Originally posted by thl408:
I know it's BR, but the breakdown of SB QBs, and where they are drafted, is interesting.
http://bleacherreport.com/articles/2632841-la-rams-start-with-a-bang-but-is-risking-future-for-qb-at-no-1-worth-it
_____
______
- Since 2000, 11 quarterbacks have been picked first overall. At least three—David Carr, JaMarcus Russell and Sam Bradford—have to be considered busts. At least three—Carson Palmer, Eli Manning and Cam Newton—should probably be considered successes. The jury remains out on the other five—Michael Vick, Alex Smith, Matthew Stafford, Andrew Luck and Jameis Winston—but none have been All-Pros or been to Super Bowls.
- Only one—Newton—has been a first-team All Pro, and only one—Manning—has led his team to a championship.
- And if we date back to 1990, only 13 percent of the quarterbacks drafted first overall have led the teams that drafted them to championships, while 33 percent have never been to a Pro Bowl and 40 percent have never won a playoff game.
- Thirteen of the last 17 Super Bowls have been won by teams led by quarterbacks who were not drafted in the top 10. The only two exceptions are Peyton and Eli Manning, who won two each.
The first two bullet points contradict one another (no All pros...Cam is an All Pro). There's also a chart that can't be posted that lists how QBs that are #1 overall picks have fared regarding pro bowls, playoffs, SBs, etc.
Most top QBs go to crappy teams and play like crap. It's not rocket science. I believe if Aaron Rogers was picked by SF he would have sucked for years until the team found a good coach and players just like Alex did. Coaches and players around them help mold what type of NFL QB everyone turns into.
I always joke that SF should have taken Tom Brady but if that happened he would not have become a HOF QB.