49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 1,012 users in the forums

How does the Rams trade affect us?

Shop Find 49ers gear online

How does the Rams trade affect us?

Originally posted by 49ersGiants7:
Ole Miss? Kelly is a big time character risk.

I want us to draft some sort of mid round QB this year with starting potential to protect ourselves from winning meaningless games in future years preventing us from getting a QB #1 overall. It'll at least give you an option in the pipeline whether it's a Cook, Prescott, hogan, Allen, Adams etc.

Agreed, but we will see what he's able to accomplish next year.

I understand that and it's a good point. I'm not opposed at to taking a later round QB this year for sure... I just think as per the thread headline The Rams trade has essentially stopped us from taking a first round QB (without some serious maneuvering) if thats what Baalke and Co were initially planning. Whether they take a late round QB or wait until next year I'll be happy. I just don't feel like it's worth selling the future for the QBs in this years draft.
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Kelly is a knucklehead that has been arrested and suspended from every school he went to going back to high school, Mayfield is a gimmick QB, not too impressed by Kayaa, hasn't shown much improvement, Kiel would get injured walking to the podium, Watson is the only guy that looks like he has the potential to be an outstanding quarterback right now. Gustafson from Montana is another guy worth watching but I'm not too optimistic.

I think ultimately this team's long term solution at QB might not be around this year or next.

Haha I just want to be Optimistic man! But I do see where you're coming from.
  • Rascal
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 13,926
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Any ideas of who that could be?


#1 QB for next year's draft as of right now.



But, remember is almost pointless to talk about Deshaun Watson if we don't have a GM who is capable of making big strategic moves to trade up to get our guy. Come this time next year, another team could easily just jump us again like what the Rams did.
[ Edited by Rascal on Apr 14, 2016 at 11:49 PM ]
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
#1 QB for next year's draft as of right now.



I would love for this to become a reality, but we all know it won't... It's like we used up all our QB luck when we had Montana & Young b2b.
Originally posted by Rascal:
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Any ideas of who that could be?


#1 QB for next year's draft as of right now.



But, remember is almost pointless to talk about Deshaun Watson if we don't have a GM who is capable of making big strategic moves to trade up to get our guy. Come this time next year, another team could easily just jump us again like what the Rams did.

Wait, what? Did you just imply the Rams did something that "affected" you?
It's been proven over the last few years that defense wins SB's and we don't necessarily need an all pro QB to achieve that. If the ScRams take a QB that bodes well for us and we go Def. I want Jack and stack our defense, get a good game breaker WR and Gabbert can steer the ship just as long as the def is shutdown caliber.
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Except there isn't a stronger class next year.

Way too early to be predicting that. A few who look like stars now will underwhelm, but a whole lot of good players will emerge that are currently off the radar. Happens every year.
Originally posted by BuZzB05:
I agreed with u. I dont want Bosa at #7. He is probably available! I prefer Brandon Kaufusi DE for 3rd round better than Bosa!

I hope it isn't Bosa at #7, but just looking, would guess it may end up being him. If so I would like to drop back a few spots and add an extra top 50 pick plus the pick we dropped back to. Hopefully, not more than a couple spots. I would hate to once again draft a guy who doesn't fit our 3-4 and we end up making changes for him , the D and end up with a very good player in a position he doesn't excel in. Really don't want that, and would be the one and only reason of dropping down a few slots and picking up an extra top 50 pick.
Originally posted by pasodoc9er:
Originally posted by BuZzB05:
I agreed with u. I dont want Bosa at #7. He is probably available! I prefer Brandon Kaufusi DE for 3rd round better than Bosa!

I hope it isn't Bosa at #7, but just looking, would guess it may end up being him. If so I would like to drop back a few spots and add an extra top 50 pick plus the pick we dropped back to. Hopefully, not more than a couple spots. I would hate to once again draft a guy who doesn't fit our 3-4 and we end up making changes for him , the D and end up with a very good player in a position he doesn't excel in. Really don't want that, and would be the one and only reason of dropping down a few slots and picking up an extra top 50 pick.

lol, I had bosa at 7 because I thought both QBs would be gone and buckner as well. I'm actually fine with bosa or buckner at 7. This is a real possibility now.
Originally posted by PacTiger:
Originally posted by pasodoc9er:
Originally posted by BuZzB05:
I agreed with u. I dont want Bosa at #7. He is probably available! I prefer Brandon Kaufusi DE for 3rd round better than Bosa!

I hope it isn't Bosa at #7, but just looking, would guess it may end up being him. If so I would like to drop back a few spots and add an extra top 50 pick plus the pick we dropped back to. Hopefully, not more than a couple spots. I would hate to once again draft a guy who doesn't fit our 3-4 and we end up making changes for him , the D and end up with a very good player in a position he doesn't excel in. Really don't want that, and would be the one and only reason of dropping down a few slots and picking up an extra top 50 pick.

lol, I had bosa at 7 because I thought both QBs would be gone and buckner as well. I'm actually fine with bosa or buckner at 7. This is a real possibility now.

that UCLA linebacker would be sick too
Originally posted by cciowa:
should have kept him and traded young

Come on guys Jerry was voted the GOAT of all time at any position! The man had no weaknesses and did it for a long time!
Now back to the pick, i say we take DeForest Buckner with the pick and pair him with Armstead. Should be a lot of passes batted down with two 6'7 inch ends.
Then we take Garnett from Stanford to start at guard, make a trade and grab Cook also in the 2nd round. Trade Kap and package his 3rd rd pick we receive along w our 5th and get best available Linebacker or receiver at that point.
Originally posted by coowal1:
It's been proven over the last few years that defense wins SB's and we don't necessarily need an all pro QB to achieve that. If the ScRams take a QB that bodes well for us and we go Def. I want Jack and stack our defense, get a good game breaker WR and Gabbert can steer the ship just as long as the def is shutdown caliber.

In the AFC, every SB since 2004 other than 2012 has featured Brady, Manning or Big Ben. You absolutely need a QB. People are still all hopped up on the Broncos who had a sterling defense that has now been taken apart a bit and had a lucky run to win it. They are the exception, not the rule. In the NFL if you want to win consistently and be in the running every year, you need a good quarterback.

You can try to game manage your way into it but your team will quickly be taken apart as we saw with the 49ers and now we are seeing with Denver.



Also where this rhetoric about a "shutdown caliber defense" coming from. The head coach is Chip Kelly and the defensive coordinator is a reject from Cleveland who coordinated one of the worst defenses in the NFL. People thinking that with just a few draft picks that its going to be 2011 all over again might just be a tad bit delusional. I don't ever see Kelly having a "shutdown caliber defense" because of the scheme that he runs.


I think the best that you can hope for is a turnover happy defense and a high octane scoring offense which you won't get with Checkdown on 3rd and long Gabbert at QB.
[ Edited by Phoenix49ers on Apr 15, 2016 at 8:29 AM ]
Originally posted by hondakillerzx:
that UCLA linebacker would be sick too

Yep, someone getting pushed down to us!
  • cciowa
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 60,541
Originally posted by PacTiger:
Originally posted by hondakillerzx:
that UCLA linebacker would be sick too

Yep, someone getting pushed down to us!

i want an elite pass rusher at number one but i am really warming up to this pick. sooner or later we do need to get a elite henchman for bowman and by all reports this would be the man. i am sure we can still get a pass rusher in round two or three. as many people have said. we should have our pick of a elite d guy when it comes our turn and that is a GLARING area of need
  • thl408
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 33,486
I know it's BR, but the breakdown of SB QBs, and where they are drafted, is interesting.
http://bleacherreport.com/articles/2632841-la-rams-start-with-a-bang-but-is-risking-future-for-qb-at-no-1-worth-it
_____
  • Since 2000, 11 quarterbacks have been picked first overall. At least three—David Carr, JaMarcus Russell and Sam Bradford—have to be considered busts. At least three—Carson Palmer, Eli Manning and Cam Newton—should probably be considered successes. The jury remains out on the other five—Michael Vick, Alex Smith, Matthew Stafford, Andrew Luck and Jameis Winston—but none have been All-Pros or been to Super Bowls.
  • Only one—Newton—has been a first-team All Pro, and only one—Manning—has led his team to a championship.
  • And if we date back to 1990, only 13 percent of the quarterbacks drafted first overall have led the teams that drafted them to championships, while 33 percent have never been to a Pro Bowl and 40 percent have never won a playoff game.
  • Thirteen of the last 17 Super Bowls have been won by teams led by quarterbacks who were not drafted in the top 10. The only two exceptions are Peyton and Eli Manning, who won two each.
______


The first two bullet points contradict one another (no All pros...Cam is an All Pro). There's also a chart that can't be posted that lists how QBs that are #1 overall picks have fared regarding pro bowls, playoffs, SBs, etc.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone