Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 431 users in the forums

49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online

49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Originally posted by 9moon:
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Originally posted by 9moon:
Originally posted by alwayssecond:
Heartbreak after heartbreak

this f**king team

shanahan and all the ofrense were disgusting tonight

3 points for the BEST " USED TO BE YOUNG" MIND IN FOOTBALL..

They had poor starting position most of the game because the defense wasn't doing their part. Even when the Seahawks didn't score they ate up clock and drove deep enough that they kept the Niners bottled up.

If we were Seahawks fans we would be braggung about how great the defense did against a high scoring offense.

... and i'll keep going back to my OLDEST POINT that Shanny just clueless when it's time to ADJUST.. everyone saw how good Seattle's D was playing.. yet, nothing changed in the 2nd half w/the way he was calling the plays..

.. and at least, DEMAND Saleh to get off that BLANKET COVERAGE where the targets continue to just find holes after holes..

What are you babbling about man? What would YOU change?

Let's just ignore the big drive we had in the 2nd half that should've been a TD instead of a pick of CMCs hands.

Our starting field position in the 2nd half was on our 12, 9, 30(which was that drive) and 20(with 2:20 left down 10)

What are you "adjusting"?
Originally posted by zeppfan1:
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by BYisGod:
Are either of you Grant Cohn? He posted this right around the same time…


Case of double plagiarism, lol.
Lol, great minds think alike.

Oof, If I ever get to the stage in life where I think Grant Cohn is a great mind, please pull the plug and put me out of my suffering.
  • bvc49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,758
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by BYisGod:
Are either of you Grant Cohn? He posted this right around the same time…


Case of double plagiarism, lol.

This boils my blood.
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by socal1632:
Now you're going into next year depending on a DE with a history of 3 knees, to hold up. There is nothing else on that line, except run stuffers. You traded away Huff and Greenlaw. What is the point of this franchise. 32 years. 32 years. 32 years.

Some of you guys come in here simply just to complain. You're contradicting your thoughts in your own post.

You're concerned about injuries but in the next sentence complain about the team "trading" away Huf(Huff is the guy we traded for who is on the team...who also happens to be only a pass rusher which contradicts your run stuffer only point) and Greenlaw - both players who have a large injury history who also have nothing to do with line play since they're a safety and a linebacker.

What is the point of this franchise the man says...as they're in the playoffs despite crazy impact injuries in a retool season.

Folks can't keep s**t real. Complain about Greenlaw and Huff being gone, yet they couldn't stay on the field….then complaining about injured players. Lol

buddy acts like going to multiple SBs, NFCCs and taking a team that everyone thought was a sub .500 team to 12 wins and a playoff appearance is some s**tty thing isn't being serious with objective debating. They're simply hating and trying to cherry pick anything negative about Kyle all while contradicting themselves.

If they got out of their little Kyle hater club bubble they're understand how bad the coaching is in the NFL. Every yr it's like 6-10 teams looking for a new HC.

the takes are so f**king stupid in here. Bunch of whiny fans.
I think he's hindered by his s**t GM.
Originally posted by Monsterniner:
Originally posted by Ninerforever:
Kyle is up for COTY, anyone who wants to get rid of him is just plain stupid. How do we even have a shot at first seed? Kyle is a genius.

He is good enough to make the playoffs and keep getting extensions but he isn't good enough to take that final jump.

Shanahan is the Prescott of the coaches.

Dan Marino is the analogy you want...for now at least.

Prescott has never seen an NFC Championship. Kyle has been to 4.

And I'm going to avoid getting into this discussion again cuz we've done this dance so many times in this thread but unlike QBs...coaches don't actually PLAY.

Shanahan has had the team in position to make that final jump every one of those seasons. But players have to make plays there to be made.

This is a perfect example


Two plays that regardless of how bad we played the rest of the game potentially flip that game from a loss to a win. Both plays our players failed to come up with the big play, or in CMC's play at least mitigate the problem.

That happens in games. That's why people here acting like Shanahan can't win the big one refuse to step back and analyze each game on its own. Yes Kyle threw up a stinker in that game but it happens. The difference between wins and losses are sometimes players either not making a critical mistake or making a critical play.
  • DrEll
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 10,377
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by socal1632:
Now you're going into next year depending on a DE with a history of 3 knees, to hold up. There is nothing else on that line, except run stuffers. You traded away Huff and Greenlaw. What is the point of this franchise. 32 years. 32 years. 32 years.

Some of you guys come in here simply just to complain. You're contradicting your thoughts in your own post.

You're concerned about injuries but in the next sentence complain about the team "trading" away Huf(Huff is the guy we traded for who is on the team...who also happens to be only a pass rusher which contradicts your run stuffer only point) and Greenlaw - both players who have a large injury history who also have nothing to do with line play since they're a safety and a linebacker.

What is the point of this franchise the man says...as they're in the playoffs despite crazy impact injuries in a retool season.

Folks can't keep s**t real. Complain about Greenlaw and Huff being gone, yet they couldn't stay on the field….then complaining about injured players. Lol

buddy acts like going to multiple SBs, NFCCs and taking a team that everyone thought was a sub .500 team to 12 wins and a playoff appearance is some s**tty thing isn't being serious with objective debating. They're simply hating and trying to cherry pick anything negative about Kyle all while contradicting themselves.

If they got out of their little Kyle hater club bubble they're understand how bad the coaching is in the NFL. Every yr it's like 6-10 teams looking for a new HC.

the takes are so f**king stupid in here. Bunch of whiny fans.

Yet two guys…Mike McDonald and Ben Johnson (both candidates that were brought up repeatedly when Kyle's fan club asked "well, who would you replace him with?") have their teams primed for a deep run.

Oh, and there's this guy that everyone laughed at…

https://www.49erswebzone.com/forum/nfl/196292-two-wordshellipsean-payton/

Three potential quality candidates that could have replaced Shanahan and had this team primed for a SB run, but no….you guys like to pretend there are no good coaches around except for Shanahan
Kyle fine for a few years. Everyone knows this D is dogs**t and we have been competitive because of the offense and ST. We need more talent in key positions and we've let people go, and retained some we shouldn't have. That's FO decisions that will be pinned on Lynch, assuming the ownership sees him as his own decision maker.
Originally posted by BYisGod:
Originally posted by maximusdecimus:
Tonges and kittle have been on the field together 7 times this season.
that's a helluva way to maximize your roster Kyle.

What's wild is that we've been clamoring for a good backup TE for an eternity. Now we have one…and we don't play him.

Tonges is good as a receiver but he's not a good blocker. Scheme wise he's basically TE3. How many 3 TE sets do we run? That takes Juice off the field.

Maybe it's something we do in the playoffs but let's not act like Tonges is the key to unlocking the offense lol. When Seattle is able to stop our run game playing nickel...a TE who's not a great blocker isn't going to suddenly break things open.
Ben Johnson, whose Bears we just beat head to head? Whose Bears finished the season with the same record we have and are only the #2 seed because, unlike us, they don't play in the toughest division in football? That Ben Johnson?

Like I think he's a very good coach but this is not the clear upgrade you seem to think it is. His biggest appeal is that we don't know him as well as we know Kyle.
Originally posted by DrEll:
Yet two guys…Mike McDonald and Ben Johnson (both candidates that were brought up repeatedly when Kyle's fan club asked "well, who would you replace him with?") have their teams primed for a deep run.

Oh, and there's this guy that everyone laughed at…

https://www.49erswebzone.com/forum/nfl/196292-two-wordshellipsean-payton/

Three potential quality candidates that could have replaced Shanahan and had this team primed for a SB run, but no….you guys like to pretend there are no good coaches around except for Shanahan

Ben Johnson? You mean the guy we just beat and lost yesterday? You mean Ben Johnson who had the biggest meltdown in Lions playoff history? So god damn hypocritical

Last I checked McDonald and Ben haven't done more than Kyle. Both dudes could be one and done in the playoffs just as easy and you know it….only difference is you will have all kinds of excuses for them. They don't win the SB then what?? They suck according to your logic.

Let's use some more of your logic. Payton is being propped up with a #1 defense not his 15th ranked offense that is suppose to be all him.

McDonald's offense only got what 13 pts vs SFs JV defense? Wow really primed up lol. Good job Seattle you guys are mostly healthy right now why we're forced to toss out our backups to the backups.
[ Edited by NYniner85 on Jan 5, 2026 at 9:34 AM ]
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Ben Johnson? You mean the guy we just beat and lost yesterday? You mean Ben Johnson who had the biggest meltdown in Lions playoff history? So god damn hypocritical

Last I checked McDonald and Ben haven't done more than Kyle. Both dudes could be one and done in the playoffs just as easy and you know it….only difference is you will have all kinds of excuses for them. They don't win the SB then what?? They suck according to your logic.

Let's use some more of your logic. Payton is being propped up with a #1 defense not his 15th ranked offense that is suppose to be all him.

McDonald's offense only got what 13 pts vs SFs JV defense? Wow really primed up lol. Good job Seattle you guys are mostly healthy right now why we're forced to toss out our backups to the backups.

pretty much this. So far, at our absolute best, we left the field with a lead in the Superbowl, something neither of those coaches have done, unless you count Payton who had Brees back before we even sniffed Jim Harbaugh
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by 9moon:
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Originally posted by 9moon:
Originally posted by alwayssecond:
Heartbreak after heartbreak

this f**king team

shanahan and all the ofrense were disgusting tonight

3 points for the BEST " USED TO BE YOUNG" MIND IN FOOTBALL..

They had poor starting position most of the game because the defense wasn't doing their part. Even when the Seahawks didn't score they ate up clock and drove deep enough that they kept the Niners bottled up.

If we were Seahawks fans we would be braggung about how great the defense did against a high scoring offense.

... and i'll keep going back to my OLDEST POINT that Shanny just clueless when it's time to ADJUST.. everyone saw how good Seattle's D was playing.. yet, nothing changed in the 2nd half w/the way he was calling the plays..

.. and at least, DEMAND Saleh to get off that BLANKET COVERAGE where the targets continue to just find holes after holes..

What are you babbling about man? What would YOU change?

Let's just ignore the big drive we had in the 2nd half that should've been a TD instead of a pick of CMCs hands.

Our starting field position in the 2nd half was on our 12, 9, 30(which was that drive) and 20(with 2:20 left down 10)

What are you "adjusting"?

The old half time adjustments b******t take lol

Originally posted by DrEll:
Why practice tackling when you can dance to music during practice all week.
In case you missed it. The current CBA severely limits the amount of full contact practices allowed. If you're just going to make stupid comments you should at least know what the rules are about "practicing tackling". The challenges presented by a limit on full contact practice is something Saleh has spoken about before. The full Article is below.

The team went 12-5 during a year when they had the most games lost to injury on the league, including their two best defense players and a promising rookie defender.

All of those injuries, the ongoing issues with Pearsall's knee, and now Williams means they have a very small margin for error and that they will have to bring their best football every game, which I suspect will limit their chances somewhat, but the team is still in the playoffs and will be in the fight until they're not and have as much of a chance as anyone else to reach the Super Bowl, .yet a bunch of you are already writing them off like the true "fans" you are. Granted, the loss to Seattle made it a much harder get, but they will still need to beat the teams they would have ultimately ended up facing anyway. They just won't be able to do it from the comfort of their own home. Go Niners!

From Article 23, section 7 of the current CBA -

Following the five-day on-field acclimation period, two-a-day practices shall be permitted, subject to the following rules: (i) players may be on the field for a total of no more than four hours per day; (ii) players may participate in no more than one padded practice per day, which shall be no longer than 2.5 hours of on-field activities; (iii) there must be at least a 90 minute interval between practices; and (iv) the second practice on the same day may only be for a maximum of the remaining four-hour on-field time, and shall be limited to only walk-through instruction and drills and plays conducted at an acceptable walkthrough pace (i.e., Pro Bowl practice pace), as demonstrated in a video jointly approved by the parties, with offensive players lining up across from defensive players, or kicking team players lining up across from return team players. No helmets may be worn during the second practice. On days on which either a padded practice or a fullspeed, non-padded practice is scheduled, but no second practice is scheduled, the padded practice or the full speed, non-padded practice remains subject to the 2.5-hour time limit for on-field activities. The two on-field practices may be conducted in either order. The 2.5-hour limit on padded practices and full-speed, non-padded practices shall begin as soon as position coaches begin to coach a player or players on the field. Padded practices may not be held on more than three consecutive calendar days, and such three-day practice periods may not be held more than three times during preseason training camp. Additionally, none of the three permissible three-day practice periods may begin until at least three calendar days have elapsed since the conclusion of the Club's previous three-day practice period. During the period between the mandatory reporting date for veteran players and the final day of preseason training camp, no Club may hold more than a total of sixteen padded practices. In any League year with three or fewer preseason games (excluding the Canton Hall of Fame Game or any American Bowl game scheduled around the Canton Hall of Fame Game), the final week of preseason training camp shall be a bye week (i.e., no games are scheduled), and a Club may hold one padded practice subject to the rules set forth in this Subsection unless the parties agree otherwise. All other practices held during the bye week may be full speed, non-padded practices subject to the rules set forth in this Subsection except that (i) players may be on the field for a total of no more than 3.5 hours per day; (ii) players may participate in no more than one full speed, non-padded practice, which shall be no longer than 2.0 hours of on-field activities; (iii) there must be at least a 90 minute interval between practices; and (iv) the second practice may be for a maximum of the remaining 3.5 hour on-field time and is limited to only walk-through instruction and drills and plays conducted at an acceptable walkthrough pace (i.e., Pro Bowl practice pace), as demonstrated in a video jointly approved by the parties, with offensive players lining up against defensive players, or kicking team players lining up against return team players. No helmets may be worn during the walkthrough practice. The definition of a "padded practice" under this Article shall be the same as the definition used for regular season practices in Article 24, Section 1(c) of this Agreement. In the event that a Club begins a padded practice but such practice is cancelled within sixty minutes of its commencement due to inclement weather or for any other reason beyond the Club's control, such practice shall not count as a padded practice under this Article or Article 24
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by BYisGod:
Originally posted by maximusdecimus:
Tonges and kittle have been on the field together 7 times this season.
that's a helluva way to maximize your roster Kyle.

What's wild is that we've been clamoring for a good backup TE for an eternity. Now we have one…and we don't play him.

Tonges is good as a receiver but he's not a good blocker. Scheme wise he's basically TE3. How many 3 TE sets do we run? That takes Juice off the field.

Maybe it's something we do in the playoffs but let's not act like Tonges is the key to unlocking the offense lol. When Seattle is able to stop our run game playing nickel...a TE who's not a great blocker isn't going to suddenly break things open.

Yeah that should happen because juice sucks.

There's a reason teams don't use a fullback.

Tell me what he's actually good at that tonges is not better at?

He can't win on short yardage runs and hes a slow ass receiver that can't break tackles... IE he's worthless...

Ohh but the block....ohh but the blocking... Tonges blocking so underrated....

Dumbest argument ever.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone