Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 661 users in the forums

How does the Rams trade affect us?

Shop Find 49ers gear online

How does the Rams trade affect us?

  • SoCold
  • Hall of Dumb
  • Posts: 133,300
Originally posted by thl408:
I know it's BR, but the breakdown of SB QBs, and where they are drafted, is interesting.
http://bleacherreport.com/articles/2632841-la-rams-start-with-a-bang-but-is-risking-future-for-qb-at-no-1-worth-it
_____
  • Since 2000, 11 quarterbacks have been picked first overall. At least three—David Carr, JaMarcus Russell and Sam Bradford—have to be considered busts. At least three—Carson Palmer, Eli Manning and Cam Newton—should probably be considered successes. The jury remains out on the other five—Michael Vick, Alex Smith, Matthew Stafford, Andrew Luck and Jameis Winston—but none have been All-Pros or been to Super Bowls.
  • Only one—Newton—has been a first-team All Pro, and only one—Manning—has led his team to a championship.
  • And if we date back to 1990, only 13 percent of the quarterbacks drafted first overall have led the teams that drafted them to championships, while 33 percent have never been to a Pro Bowl and 40 percent have never won a playoff game.
  • Thirteen of the last 17 Super Bowls have been won by teams led by quarterbacks who were not drafted in the top 10. The only two exceptions are Peyton and Eli Manning, who won two each.
______


The first two bullet points contradict one another (no All pros...Cam is an All Pro). There's also a chart that can't be posted that lists how QBs that are #1 overall picks have fared regarding pro bowls, playoffs, SBs, etc.

Most top QBs go to crappy teams and play like crap. It's not rocket science. I believe if Aaron Rogers was picked by SF he would have sucked for years until the team found a good coach and players just like Alex did. Coaches and players around them help mold what type of NFL QB everyone turns into.

I always joke that SF should have taken Tom Brady but if that happened he would not have become a HOF QB.
  • cciowa
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 60,541
Originally posted by SoCold:
Most top QBs go to crappy teams and play like crap. It's not rocket science. I believe if Aaron Rogers was picked by SF he would have sucked for years until the team found a good coach and players just like Alex did. Coaches and players around them help mold what type of NFL QB everyone turns into.

I always joke that SF should have taken Tom Brady but if that happened he would not have become a HOF QB.

i have always felt nolan should have signed garcia when he lobbied to come back to us. that way alex would never have been thrown to the wolves that first year and it may have turned out different for him and for us
Originally posted by SoCold:
Most top QBs go to crappy teams and play like crap. It's not rocket science. I believe if Aaron Rogers was picked by SF he would have sucked for years until the team found a good coach and players just like Alex did. Coaches and players around them help mold what type of NFL QB everyone turns into.

I always joke that SF should have taken Tom Brady but if that happened he would not have become a HOF QB.

Yep. Tim Couch and David Carr were both chosen #1, drafted by truly horrible teams, thrown out there and had the absolute s**t kicked out of them. Sometimes its the player but I think a lot of times its just that the team destroys the QB, mentally and physically. Bruce Arians who was the Browns OC has repeatedly said that Couch could have been a tremendous QB had he not been wrecked physically.


"There was a feeling that we were asking our quarterback to do too much and that's never been one of the things I've felt. I felt very adamant about a quarterback had to run the show, and I felt very, very confident in Tim Couch. I think Tim Couch is still one of the most underrated players because Timmy took us to the playoffs, and then, broke his leg. Kelly (Holcomb) had the great game, and then, all of a sudden, there was a controversy, probably because I was a Tim Couch supporter.

"Tim Couch. Hell of a player. Tim was no bust. It kills me when people call him a bust. His arm was just so torn up he couldn't play anymore. He would have been a real good one."



The worst thing that you can do is to take a QB #1 and then allow them to get their head bashed in before they've even gotten their bearings straight and been able to catch up to the speed of the NFL game. In the case of Couch and Carr you had expansion franchises taking QB's early and just completely wrecking them.


Alex is gangster as f**k for the beatdowns he took year after year after year and the dude kept coming so I'm happy that he's had some success.
Originally posted by SoCold:
Originally posted by thl408:
I know it's BR, but the breakdown of SB QBs, and where they are drafted, is interesting.
http://bleacherreport.com/articles/2632841-la-rams-start-with-a-bang-but-is-risking-future-for-qb-at-no-1-worth-it
_____
  • Since 2000, 11 quarterbacks have been picked first overall. At least three—David Carr, JaMarcus Russell and Sam Bradford—have to be considered busts. At least three—Carson Palmer, Eli Manning and Cam Newton—should probably be considered successes. The jury remains out on the other five—Michael Vick, Alex Smith, Matthew Stafford, Andrew Luck and Jameis Winston—but none have been All-Pros or been to Super Bowls.
  • Only one—Newton—has been a first-team All Pro, and only one—Manning—has led his team to a championship.
  • And if we date back to 1990, only 13 percent of the quarterbacks drafted first overall have led the teams that drafted them to championships, while 33 percent have never been to a Pro Bowl and 40 percent have never won a playoff game.
  • Thirteen of the last 17 Super Bowls have been won by teams led by quarterbacks who were not drafted in the top 10. The only two exceptions are Peyton and Eli Manning, who won two each.
______


The first two bullet points contradict one another (no All pros...Cam is an All Pro). There's also a chart that can't be posted that lists how QBs that are #1 overall picks have fared regarding pro bowls, playoffs, SBs, etc.

Most top QBs go to crappy teams and play like crap. It's not rocket science. I believe if Aaron Rogers was picked by SF he would have sucked for years until the team found a good coach and players just like Alex did. Coaches and players around them help mold what type of NFL QB everyone turns into.

I always joke that SF should have taken Tom Brady but if that happened he would not have become a HOF QB.
SoCold is right. And I'd add that I think this is a function of a couple of things: the model in which teams draft QB's and the league's designed parity. The top QB's are going to the bottom teams and being asked to start right away, often with terrible O-lines and little to throw to (which is what's gonna happen to Goff or Wentz if the Rams draft one). The mid-range and top teams hardly move up in the draft to get top QB's. And the NFL has a successful parity model that is the envy of other pro leagues. If Goof or Wentz go to, say, Buffalo, Jets, Cowgirls, or even the 49ers those QB's will have better long-term success because those teams have better teams overall. But if they go to the Browns or the Lambs they are bound to struggle, for a long time too.
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
How does it effect the 49ers, simple......now they will have to look to Conor Cook in the 2nd or so.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
How does it effect the 49ers, simple......now they will have to look to Conor Cook in the 2nd or so.

I will puke over this whole damn bay area if Conner Cook is a Niner
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by wailers15:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
How does it effect the 49ers, simple......now they will have to look to Conor Cook in the 2nd or so.

I will puke over this whole damn bay area if Conner Cook is a Niner

Well thank Trent and Chip.
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
I watched Gruden's qb camp with goff man that kid was impressive. I've changed my opinion on him, still worried about the hand size but should be okay on warm weather team.
  • boast
  • Hella Fame
  • Posts: 157,048
Originally posted by susweel:
I watched Gruden's qb camp with goff man that kid was impressive. I've changed my opinion on him, still worried about the hand size but should be okay on warm weather team.

a Goff led Cal team never ever beat a ranked team. he never seemed to elevate his game against good competition. that's a huge red flag to me.
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
Originally posted by boast:
Originally posted by susweel:
I watched Gruden's qb camp with goff man that kid was impressive. I've changed my opinion on him, still worried about the hand size but should be okay on warm weather team.

a Goff led Cal team never ever beat a ranked team. he never seemed to elevate his game against good competition. that's a huge red flag to me.

His oline was pretty bad many times he was forced to make plays with free rushers coming at him.
  • boast
  • Hella Fame
  • Posts: 157,048
Originally posted by thl408:
I know it's BR, but the breakdown of SB QBs, and where they are drafted, is interesting.
http://bleacherreport.com/articles/2632841-la-rams-start-with-a-bang-but-is-risking-future-for-qb-at-no-1-worth-it
_____
  • Since 2000, 11 quarterbacks have been picked first overall. At least three—David Carr, JaMarcus Russell and Sam Bradford—have to be considered busts. At least three—Carson Palmer, Eli Manning and Cam Newton—should probably be considered successes. The jury remains out on the other five—Michael Vick, Alex Smith, Matthew Stafford, Andrew Luck and Jameis Winston—but none have been All-Pros or been to Super Bowls.
  • Only one—Newton—has been a first-team All Pro, and only one—Manning—has led his team to a championship.
  • And if we date back to 1990, only 13 percent of the quarterbacks drafted first overall have led the teams that drafted them to championships, while 33 percent have never been to a Pro Bowl and 40 percent have never won a playoff game.
  • Thirteen of the last 17 Super Bowls have been won by teams led by quarterbacks who were not drafted in the top 10. The only two exceptions are Peyton and Eli Manning, who won two each.
______


The first two bullet points contradict one another (no All pros...Cam is an All Pro). There's also a chart that can't be posted that lists how QBs that are #1 overall picks have fared regarding pro bowls, playoffs, SBs, etc.

not a contradiction. the claim is that Michael Vick, Alex Smith, Matthew Stafford, Andrew Luck and James Winston have not been All-Pros or been to Super Bowls
Originally posted by boast:
a Goff led Cal team never ever beat a ranked team. he never seemed to elevate his game against good competition. that's a huge red flag to me.

A Goff-less Cal team last year might not even win a single game. 121st ranked OL in the country and a terrible defense meant that he basically had to carry that team against better opponents pretty much game in and game out. I can't think of a top QB in recent memory that played on as shoddy of a team in a major conference.

If you look at some of the other top QB's

Wentz -Team was stacked. They won their 5th straight national championship with Carson starting for two of them. Just a behemoth in the FCS.

Cook-#3 OL in the country, loaded defense, team went on to win perhaps their biggest game of the year against Ohio State without him even in the lineup.
[ Edited by Phoenix49ers on Apr 15, 2016 at 1:47 PM ]
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by boast:
a Goff led Cal team never ever beat a ranked team. he never seemed to elevate his game against good competition. that's a huge red flag to me.

A Goff-less Cal team last year might not even win a single game. 121st ranked OL in the country and a terrible defense meant that he basically had to carry that team against better opponents pretty much game in and game out. I can't think of a top QB in recent memory that played on as shoddy of a team in a major conference.

If you look at some of the other top QB's

Wentz -Team was stacked. They won their 5th straight national championship with Carson starting for two of them. Just a behemoth in the FCS.

Cook-#3 OL in the country, loaded defense, team went on to win perhaps their biggest game of the year against Ohio State without him even in the lineup.

Yep even the great Aaron Rodgers at cal had DeSean jackson and beastmode on that team. Goff didn't have much to work with. I also remember hearing similar comments about Peyton Manning in college how he couldn't beat Florida. I don't put too much stock in team success when I evaluate individual collegiate players.
  • thl408
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 33,510
Originally posted by boast:
not a contradiction. the claim is that Michael Vick, Alex Smith, Matthew Stafford, Andrew Luck and James Winston have not been All-Pros or been to Super Bowls

I see it now. I read it wrong. I thought it was referring to all #1 overall QBs. It was just referring to those 5 mentioned.
Sounds like the Rams must have consulted Mike Ditka on this trade.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone