49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Originally posted by KSRULES:
As a newish member, this thread is very helpful in telling me who I should block.

That's not surprising at all considering your username.

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by DrEll:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by DrEll:
Why didnt we win the Super Bowl in 2023 ? With a stacked roster and no injuries ?

No injuries? Dre Greenlaw and Feliciano would like a word.

It was our least injured season but those two injuries were both critical in the SB itself. Which given your need to only concentrate on that single game should matter.

LB 2 and subpar OLineman. Got it. Maybe the water boy broke a fingernail and that contributed. If you can't coach a contingency plan for LB 2, then you're not doing a good job at your job.

Once again you're either a troll or a casual. There is no inbetween with responses like that.

We all watched that game. I know you're aware of the issues each of those injuries presented so you're playing dumb just to keep a stupid argument going in circles.

The first time you have a genuine point to make on this forum will be your first one.

These callouts of being a troll or casual need to stop. Seriously dude.

The guy is making legit conversation and you of all people are calling him out.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
How can you not care about the comeback stat? Look how many games we see every week with teams coming back in the 4th quarter for wins. I'm not saying Kyle should win all thise games but with the talent he's had most years hiis record in games like that sould be better. Maybe .500 or at least .300. 9-21 wouldn't be great but it sure looks better than 1-29.

9ers came back in the 4th vs the Bears.

its a b******t stat when you dig into the details. great for low IQ arguments tho.

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:

Originally posted by KSRULES:
As a newish member, this thread is very helpful in telling me who I should block.

That's not surprising at all considering your username.

Let me give you some history for perspective.

JG was a yellow jacket hall of famer on this forum even as a Raider. There is a reason the JG thread reached 10000+. You will figure out who wears the rosies and lives in candyland.

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:

Originally posted by KSRULES:
As a newish member, this thread is very helpful in telling me who I should block.

That's not surprising at all considering your username.

Let me give you some history for perspective.

JG was a yellow jacket hall of famer on this forum even as a Raider. There is a reason the JG thread reached 10000+. You will figure out who wears the rosies and lives in candyland.

There's nothing wrong with being a homer. But the extremes some fan will go just to protect one entity without looking at the team as a whole is ridiculous. I remember there used to be a large contingency of Alex Smith fans that would defend him endlessly, just blaming everything and everyone around him but not willing to point the finger at the common denominator.

Originally posted by TD49ers:
Let me give you some history for perspective.

JG was a yellow jacket hall of famer on this forum even as a Raider. There is a reason the JG thread reached 10000+. You will figure out who wears the rosies and lives in candyland.

Lol… what?

Originally posted by DrEll:

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:

Originally posted by KSRULES:
As a newish member, this thread is very helpful in telling me who I should block.

That's not surprising at all considering your username.

Let me give you some history for perspective.

JG was a yellow jacket hall of famer on this forum even as a Raider. There is a reason the JG thread reached 10000+. You will figure out who wears the rosies and lives in candyland.

There's nothing wrong with being a homer. But the extremes some fan will go just to protect one entity without looking at the team as a whole is ridiculous. I remember there used to be a large contingency of Alex Smith fans that would defend him endlessly, just blaming everything and everyone around him but not willing to point the finger at the common denominator.

Yep

Originally posted by DrEll:
There's nothing wrong with being a homer. But the extremes some fan will go just to protect one entity without looking at the team as a whole is ridiculous. I remember there used to be a large contingency of Alex Smith fans that would defend him endlessly, just blaming everything and everyone around him but not willing to point the finger at the common denominator.

The lack of self awareness in this post is pretty amazing.

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by TD49ers:
So Shanys record trailing at halftime by 7+ since 2017 is beyond poor......how should we spin this?

Site your source.

Make sure to list other coaches in the same situation and feel free to include the QBs who have attempted those come backs.

I don't care about other teams or other coaches.

We are talking about the 49ers and our coach

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by DrEll:
The genuine point is that you can't make an argument for every single mishap that happens to the team as the sole reasons for their losses. This year the argument is that LB 1 and DE 1 both HOF caliber players went down so we can't win. Fine. But then you go back to 2023 where LB 1 and DE 1 are both on the field healthy, so now you blame LB 2 and OL 5 getting hurt and that's why we couldn't win.

Maybe your coach learns from his mistakes and realizes that the roster is so top heavy that any injury to one of your starters makes you go from favorite to lucky we even got in to the playoffs. Last year everyone pointed to CMC being hurt, so we go out and get BRob who doesn't even see the field.

You can't keep using the same excuses in loops to downplay Shanahan's role in this. God forbid next year CMC falls apart because his legs are done. Or another cog on defense goes down. Are you going to roll with the "aw shucks wait until next year guys when Kyle has his team at full throttle" ? Try something else. We had AMPLE opportunities to put away the Chiefs in both Superbowls. Kyle shat the bed both times. And you guys will go into micromanage mode and blame broken plays and players fault for everything, not acknowledging that Kyle had the opportunity to call a different play or make a different decision and maybe the outcome is different.

Yes. This is totally rational.

Forget that the plays were there to be made. A real HC would've known that his players wouldn't execute as designed on that play and call a different one!

Brilliant stuff.

And you wonder why people think you're trolling?

And who is the mastermind behind the roster building?

I will use Spencer Burford as an example in the Chris Jones block. Who drafted him?

Or how about we are going against one of the greatest interior linemen to play and we have one chance to score the game winning TD so he calls a protection to leave Jones with 1 in 1 blocking vs Chris Jones who has singlehandedly wrecked our offensive gameplan all game. Thats just brilliant right there.

That said, my biggest beef with Shanahan isn't his coaching even though he has been conservative at times, it's the laundry list of horrible personnel and draft decisions.

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by TD49ers:
Maybe you missed it. I cant block you.

I dont care what you think. Do no reply to my post.

lol poor whiny fan

I know....thats why.

Everyone else blocks people who criticize Shanahan but they aren't whiny. What are they then? Homers?

Originally posted by RickyRoma:

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
The only real flaw in Kyle's record, and it's a big one is his W-L record when trailing by 7 or more at halftime. He hasn't shown that he can make adjustments when his teams fall behind. It's not all on him but as HC he has to acknowledge that he hasn't done well when trailing entering the 2nd half.

That's largely because of the QB's that Shanahan has basically had since 2017. I'm not one to really care much about the comeback stat, but they do attribute that to the QB's....not the HC's.

And whose fault is it that we chose to have those QB's on the roster?

Who chooses to go into 2017 with Brian Freaking Hoyer? Hell, take Trubisky at 1.2

It would have been a 10x better pick that Solomon Thomas

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
And whose fault is it that we chose to have those QB's on the roster?

Who chooses to go into 2017 with Brian Freaking Hoyer? Hell, take Trubisky at 1.2

It would have been a 10x better pick that Solomon Thomas

Or Ruben Foster

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
And whose fault is it that we chose to have those QB's on the roster?

Who chooses to go into 2017 with Brian Freaking Hoyer? Hell, take Trubisky at 1.2

It would have been a 10x better pick that Solomon Thomas

Or Ruben Foster

Or trading Deforest Buckner and replacing him with Javon Kinlaw.

And then giving the same contract we could have given to Buckner to Javon Hargrave.

Or keeping JG over Brady when Brady wanted to come here. Then Brady goes on to win a SB with Tampa.

Or not taking the Aiuyk trade to the Steelers for a 2 and 3.

Or the worst draft trade in NFL history. Trey Lance.

Or taking Jake Moody in the 3rd. Back to back bust RB's in the 3rd. Dante Pettis in round 2. Jalen Hurd in round 3. Cameron Latu in the 3rd. Danny Gray in the 3rd. Drake Jackson in the 2nd. Ambry Thomas in the 3rd.

It's just horrific roster building and drafting propped up by two good trades for CMC and Trent Williams. When those two leave this team is cooked.