Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 775 users in the forums

How does the Rams trade affect us?

Shop Find 49ers gear online

How does the Rams trade affect us?

Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Any ideas of who that could be?


#1 QB for next year's draft as of right now.


Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
It's excellent. There are no guaranteed QB prospects in this draft. We will pick something that helps us more.

There are no guaranteed QB prospects in any draft.

The odds are that one of Goff or Wentz winds up as a franchise QB in the NFL.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
It's excellent. There are no guaranteed QB prospects in this draft. We will pick something that helps us more.

Maybe. I would have been psyched to pick up Goff, I'm very high on him.

But you are right in that a really good prospect is going to drop to us, because it looks like both QBs are likely going 1-2. That means one of Buckner, Jack, Bosa, or maybe even Tunsil, could drop to us at 7.

We're going to get a really good player regardless.
Originally posted by SofaKing:
Maybe. I would have been psyched to pick up Goff, I'm very high on him.

But you are right in that a really good prospect is going to drop to us, because it looks like both QBs are likely going 1-2. That means one of Buckner, Jack, Bosa, or maybe even Tunsil, could drop to us at 7.

We're going to get a really good player regardless.

Tunsil, Jack and Buckner are all likely to be gone and you may end up with Bosa who has some character questions, also is better suited to be a 4-3 DE. Not that he can't be a 3-4 OLB, but just like Jared Allen, his best fit is playing with his hand on the ground on the edge. Not sure I'd be too thrilled about that one.
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Tunsil, Jack and Buckner are all likely to be gone and you may end up with Bosa who has some character questions, also is better suited to be a 4-3 DE. Not that he can't be a 3-4 OLB, but just like Jared Allen, his best fit is playing with his hand on the ground on the edge. Not sure I'd be too thrilled about that one.

Agree on Bosa. Definitely a better fit as a 4-3 end. Hoping for Buckner or Jack, but out of those 3 I would agree Bosa is the most likely to slip to 7.
Originally posted by SofaKing:
Agree on Bosa. Definitely a better fit as a 4-3 end. Hoping for Buckner or Jack, but out of those 3 I would agree Bosa is the most likely to slip to 7.

I did not want Bosa for this team as high as pick 7. I hope someone else takes the bait
Originally posted by Pillbusta:
I did not want Bosa for this team as high as pick 7. I hope someone else takes the bait

He's not the most ideal fit for a 3-4, but I wouldn't be upset if he was the pick to be honest. He has some schematic versatility and is just a quality football player. But I think Buckner or Jack would be bigger impact players for us. Hope that one of them slips to 7.
Originally posted by Pillbusta:
Originally posted by SofaKing:
Agree on Bosa. Definitely a better fit as a 4-3 end. Hoping for Buckner or Jack, but out of those 3 I would agree Bosa is the most likely to slip to 7.

I did not want Bosa for this team as high as pick 7. I hope someone else takes the bait



I agreed with u. I dont want Bosa at #7. He is probably available! I prefer Brandon Kaufusi DE for 3rd round better than Bosa!
  • thl408
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 33,510
Originally posted by Pillbusta:
Originally posted by SofaKing:
Agree on Bosa. Definitely a better fit as a 4-3 end. Hoping for Buckner or Jack, but out of those 3 I would agree Bosa is the most likely to slip to 7.

I did not want Bosa for this team as high as pick 7. I hope someone else takes the bait

If what JoN did in CLE carries over, the 49ers will show 4-3 fronts and there will be a place for Bosa to play as a 4-3 DE. I agree with you though, Bosa is the least appealing of the top7 prospects.
Originally posted by thl408:
If what JoN did in CLE carries over, the 49ers will show 4-3 fronts and there will be a place for Bosa to play as a 4-3 DE. I agree with you though, Bosa is the least appealing of the top7 prospects.

This is true too. JoN did run a hybrid 3-4/4-3 with Pettine for a number of years. Bosa would find a niche in this defense, but Buckner or Jack would fit perfectly. Buckner is a rare breed, perfect 3-4 DE prospect, and Jack is the perfect 3-down linebacker to pair with Bowman.
I'm happy to see this trade happen because I feel like it forces the 49ers to focus on other needs like others have said. I feel like the smartest thing to do is sit on the 7th pick along with all the other picks they have accrued and build the team for the long haul. The smartest move in my eyes is keep Kap and Gabbert and focus on other needs. I understand this has become the win now league but you need a solid foundation to accomplish that. It's a win-win scenario if they are smart about it really. You aquire young new talent...IE, possibly tunsel, Hargreaves, Ramsey (I'm being optimistic) or whoever is left at 7th, you give Kap a chance for a comeback and silence the "what if Kap did yadayadayada Blablah blah chip Kelly" talk, and you invest in the future. If need be you take a qb from a stronger class next year. The only qb I would honestly consider at 7th if by some miracle he was still around would be Goff. Dude has accuracy, can read a defense, and actually looks through his progressions. However I really doubt that will be the case and I think he's the reason the Rams wanted the first pick.
Originally posted by ID2AZ:
If need be you take a qb from a stronger class next year.
Except there isn't a stronger class next year.
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Except there isn't a stronger class next year.


You don't think so? I feel like there is... you got some big name schools that will losing their QBs next draft. Clemson, Miami, Oklahoma, Ole Miss... etc I feel like there will be some strong talent and prospects worth grooming... but I agree as you said before there aren't any guaranteed QBs in any draft. I personally Like Goff and feel like Wentz will be a bust. Beyond that Lynch is the only real talent I see competing with Goff in this years draft... IMO of course.

What would you have them do then? Try to see if the browns are willing to trade their 2nd overall to take a gamble at QB? I feel like the Rams trade has almost guaranteed we won't be taking a first round QB.
Ole Miss? Kelly is a big time character risk.

I want us to draft some sort of mid round QB this year with starting potential to protect ourselves from winning meaningless games in future years preventing us from getting a QB #1 overall. It'll at least give you an option in the pipeline whether it's a Cook, Prescott, hogan, Allen, Adams etc.
Originally posted by ID2AZ:
You don't think so? I feel like there is... you got some big name schools that will losing their QBs next draft. Clemson, Miami, Oklahoma, Ole Miss... etc I feel like there will be some strong talent and prospects worth grooming... but I agree as you said before there aren't any guaranteed QBs in any draft. I personally Like Goff and feel like Wentz will be a bust. Beyond that Lynch is the only real talent I see competing with Goff in this years draft... IMO of course.

What would you have them do then? Try to see if the browns are willing to trade their 2nd overall to take a gamble at QB? I feel like the Rams trade has almost guaranteed we won't be taking a first round QB.

Kelly is a knucklehead that has been arrested and suspended from every school he went to going back to high school, Mayfield is a gimmick QB, not too impressed by Kayaa, hasn't shown much improvement, Kiel would get injured walking to the podium, Watson is the only guy that looks like he has the potential to be an outstanding quarterback right now. Gustafson from Montana is another guy worth watching but I'm not too optimistic.

I think ultimately this team's long term solution at QB might not be around this year or next.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone