49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 802 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by jreff22:
Originally posted by SF4EVA:
Originally posted by jreff22:
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:


THATS THE POINT!!!!

lol Why not ?? If the rest of the team is so strong and we only need an average player to manage the game. right ?
Originally posted by jreff22:
How many guys are available right now that would be an upgrade?

You don't give him enough credit for what he has done. Remember short offseason, injured WR's and bad OL play to start the season.

I am giving him credit for his clean play, but your saying the rest of our team is so strong that we dont need an elite QB. So replacing him should not be that hard.

Why would you want to replace him? What has he done to garner consideration for replacement?

Alex will have to play better to stay another yr. If Kap We aint ready by then, we may have a problem. Now that we are past the Hard part of our schedule Alex needs to avg over 300 yds a game but still keep the efficiency. That would make our team scary. Right now team know that we will give them a cnace to win the game. We have the weapons to do it. Just think, he hits thos overthows to Crabs in stride and the game aint even close. That is the next level for this team to become eliete. You just cant game manage. Thats my expectation for Alex in the 2nd half of the season for us. We play too many poor defenses for him not to make that leap.

Wins are the only stat that matters

I wholly agree with that. If he kept his avg and we continued to win, I would not be mad at all. That is why i said" Keep the efficiency. We currently avg 1 point per 10 yds made.
Originally posted by gamechanger:
Originally posted by SF4EVA:
Originally posted by jreff22:
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:


THATS THE POINT!!!!

lol Why not ?? If the rest of the team is so strong and we only need an average player to manage the game. right ?
Originally posted by jreff22:
How many guys are available right now that would be an upgrade?

You don't give him enough credit for what he has done. Remember short offseason, injured WR's and bad OL play to start the season.

I am giving him credit for his clean play, but your saying the rest of our team is so strong that we dont need an elite QB. So replacing him should not be that hard.

Why would you want to replace him? What has he done to garner consideration for replacement?

Alex will have to play better to stay another yr. If Kap We aint ready by then, we may have a problem. Now that we are past the Hard part of our schedule Alex needs to avg over 300 yds a game but still keep the efficiency. That would make our team scary. Right now team know that we will give them a cnace to win the game. We have the weapons to do it. Just think, he hits thos overthows to Crabs in stride and the game aint even close. That is the next level for this team to become eliete. You just cant game manage. Thats my expectation for Alex in the 2nd half of the season for us. We play too many poor defenses for him not to make that leap.

This is BS, the only way this happens is if we need him too. Also He could easily get those yards if we weren't so inconsistent in other aspects of our team. Like say the Oline and WR catching the ball. Alex could've had 3 TDs versus Detroit if it weren't for drops and you all still would find a reason to complain about his play.

I didnt say that he was all at fault for the errors. He still needs to step up in the yds per game. just geting our 3rd down% up to 35% would get his total yds up to the 300 range. Dont get me twisted,I'm riding the Alex Train till the wheels fall off. At the same time he still needs to get better. Why you think he was at the office all week?
Originally posted by SF4EVA:
I wholly agree with that. If he kept his avg and we continued to win, I would not be mad at all. That is why i said" Keep the efficiency. We currently avg 1 point per 10 yds made.

I didnt say that he was all at fault for the errors. He still needs to step up in the yds per game. just geting our 3rd down% up to 35% would get his total yds up to the 300 range. Dont get me twisted,I'm riding the Alex Train till the wheels fall off. At the same time he still needs to get better. Why you think he was at the office all week?

because he's a professional and that's where he should be. you do know we are on pace to break a nfl record for scoring efficiency
Originally posted by stepnez:
Originally posted by SF4EVA:
I wholly agree with that. If he kept his avg and we continued to win, I would not be mad at all. That is why i said" Keep the efficiency. We currently avg 1 point per 10 yds made.

I didnt say that he was all at fault for the errors. He still needs to step up in the yds per game. just geting our 3rd down% up to 35% would get his total yds up to the 300 range. Dont get me twisted,I'm riding the Alex Train till the wheels fall off. At the same time he still needs to get better. Why you think he was at the office all week?

because he's a professional and that's where he should be. you do know we are on pace to break a nfl record for scoring efficiency

Um no he had 6 days off. Are you questioning me cuase i said something bad about Alex? I am Rooting for him to win at the same time wanting him to get better so we go farther in the postseason.
  • mike
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,827
Even if we don't currently need 300 yds a game, alex is just a stopgap because eventually we'll be setting an expectation that's greater than just making the playoffs, but also being a consistent contender. The only way I see us getting past green bay or maybe even new orleans is with a guy that can keep up with those gunslingers especially in the 4th quarter. They quickly drive the ball down the field and score, we match that. Sometimes running and throwing short routes just takes too much damn time.

Who knows though maybe he keeps getting better and does get that accuracy and zip. But for now I'll be happy we're winning. I do still think kaep is the future and alex's current stopgap role is perfect for the patient, slow development approach we need to take with colin.
i dont get it whats with the faciniation of yards?

did you guys know we have the most yard to TD ratio in the nfl?

if we keep up at this pace we will bear the 2007 (pr 2008 ) patriots which would be the best in nfl history
I am just curious where all the people went who had such a problem with people saying "wins are the only thing that matters" for the past 7 years?

From 2005-2010, some people (sus, leather and some others) said that same thing....that wins are the only important stat. And they were constantly attacked with things like "QBs dont have W-L records," or "its on the team, not Alex" or other similar comments. Now that we are winning, its conveniently the only stat that matters.

Just funny to me.
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
I am just curious where all the people went who had such a problem with people saying "wins are the only thing that matters" for the past 7 years?

From 2005-2010, some people (sus, leather and some others) said that same thing....that wins are the only important stat. And they were constantly attacked with things like "QBs dont have W-L records," or "its on the team, not Alex" or other similar comments. Now that we are winning, its conveniently the only stat that matters.

Just funny to me.
either way i think our offense will improve (yards and points wise) not that we havent got points on the board but we will put up more especially once we get our #1 WR back and anther week of absorbing and learning the week without too much pressure of gameplanning
Originally posted by mike:
Even if we don't currently need 300 yds a game, alex is just a stopgap because eventually we'll be setting an expectation that's greater than just making the playoffs, but also being a consistent contender. The only way I see us getting past green bay or maybe even new orleans is with a guy that can keep up with those gunslingers especially in the 4th quarter. They quickly drive the ball down the field and score, we match that. Sometimes running and throwing short routes just takes too much damn time.

Who knows though maybe he keeps getting better and does get that accuracy and zip. But for now I'll be happy we're winning. I do still think kaep is the future and alex's current stopgap role is perfect for the patient, slow development approach we need to take with colin.
You cant beat NO or GB by playing there style. We have to have long drives so there offense stays on the sideline, and rely on our defense to slow down that explosive offense. I think thats the best strategy against those teams.
Originally posted by KALI-KING:
Originally posted by mike:
Even if we don't currently need 300 yds a game, alex is just a stopgap because eventually we'll be setting an expectation that's greater than just making the playoffs, but also being a consistent contender. The only way I see us getting past green bay or maybe even new orleans is with a guy that can keep up with those gunslingers especially in the 4th quarter. They quickly drive the ball down the field and score, we match that. Sometimes running and throwing short routes just takes too much damn time.

Who knows though maybe he keeps getting better and does get that accuracy and zip. But for now I'll be happy we're winning. I do still think kaep is the future and alex's current stopgap role is perfect for the patient, slow development approach we need to take with colin.
You cant beat NO or GB by playing there style. We have to have long drives so there offense stays on the sideline, and rely on our defense to slow down that explosive offense. I think thats the best strategy against those teams.

eagles game?
Originally posted by tjd808185:
If you guys can find me a team as consistent as the Colts over the past decade I'd like to see them. This post isn't meant to be anti Alex but I really think some of you guys are off your rocker.

You don't want to be built around a franchise quarterback? Seriously. Indianapolis has made the playoffs for the last 7 years. Peyton Manning has had 1 injury in 14 years and that's enough reason for you guys to not want to build around a quarterback. Trust me on this one not having franchise quarterback will ruin more seasons than that. See Baltimore and their 4 missed playoff births despite having a top 6 defense practically every year.

Yeah let's just draft Peyton Manning next year with out 25th to 30ish draft pick because there is a Peyton in every draft. It is a team sport and our team is the most complete team in the NFL. Guys can whine and cry that Smith doesn't throw for three hundred yards every game but when he has been called upon to win games for us, he has delivered every time this year. Too many of the doubters seem to think the passing game is already running at full speed, but that is not the case, it is still a work in progress. For all any of us know Smith could be that franchise QB, we don't know that he has hit his ceiling yet, we have to wait and see how things play out. He is playing like a top ten QB right now and if he finishes the year playing like he has we have a great shot at beating any team we play. We do not have to get a top three QB to win with this team, all we need is someone to make smart decisions and get the ball to the playmakers and Smith has already shown that he can make plays himself. I just don't get how some folks on here can still be perpetually pessimistic while this team is playing its best football in a decade. The last time this TEAM was so strong we still had a hall of famer at QB.

About Baltimore, if they had any offense to go with that D, they would have maybe beat Indianapolis, New England or Pittsburgh one of those years. The time the did win it was with a power running game and a QB much worse than Smith.

I guess the point I am trying to make is there is only a need for a top three QB if you have glaring deficiencies in other areas of your team, we don't, we are solid all around and the best teams usually win, not just the team with the best QB.
[ Edited by Memphis9er on Oct 28, 2011 at 11:06 PM ]
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
I am just curious where all the people went who had such a problem with people saying "wins are the only thing that matters" for the past 7 years?

From 2005-2010, some people (sus, leather and some others) said that same thing....that wins are the only important stat. And they were constantly attacked with things like "QBs dont have W-L records," or "its on the team, not Alex" or other similar comments. Now that we are winning, its conveniently the only stat that matters.

Just funny to me.

Seriously? You can't see the difference?

The posters you mentioned blamed Alex almost entirely for previous losses. To them and many others, he was the only reason we lost games. That was a completely ignorant point of view. Now, they are still hating, I have no idea why. I don't even think they know why. They say s**t like "well he's not throwing for enough yards" or "he's just a game manager."

Now, defenders of Alex aren't giving him complete credit for wins, just simply acknowledging that he is playing well and contributing to the wins. There are a variety of other factors that are also contributing to the wins. I don't need to list them, if you don't know than oh well.

You know what's funny to me? Your comment: "Now that we are winning, it's conveniently the only stat that matters." Now that's funny.
[ Edited by AXEGRINDER on Oct 29, 2011 at 12:24 AM ]
Originally posted by Memphis9er:
Yeah let's just draft Peyton Manning next year with out 25th to 30ish draft pick because there is a Peyton in every draft. It is a team sport and our team is the most complete team in the NFL. Guys can whine and cry that Smith doesn't throw for three hundred yards every game but when he has been called upon to win games for us, he has delivered every time this year. Too many of the doubters seem to think the passing game is already running at full speed, but that is not the case, it is still a work in progress. For all any of us know Smith could be that franchise QB, we don't know that he has hit his ceiling yet, we have to wait and see how things play out. He is playing like a top ten QB right now and if he finishes the year playing like he has we have a great shot at beating any team we play. We do not have to get a top three QB to win with this team, all we need is someone to make smart decisions and get the ball to the playmakers and Smith has already shown that he can make plays himself. I just don't get how some folks on here can still be perpetually pessimistic while this team is playing its best football in a decade. The last time this TEAM was so strong we still had a hall of famer at QB.

About Baltimore, if they had any offense to go with that D, they would have maybe beat Indianapolis, New England or Pittsburgh one of those years. The time the did win it was with a power running game and a QB much worse than Smith.

I guess the point I am trying to make is there is only a need for a top three QB if you have glaring deficiencies in other areas of your team, we don't, we are solid all around and the best teams usually win, not just the team with the best QB.

I could say it 15 times and I'm sure you guys are still ignore the fact that I've clearly stated that I'm not bashing Alex Smith. I'm not calling for us to draft someone else or trade for "x" quarterback. I'm just simply stating the importance of the position.

This is a 98 page thread and there's alot of discussions going on. People were talking about whether or not Smith should get an extension and I saw a bunch of posts that you don't need a quarterback in this league. That's not something I agree with.

I'm not stating Alex can't be the guy, and he's certainly proving that he's capable of being it so far this year.
[ Edited by tjd808185 on Oct 29, 2011 at 12:48 AM ]
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
I am just curious where all the people went who had such a problem with people saying "wins are the only thing that matters" for the past 7 years?

From 2005-2010, some people (sus, leather and some others) said that same thing....that wins are the only important stat. And they were constantly attacked with things like "QBs dont have W-L records," or "its on the team, not Alex" or other similar comments. Now that we are winning, its conveniently the only stat that matters.

Just funny to me.

Seriously? Your post makes no sense.

How does it make no sense? For 6 years, Alex apologists would ridicule people who bashed Alex's poor performance in this way. Some would look at Alex's horrendous record as our starter and judge him based on that. Then the apologists came in and made comments deflecting the W-L record off of Alex and onto ANYone else, or make claims like QBs dont have W-L records.

Now, its the same people who are saying "winning is the only stat that matters," when people like Sus, Leatherface, etc. have been making that argument for 6+ years. But now that the W-L record is actually good, these same people who downplayed W-L over the past 6 years, are saying its the only thing that matters.

Its hilarious to me how hypocritical some are.

Not sure what isnt clear to you.
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
How does it make no sense? For 6 years, Alex apologists would ridicule people who bashed Alex's poor performance in this way. Some would look at Alex's horrendous record as our starter and judge him based on that. Then the apologists came in and made comments deflecting the W-L record off of Alex and onto ANYone else, or make claims like QBs dont have W-L records.

Now, its the same people who are saying "winning is the only stat that matters," when people like Sus, Leatherface, etc. have been making that argument for 6+ years. But now that the W-L record is actually good, these same people who downplayed W-L over the past 6 years, are saying its the only thing that matters.

Its hilarious to me how hypocritical some are.

Not sure what isnt clear to you.

I edited my post to further elaborate my point. Hypocritical? Stop living in the past.
Originally posted by tjd808185:
I could say it 15 times and I'm sure you guys are still ignore the fact that I've clearly stated that I'm not bashing Alex Smith. I'm not calling for us to draft someone else or trade for "x" quarterback. I'm just simply stating the importance of the position.

Baltimore had the 1 out of 2 best single season defenses of all time the year they won. Flacco has put up Joe Montana esque stats the past 2 seasons in Baltimore. Their offense is mediocre not horrible. They've finished 11th, 9th, and 16th in points. They're not much different than us, and that should be taken as a compliment towards us not a slight.

I'd say the new formula to win is the best quarterback with the best defense. League rules are making it harder and harder to beat the Aaron Rodgers or Drew Brees of this world. Right now Green Bay's defense looks beatable, but you go back to last year when they had a top 5 defense to go with Rodgers good luck beating that without a quarterback.

I don't get it. Sure. Smith isn't in the class of Rodgers or Brees, but he has definitely been capable of generating decent passing offense before. Didn't he actually outplayed Brees last year when the Saints and the 49ers met? And didn't he manage to stage an almost comeback against the Packers the last time the two teams met?
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone