49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 721 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by fastforward:
I don't get it. Sure. Smith isn't in the class of Rodgers or Brees, but he has definitely been capable of generating decent passing offense before. Didn't he actually outplayed Brees last year when the Saints and the 49ers met? And didn't he manage to stage an almost comeback against the Packers the last time the two teams met?

My point was not Alex can't do it. It's Alex is going to have to do it. We're going to need Alex to be what he was in the 2nd half against Philly or the Tampa game.

Dallas, Philly both of those teams moved the ball against with ease. They also shot themselves in the foot repeatedly. As good as our defense is it can't be relied upon playoff game upon playoff game.
[ Edited by tjd808185 on Oct 29, 2011 at 12:45 AM ]
Originally posted by tjd808185:
Originally posted by fastforward:
I don't get it. Sure. Smith isn't in the class of Rodgers or Brees, but he has definitely been capable of generating decent passing offense before. Didn't he actually outplayed Brees last year when the Saints and the 49ers met? And didn't he manage to stage an almost comeback against the Packers the last time the two teams met?

My point was not Alex can't do it. It's Alex is going to have to do it.

Dallas, Philly both of those teams moved the ball against with ease. They also shot themselves in the foot repeatedly. As good as our defense is it can't be relied upon playoff game upon playoff game.

By playoff time this offense will be dramatically improved, IMO.
Originally posted by tjd808185:
I could say it 15 times and I'm sure you guys are still ignore the fact that I've clearly stated that I'm not bashing Alex Smith. I'm not calling for us to draft someone else or trade for "x" quarterback. I'm just simply stating the importance of the position.

Here's the thing. This is a 98 page thread and there's alot of discussions going on. Some people are talking about extending Alex, others jump and say no or it's too early and then his defenders come in and point to Indy as a reason why building around a qb is a bad thing. Seriously? I have no problem with extending Smith because I agree with you he's playing fine and Peyton Manning is not coming here, but really.

I couldn't be happier with the way the team is looking right now. Like I said I hope Alex continues to grow and no problem with extending him.

We mostly agree, I knew you weren't bashing Smith, just saying that there aren't many elite qbs and you don't need one if you have a strong team.
Thought the new interview with Coach Meyer was really insightful. Pretty interesting to read that Alex was "devastated" that Turner left. Figured as much but "devastated?" Then again he must have known he would be stuck with Hostler.

Maybe Turner was one of his biggest supporters on the coaching staff. Obviously Nolan was a douche.
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
How does it make no sense? For 6 years, Alex apologists would ridicule people who bashed Alex's poor performance in this way. Some would look at Alex's horrendous record as our starter and judge him based on that. Then the apologists came in and made comments deflecting the W-L record off of Alex and onto ANYone else, or make claims like QBs dont have W-L records.

Now, its the same people who are saying "winning is the only stat that matters," when people like Sus, Leatherface, etc. have been making that argument for 6+ years. But now that the W-L record is actually good, these same people who downplayed W-L over the past 6 years, are saying its the only thing that matters.

Its hilarious to me how hypocritical some are.

Not sure what isnt clear to you.

Do you have this post saved somewhere on your computer? I feel like I've seen it many times from you.
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
I am just curious where all the people went who had such a problem with people saying "wins are the only thing that matters" for the past 7 years?

From 2005-2010, some people (sus, leather and some others) said that same thing....that wins are the only important stat. And they were constantly attacked with things like "QBs dont have W-L records," or "its on the team, not Alex" or other similar comments. Now that we are winning, its conveniently the only stat that matters.

Just funny to me.

Seriously? Your post makes no sense.

How does it make no sense? For 6 years, Alex apologists would ridicule people who bashed Alex's poor performance in this way. Some would look at Alex's horrendous record as our starter and judge him based on that. Then the apologists came in and made comments deflecting the W-L record off of Alex and onto ANYone else, or make claims like QBs dont have W-L records.

Now, its the same people who are saying "winning is the only stat that matters," when people like Sus, Leatherface, etc. have been making that argument for 6+ years. But now that the W-L record is actually good, these same people who downplayed W-L over the past 6 years, are saying its the only thing that matters.

Its hilarious to me how hypocritical some are.

Not sure what isnt clear to you.

For years now people like you have been flinging insults around here and getting away with it because they were not aimed at one person but at half of the zone.

It ought to be possible to discuss our starting quarterback without resorting to abuse, but a number of posters including yourself find this impossible.

This divisiveness has no further justification, as Smith is playing well and the team are winning. If you believe the team should replace its starting quarterback, it would be adult to do it with reason and logic and not insults.
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
I am just curious where all the people went who had such a problem with people saying "wins are the only thing that matters" for the past 7 years?

From 2005-2010, some people (sus, leather and some others) said that same thing....that wins are the only important stat. And they were constantly attacked with things like "QBs dont have W-L records," or "its on the team, not Alex" or other similar comments. Now that we are winning, its conveniently the only stat that matters.

Just funny to me.

Seriously? Your post makes no sense.

How does it make no sense? For 6 years, Alex apologists would ridicule people who bashed Alex's poor performance in this way. Some would look at Alex's horrendous record as our starter and judge him based on that. Then the apologists came in and made comments deflecting the W-L record off of Alex and onto ANYone else, or make claims like QBs dont have W-L records.

Now, its the same people who are saying "winning is the only stat that matters," when people like Sus, Leatherface, etc. have been making that argument for 6+ years. But now that the W-L record is actually good, these same people who downplayed W-L over the past 6 years, are saying its the only thing that matters.

Its hilarious to me how hypocritical some are.

Not sure what isnt clear to you.

nobody down plays wins and losses dude. why the f**k does anyone watch sports who doesnt care if their team wins or not?
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
How does it make no sense? For 6 years, Alex apologists would ridicule people who bashed Alex's poor performance in this way. Some would look at Alex's horrendous record as our starter and judge him based on that. Then the apologists came in and made comments deflecting the W-L record off of Alex and onto ANYone else, or make claims like QBs dont have W-L records.

Now, its the same people who are saying "winning is the only stat that matters," when people like Sus, Leatherface, etc. have been making that argument for 6+ years. But now that the W-L record is actually good, these same people who downplayed W-L over the past 6 years, are saying its the only thing that matters.

Its hilarious to me how hypocritical some are.

Not sure what isnt clear to you.

What's not clear to you is that this team was poorly managed and coached during the time you speak of. As a team they lost games and for people to blame the qb for those losses, things should be a little clearer now that we are winning. In those losses go find out how many games Alex started in and then go find how many times we had the lead in the 4th qtr only to lose it at the end. With better coaching we could have won a lot more games and the proof is in our record this season. How this is not clear to anyone that's a 9er fan baffles me!
Yawn....different team..typical anti smith arguments that are based on half truths. No question Cam is the better Athlete...if both had come out the same year, Alex would have been the 2nd qb chosen.
Originally posted by LambdaChi49:
Thought the new interview with Coach Meyer was really insightful. Pretty interesting to read that Alex was "devastated" that Turner left. Figured as much but "devastated?" Then again he must have known he would be stuck with Hostler.

Maybe Turner was one of his biggest supporters on the coaching staff. Obviously Nolan was a douche.


It was an interesting article, wasn't it? The fact that Smith has played under some of the worst coaches in the NFL seems to escape many people, some even saying that coaching doesn't matter! Turner gave Smith some hope that he would be taught how to play in the NFL, when he left...nothing! Nolan was the anti-offense kind of D coach I least wanted to see as a HC and he was the best HC until Harbaugh took over...yikes!
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by LambdaChi49:
Thought the new interview with Coach Meyer was really insightful. Pretty interesting to read that Alex was "devastated" that Turner left. Figured as much but "devastated?" Then again he must have known he would be stuck with Hostler.

Maybe Turner was one of his biggest supporters on the coaching staff. Obviously Nolan was a douche.


It was an interesting article, wasn't it? The fact that Smith has played under some of the worst coaches in the NFL seems to escape many people, some even saying that coaching doesn't matter! Turner gave Smith some hope that he would be taught how to play in the NFL, when he left...nothing! Nolan was the anti-offense kind of D coach I least wanted to see as a HC and he was the best HC until Harbaugh took over...yikes!

With the benefit of hindsight, SF became the black hole of coaching skills from Mooch to Harbaugh. I dont think Turner was that great, just significantly better that the others.

The team improved under Nolan, from a very low talent level, but I dont recall much in the way of player development. Likewise under Sing, with the possible exception of Vernon.
I think those of us who believe Alex is doing good and can take us places will just have to deal with the fact that just like there is a Yin to every Yang there will be those who will want to Hate on Alex just for the pure joy of hatin. So there is no real point to argue with those like Sus and those like him. As any argument that can be made will just hit a wall and be shot down by their own unwillingness to accept Alex Smith as our QB and as one that is showing he can be a pretty good one at that.

/thread

http://flic.kr/p/azYXws
  • rserda
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 20,306
Originally posted by ninerfan29:
I think those of us who believe Alex is doing good and can take us places will just have to deal with the fact that just like there is a Yin to every Yang there will be those who will want to Hate on Alex just for the pure joy of hatin. So there is no real point to argue with those like Sus and those like him. As any argument that can be made will just hit a wall and be shot down by their own unwillingness to accept Alex Smith as our QB and as one that is showing he can be a pretty good one at that.

/thread

http://flic.kr/p/azYXws


neither side should have to deal with anything. The facts are that Alex Smith is playing well and the team is winning. That is one thing that the haters can not deny! Facts can not be denied.
Originally posted by ninerfan29:
I think those of us who believe Alex is doing good and can take us places will just have to deal with the fact that just like there is a Yin to every Yang there will be those who will want to Hate on Alex just for the pure joy of hatin. So there is no real point to argue with those like Sus and those like him. As any argument that can be made will just hit a wall and be shot down by their own unwillingness to accept Alex Smith as our QB and as one that is showing he can be a pretty good one at that.

/thread

http://flic.kr/p/azYXws

If that is your attachment I think you mean Detractor rather than Retractor.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by LambdaChi49:
Thought the new interview with Coach Meyer was really insightful. Pretty interesting to read that Alex was "devastated" that Turner left. Figured as much but "devastated?" Then again he must have known he would be stuck with Hostler.

Maybe Turner was one of his biggest supporters on the coaching staff. Obviously Nolan was a douche.


It was an interesting article, wasn't it? The fact that Smith has played under some of the worst coaches in the NFL seems to escape many people, some even saying that coaching doesn't matter! Turner gave Smith some hope that he would be taught how to play in the NFL, when he left...nothing! Nolan was the anti-offense kind of D coach I least wanted to see as a HC and he was the best HC until Harbaugh took over...yikes!

I was most surprised to read Smith's comments about Singletary,
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone