49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 833 users in the forums

Indispensable

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Agree! People tend to under rate the lack of mistakes by Smith. JTO ring a bell?

If Alex was gunning the ball all over the field and taking risks, it would be one thing. He didn't have to do any of that though. He was asked to make simple reads, hit wide open shot plays down the field (almost always against single coverage bdcause Ds were putting 8 or 9 in the box) or hold the ball and take a sack when he didn't like what he saw. Perhaps I do underestimate Alexs part in that, but maybe you overestimate what he was asked to do. To each his own.

One thing I will say is it's nice having Alex when we are trailing. He's proven to be clutch, that's for sure.
  • Antix
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 9,984
anything that affects ourpass rush would hurt the worst imo. Our D is great b/c of our pass rush
Originally posted by kush:
Originally posted by dtcomposer:
Originally posted by kush:
Just my opinion, but the drop off from Justin Smith(arguably the best defensive player in the league last year) to RJF(solid backup, depth guy) is much greater than the dropoff between Alex Smith to CK.

We're a team that wins by playing great D and ST while limiting turnovers on offense.

Which is one reason why It seems Kaep wouldn't be an upgrade, and might just be a big problem. Dude's slow windup and propensity to try to gun it into tight spots plus the fact that he has zero NFL experience has turnovers written all over it.

With the way the team plays defense and tries to control field position it even 5-10 more turnovers would cost the team a bunch of wins.

All that is assuming that Kaep can actually play, and isn't a bust of some kind. Nobody knows if that is the case because he didn't play last season. When he did play, it was obvious (pre-season) that he had a long way to go.

Kaep does NOT have a long motion. He has an awkward delivery but it is actually very quick. Kaep is a mystery, you're right, but I trust Harbaugh and Roman to draw up game plans that help our QB as much as possible. They proved last year they can gameplan creatively and make he QBs job easier. I don't think it's possible to replace Justin smiths play no matter how creative you get.

I agree replacing Just Smith would be tough because it affects Aldon, and Willis, as well as the Run game. I might put him #1, but Alex just plays an even more important position. I think that Kaeps windup is very slow and awkward, but his release is fast. It is the motion back that is the problem because it telegraphs where he is going with the ball. But whatever, I have no clue how he would play. It is a HUGE risk though at the most important position on the field.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by dtcomposer:
Originally posted by kush:
Just my opinion, but the drop off from Justin Smith(arguably the best defensive player in the league last year) to RJF(solid backup, depth guy) is much greater than the dropoff between Alex Smith to CK.

We're a team that wins by playing great D and ST while limiting turnovers on offense.

Which is one reason why It seems Kaep wouldn't be an upgrade, and might just be a big problem. Dude's slow windup and propensity to try to gun it into tight spots plus the fact that he has zero NFL experience has turnovers written all over it.

With the way the team plays defense and tries to control field position it even 5-10 more turnovers would cost the team a bunch of wins.

All that is assuming that Kaep can actually play, and isn't a bust of some kind. Nobody knows if that is the case because he didn't play last season. When he did play, it was obvious (pre-season) that he had a long way to go.


Agree! People tend to under rate the lack of mistakes by Smith. JTO ring a bell?

His INT numbers were his ONLY impressive stat. Everything else was completely meh. I would trade more INTs for higher offensive output. Rodgers threw 1 more INT BUT 3x as many TDs and about 1600 more yards. Not saying he needs to do that (he's obviously way too limited to reach that), but in today's game 3k yards and 17 TDS ain't gonna cut it
Originally posted by monsterzero789:
His INT numbers were his ONLY impressive stat. Everything else was completely meh. I would trade more INTs for higher offensive output. Rodgers threw 1 more INT BUT 3x as many TDs and about 1600 more yards. Not saying he needs to do that (he's obviously way too limited to reach that), but in today's game 3k yards and 17 TDS ain't gonna cut it

How bout the 6 comeback drives for wins? Not too shabby for a QB in a yr 1 WCO with limited receivers. Not impressed enough to enjoy those close wins?
Originally posted by oldman9er:
Originally posted by monsterzero789:
His INT numbers were his ONLY impressive stat. Everything else was completely meh. I would trade more INTs for higher offensive output. Rodgers threw 1 more INT BUT 3x as many TDs and about 1600 more yards. Not saying he needs to do that (he's obviously way too limited to reach that), but in today's game 3k yards and 17 TDS ain't gonna cut it

How bout the 6 comeback drives for wins? Not too shabby for a QB in a yr 1 WCO with limited receivers. Not impressed enough to enjoy those close wins?

And what are we considering a "comeback"? Lead changes in the 4th quarter happen all the time. Some games teams go back and forth. Is the saints game (as clutch as Alex was) considered a "comeback"? We were up for most of that gsme, the Saints came back on us. We traded points late in the game with the Lions and Giants. The only real "comeback" was the Eagles game (where we were down by more than 1 score). And in virtually all those games another Smith left an impact on those games.
Originally posted by monsterzero789:
His INT numbers were his ONLY impressive stat. Everything else was completely meh. I would trade more INTs for higher offensive output. Rodgers threw 1 more INT BUT 3x as many TDs and about 1600 more yards. Not saying he needs to do that (he's obviously way too limited to reach that), but in today's game 3k yards and 17 TDS ain't gonna cut it

Ironically it "cut it" last season.
How about VD? I hope our new additions pan out, but he was our top offensive threat last year. Mismatch nightmare that had to be accounted for every play. Delanie was sorely missed and he's no VD.
Originally posted by kush:
If Alex was gunning the ball all over the field and taking risks, it would be one thing. He didn't have to do any of that though. He was asked to make simple reads, hit wide open shot plays down the field (almost always against single coverage bdcause Ds were putting 8 or 9 in the box) or hold the ball and take a sack when he didn't like what he saw. Perhaps I do underestimate Alexs part in that, but maybe you overestimate what he was asked to do. To each his own.

One thing I will say is it's nice having Alex when we are trailing. He's proven to be clutch, that's for sure.


Several X-Coaches have said Smith was asked to do more with fewer opportunities, which is more difficult. In other words, he was asked to play it cool until he was needed to bail out the team by leading a comeback or score to put the game away. Other QBs were allowed to just play as they had their offenses in sync and actually had functional WRs.
Originally posted by LoneWolf:
Originally posted by monsterzero789:
His INT numbers were his ONLY impressive stat. Everything else was completely meh. I would trade more INTs for higher offensive output. Rodgers threw 1 more INT BUT 3x as many TDs and about 1600 more yards. Not saying he needs to do that (he's obviously way too limited to reach that), but in today's game 3k yards and 17 TDS ain't gonna cut it

Ironically it "cut it" last season.

Originally posted by LoneWolf:
Originally posted by monsterzero789:
His INT numbers were his ONLY impressive stat. Everything else was completely meh. I would trade more INTs for higher offensive output. Rodgers threw 1 more INT BUT 3x as many TDs and about 1600 more yards. Not saying he needs to do that (he's obviously way too limited to reach that), but in today's game 3k yards and 17 TDS ain't gonna cut it

Ironically it "cut it" last season.

Oh are we polishing #6? I don't blame Alex for losing the NFCC game, but if we would've had a little more offensive output...

We aren't going to continually be +28 in the turnover column
Originally posted by SD49ers:
How about VD? I hope our new additions pan out, but he was our top offensive threat last year. Mismatch nightmare that had to be accounted for every play. Delanie was sorely missed and he's no VD.

Not knowing how Manningham, Moss, and Jenkins are going to pan out for us, you have a very valueble point, Vernon is at the moment our biggest receiving threat, if we lost Vernon, If our 3 new additions to receiver don't play the way we hope it would be very costly in more ways then one. We would have to run more working our RB's to death, and Alex would get hit more in his attempts to pass.
Originally posted by monsterzero789:
Oh are we polishing #6? I don't blame Alex for losing the NFCC game, but if we would've had a little more offensive output...

We aren't going to continually be +28 in the turnover column

Had we not been struck with bad luck in the turnover department (both sides of it), we would be polishing #6, especially since the Giants had 1/2 the defense we did and beat the Patriots simply by having the better defense.
Originally posted by LoneWolf:
Originally posted by monsterzero789:
Oh are we polishing #6? I don't blame Alex for losing the NFCC game, but if we would've had a little more offensive output...

We aren't going to continually be +28 in the turnover column

Had we not been struck with bad luck in the turnover department (both sides of it), we would be polishing #6, especially since the Giants had 1/2 the defense we did and beat the Patriots simply by having the better defense.
That's what Im saying. If we had more offensive output, we would be more able to handle situations when the ball literally isn't bouncing our way. As great as our defense is, it's against the odds that they have the 38 takeaways again this year. And as good as Alex was protecting the ball, another 5 INT year looks pretty slim.
[ Edited by monsterzero789 on May 27, 2012 at 5:58 PM ]
  • fly15
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 5,790
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Alex Smith.

Hater or not, if he went down, so would our chances. Anyone who says Kap could come in with no substantial dropoff is completely fooling themselves.

anyone can replace alex, give Tolzien a couple of games and we're deep into the playoffs especially with our defense.
but I say Vernon is the most essential player
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone