,633
Originally posted by BleedsRedNGold:
Originally posted by susweel:
That's what happens when the head coach tries to be one of the guys.

That dang blasted hippity hop music.

Truth. There just isn't any harmony. It's all about the beat. Nobody hears anything else.

Originally posted by Niners816:
Personnally and this is just me.....I don't really start worrying or formulating harden opinions until at least 4 regular season games have been played. We have no clue what the 2018 Niners personality is really gonna be.

I don't start fretting until I've seen real games. That's why I f**king hate preseason. Outside of the risk of injuries, it also gives this snap shot of something close to football but not really football. Hell, look at 2011 if you based everything on preseason we looked like 2 win team destined to be in the Andrew Luck sweepstakes. Now look at that team after 4 games, it was pretty apparent something special was going on.

I mean sounds like a logical way to look at it
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by Jeepzilla:
We are paying over $8 mill for a backup right now
....lol
It's all good though. It's not my money and they made these decisions with Ward and AA so hopefully one of them works out

Yes when they gave Ward that 5th yr option he was currently our starting FS....apples to oranges there

Not really..
How do you relay on a "starter" who's out constantly?
He shouldn't have been given the 5th year.
He's constantly injured. Not his fault, but can't count on him.
It was a mistake by the front office.

Was hoping they learn from there mistakes but they give it to AA then.

I guess if AA works out they're batting 50%... be a high batting average, if this was baseball

We're all hoping Ward & AA stay healthy and play great, but past is best predictor of future and it's not looking good. Hopefully these two top picks turn it around for, what.... one year of there, Combined 9 years of play.
Originally posted by SanFranFanfrmVa:
Originally posted by Jiks:
Originally posted by SanFranFanfrmVa:
We can talk about the pass rush and other things concerning us but in my opinion the most concerning thing on this team is concentration,discipline, and penalties. We saw the same things last season and it hasn't gotten any better. This team continues to beat itself time after time. This has to fall on the coaching staff and they better address it before week 1.
The first half was played pretty damn well minus the lack of discipline. As you said hopefully it gets ironed out by week one.
How many times in the preseason have we just left players wide open with no one covering them at all. Yesterday I saw missed assignments on defense and I also saw some players playing zone when we were in man to man coverage. I'm not sold on Robert Saleh as a defensive coordinator at all.

Sometimes I like to think of it as trying to invent a new style of a play with part zone / part man trying to confuse the offens . Maybe Saleh is experamenting
Originally posted by simplyfloyd:
Raise your hand if you think our starting half back will be someone other than Jerick McKinnon at years end?

  • DrNo
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 19
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by longterm9erfan:
Great post, NY.... I would add to what you stated about the youth of the team that several of the penalties called on the team this preseason have been bad calls...the one on Mostert, a few of the holding calls, a couple of the new helmet hit calls, etc. Also, let us not forget that in the preseason, coaches are very conservative (both on offense and defense) and don't want to show too much. Also, the players themselves, if they have secured a roster spot, may be playing at 80-85 % so as to avoid injury No player wants to go on IR for the year as a result of an injury in a preseason game. (Foster needs to learn this).

As far as concerns are concerned, , I would share that the outside LB group in general looks average at best. When a team trades its starting OLB 2 weeks before the season starts, that should tell you something. Look for the team to watch the waiver wire closely for OLBs. I'm less concerned about the secondary, despite its overall youth. There is some good talent back there and the coaching seems first rate. I'm also encouraged by the overall play of the OL. Let us also not forget that it takes time for an OL to gel and there are 3 new starters on the line this year.

Finally, the failure of the pass rushers to wrap up and actually sack the QB is a concern. It seems that many players are concerned about getting flags for hitting a QB too hard, too high, too low, etc. You guys get the picture. Frankly, I'm more concerned about the league and the officiating than I am about our team. IMHO, the league should take all of the officials off the field and put them in the booth. It is really hard to see the infractions from ground level because of all of the bodies obstructing the views. Also, replays now are done in 10-15 seconds so it would be easy to make calls (or fix bad calls) faster. Just my 2 cents.

Cheers!

Totally agree

Watching some high profiled national televised games ( especially Sunday games) I saw how the refs called penalties against specific teams ( such as Dallas and Buffalo as of today) I KIND OF PREDICT WHICH TEAMS WILL WIN FOR SURE. Talking in person to some national renown sport betting " advisors" I was told that " sharps money" are usually, most likely made from betting preseason games !!! Now WITH THE HELMET HIT RULE THE REFS WILL HAVE MORE POWER AT EASE TO DICTATE THE GAME. Be careful football bettors !!!
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone