49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 940 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,638
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
We have no idea of whether Smith is ahead of Harbaughs timetable for his improvement or behind. Since he plays things close to the vest, JH will keep us guessing about his view of Smith's upside. If he really likes where Alex is at the end of the season I could see him trying to wrap him up long term. If he still has doubts, then a shorter term deal seems reasonable. Anything shorter than three years would be counter productive as it will take some time to groom CK, Tolzien or another QB to take over.

The NFL may be considered a passing league but the teams who win superbowls tend to be balanced. Even Manning and Brady's teams had good, effective RBs..

We will know a lot more about "Harbaugh's timetable" for Smith when Edwards gets fully healthy and Crabtree has played enough to develop better chemistry with Smith.
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
I'm now convinced that you either don't understand, don't want to understand, or are f**kin around. You are easily the most biased poster on this entire board. Unwarranted I might add. But whatever, wallow in ignorance. I tried.

All good though.

Man you just because you got pwned. But its all good man, one love.
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
I'm now convinced that you either don't understand, don't want to understand, or are f**kin around. You are easily the most biased poster on this entire board. Unwarranted I might add. But whatever, wallow in ignorance. I tried.

All good though.

Man you just because you got pwned. But its all good man, one love.

Ya, you just got pwned by a guy that says pwned, OUCH!
Originally posted by tjd808185:
If you guys can find me a team as consistent as the Colts over the past decade I'd like to see them. This post isn't meant to be anti Alex but I really think some of you guys are off your rocker.

You don't want to be built around a franchise quarterback? Seriously. Indianapolis has made the playoffs for the last 7 years. Peyton Manning has had 1 injury in 14 years and that's enough reason for you guys to not want to build around a quarterback. Trust me on this one not having franchise quarterback will ruin more seasons than that. See Baltimore and their 4 missed playoff births despite having a top 6 defense practically every year.

You can win with an 'efficient' quarterback. You must think that Peyton Mannings are a dime a dozen, like all we have to do is get rid of Alex and draft a franchise quarterback. All I am saying is if Alex steadily improves, we will continue to win games. And that is the name of the game right?

We don't have to constantly think about replacing him, if there is no reason to. If Kaep down the road proves he is the answer, than I have zero problem with that.
Originally posted by jreff22:
Its not that we don't want a franchise QB, its that Alex is doing what is needed to win and almost be 6-0. Whimsically replacing him for another QB might not give the results everybody is expecting.

I have no problem if we gave Alex an extension right now.

That being said teams built around a franchise quarterback are more consisent than teams that don't have them. The McNabbs and Vick's get hurt alot other than that quarterbacks don't drop like flies. Brady has 1 injury in 10 years. Manning has 1 injury in 14 years. Favre didn't miss a game until he was 45.

Those are odds I'm more than willing to take.
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
I'm now convinced that you either don't understand, don't want to understand, or are f**kin around. You are easily the most biased poster on this entire board. Unwarranted I might add. But whatever, wallow in ignorance. I tried.

All good though.

Man you just because you got pwned. But its all good man, one love.

LMAO ya I got pwned. Ha! All hail to the mighty McLovin.



I know lots of guys have cooled off of Alex this past week because of the Lions game, but one game doesn't make a season. Alex will never be ELITE but he can be a FRANCHISE qb and there are only a handful of QBs I would say are clearly more productive than him.

I'm predicting Alex takes a big step forward this week and recaptures some of the bandwagoners that jumped off.
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
You can win with an 'efficient' quarterback. You must think that Peyton Mannings are a dime a dozen, like all we have to do is get rid of Alex and draft a franchise quarterback. All I am saying is if Alex steadily improves, we will continue to win games. And that is the name of the game right?

We don't have to constantly think about replacing him, if there is no reason to. If Kaep down the road proves he is the answer, than I have zero problem with that.

Yes, you can win with an efficient quarterback and yes I agree with you that the Peyton Mannings of this world are hard to find, but that wasn't my point. Alot of you guys were stating that it's smarter not to build around a quarterback and I disagree with that. There's not a single team in this league that has been more consistent than the Patriots or Colts over the past decade. Just because their quarterback got hurt 1 year and they missed the playoffs that one year doesn't mean you should forget about the other 8 years that they made the playoffs.

Alex is playing great football, and I have no problem with what we're doing with him. I don't want to sound like I'm hating on Alex. I hope he keeps growing as a quarterback here.
[ Edited by tjd808185 on Oct 28, 2011 at 7:28 PM ]
Originally posted by Baugh_Area:
I know lots of guys have cooled off of Alex this past week because of the Lions game, but one game doesn't make a season. Alex will never be ELITE but he can be a FRANCHISE qb and there are only a handful of QBs I would say are clearly more productive than him.

I'm predicting Alex takes a big step forward this week and recaptures some of the bandwagoners that jumped off.
nobody can say he won't be elite yet, nobody can say he will be good yet. Its been 6 games. Rob Johnson, frank reich, doug flutie, kevin kolb looked good for a few games less than 6 and were huge failures later in the season, or the following season.

Just let it play itself out.
Originally posted by jreff22:
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:


THATS THE POINT!!!!

lol Why not ?? If the rest of the team is so strong and we only need an average player to manage the game. right ?
Originally posted by jreff22:
How many guys are available right now that would be an upgrade?

You don't give him enough credit for what he has done. Remember short offseason, injured WR's and bad OL play to start the season.

I am giving him credit for his clean play, but your saying the rest of our team is so strong that we dont need an elite QB. So replacing him should not be that hard.

Why would you want to replace him? What has he done to garner consideration for replacement?

Alex will have to play better to stay another yr. If Kap We aint ready by then, we may have a problem. Now that we are past the Hard part of our schedule Alex needs to avg over 300 yds a game but still keep the efficiency. That would make our team scary. Right now team know that we will give them a cnace to win the game. We have the weapons to do it. Just think, he hits thos overthows to Crabs in stride and the game aint even close. That is the next level for this team to become eliete. You just cant game manage. Thats my expectation for Alex in the 2nd half of the season for us. We play too many poor defenses for him not to make that leap.
Originally posted by SF4EVA:
Alex will have to play better to stay another yr. If Kap We aint ready by then, we may have a problem. Now that we are past the Hard part of our schedule Alex needs to avg over 300 yds a game but still keep the efficiency. That would make our team scary. Right now team know that we will give them a cnace to win the game. We have the weapons to do it. Just think, he hits thos overthows to Crabs in stride and the game aint even close. That is the next level for this team to become eliete. You just cant game manage. Thats my expectation for Alex in the 2nd half of the season for us. We play too many poor defenses for him not to make that leap.

Originally posted by SF4EVA:
Originally posted by jreff22:
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:


THATS THE POINT!!!!

lol Why not ?? If the rest of the team is so strong and we only need an average player to manage the game. right ?
Originally posted by jreff22:
How many guys are available right now that would be an upgrade?

You don't give him enough credit for what he has done. Remember short offseason, injured WR's and bad OL play to start the season.

I am giving him credit for his clean play, but your saying the rest of our team is so strong that we dont need an elite QB. So replacing him should not be that hard.

Why would you want to replace him? What has he done to garner consideration for replacement?

Alex will have to play better to stay another yr. If Kap We aint ready by then, we may have a problem. Now that we are past the Hard part of our schedule Alex needs to avg over 300 yds a game but still keep the efficiency. That would make our team scary. Right now team know that we will give them a cnace to win the game. We have the weapons to do it. Just think, he hits thos overthows to Crabs in stride and the game aint even close. That is the next level for this team to become eliete. You just cant game manage. Thats my expectation for Alex in the 2nd half of the season for us. We play too many poor defenses for him not to make that leap.

This is BS, the only way this happens is if we need him too. Also He could easily get those yards if we weren't so inconsistent in other aspects of our team. Like say the Oline and WR catching the ball. Alex could've had 3 TDs versus Detroit if it weren't for drops and you all still would find a reason to complain about his play.
Originally posted by unst4bl3:
How do you know it wasn't the Rb's fault? just sayin.

Alex has yet to run into a running back on a handoff this season and kaep did it twice on one drive.
Originally posted by tjd808185:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
You can win with an 'efficient' quarterback. You must think that Peyton Mannings are a dime a dozen, like all we have to do is get rid of Alex and draft a franchise quarterback. All I am saying is if Alex steadily improves, we will continue to win games. And that is the name of the game right?

We don't have to constantly think about replacing him, if there is no reason to. If Kaep down the road proves he is the answer, than I have zero problem with that.

Yes, you can win with an efficient quarterback and yes I agree with you that the Peyton Mannings of this world are hard to find, but that wasn't my point. Alot of you guys were stating that it's smarter not to build around a quarterback and I disagree with that. There's not a single team in this league that has been more consistent than the Patriots or Colts over the past decade. Just because their quarterback got hurt 1 year and they missed the playoffs that one year doesn't mean you should forget about the other 8 years that they made the playoffs.

Alex is playing great football, and I have no problem with what we're doing with him. I don't want to sound like I'm hating on Alex. I hope he keeps growing as a quarterback here.

of course I would love to have a 'franchise' quarterback, in the context you're referring to. And of course it's smart to build around one, but our team is pretty much built, minus a some depth here and there. Alex is fine for this franchise as it's built right now. We just need him to fufill his role as manager of the game, and we continue to win games. Keep improving, keep it moving.
Originally posted by SF4EVA:
Originally posted by jreff22:
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:


THATS THE POINT!!!!

lol Why not ?? If the rest of the team is so strong and we only need an average player to manage the game. right ?
Originally posted by jreff22:
How many guys are available right now that would be an upgrade?

You don't give him enough credit for what he has done. Remember short offseason, injured WR's and bad OL play to start the season.

I am giving him credit for his clean play, but your saying the rest of our team is so strong that we dont need an elite QB. So replacing him should not be that hard.

Why would you want to replace him? What has he done to garner consideration for replacement?

Alex will have to play better to stay another yr. If Kap We aint ready by then, we may have a problem. Now that we are past the Hard part of our schedule Alex needs to avg over 300 yds a game but still keep the efficiency. That would make our team scary. Right now team know that we will give them a cnace to win the game. We have the weapons to do it. Just think, he hits thos overthows to Crabs in stride and the game aint even close. That is the next level for this team to become eliete. You just cant game manage. Thats my expectation for Alex in the 2nd half of the season for us. We play too many poor defenses for him not to make that leap.

Wins are the only stat that matters
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone