Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 1,012 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
We have no idea of whether Smith is ahead of Harbaughs timetable for his improvement or behind. Since he plays things close to the vest, JH will keep us guessing about his view of Smith's upside. If he really likes where Alex is at the end of the season I could see him trying to wrap him up long term. If he still has doubts, then a shorter term deal seems reasonable. Anything shorter than three years would be counter productive as it will take some time to groom CK, Tolzien or another QB to take over.

The NFL may be considered a passing league but the teams who win superbowls tend to be balanced. Even Manning and Brady's teams had good, effective RBs..
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Just look at what we did to the Lions. That is the future of the NFL imho. A theory behind your comment is that in the last few superbowls, high passing offenses have thrown over bigger, older style defenses that are mainly designed to stop the run. Now, teams are starting to draft smaller, quicker defenses to compete with the vertical passing game. The problem is that when you have a balanced offense like the 49ers have, those smaller defenses are overmatched and confused, tribute to a good running game, and an efficient passing game. Conversely, the 49ers style of defense forces a team to be one-dimensional, and when you have a pass rush like the 49ers are in the midst of developing, that one dimension is difficult to maintain: turnovers are eventually forced.

You are overrating the Lions I dont think they are that good. Shut down a team like the Packers, Saints and Pats and then you can say our defense can shut down elite passing teams. Much of the Lions success is throwing the ball up to Johnson, you stop that and you stop them.

Ya and much of the Pats offense is Brady to Welker. You're proving my point. Stop that one dimension, and you stop that one team. The 49ers exposed the Lions and drew the blueprint of how to beat them.

Well your saying that in order for Alex to take us to the super bowl we must have an elite defense capable of shutting down elite offenses and an elite special teams unit. Im saying if we had an elite QB it would cover up for so many other weak areas in the team. Its very hard to keep an elite defense or special teams unit together year in and year out. A franchise QB would stabilize the position for a decade at least.

You have an over-reliance on the position. The entire team needs to be good to win at a high level. A great QB can mask issues on a team but at what price? Look at the Colts without Manning they are garbage, right now Alex has masked nothing and the team is playing great on all sides of the ball. I would rather have a well rounded team then a reliance on a single player.
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Just look at what we did to the Lions. That is the future of the NFL imho. A theory behind your comment is that in the last few superbowls, high passing offenses have thrown over bigger, older style defenses that are mainly designed to stop the run. Now, teams are starting to draft smaller, quicker defenses to compete with the vertical passing game. The problem is that when you have a balanced offense like the 49ers have, those smaller defenses are overmatched and confused, tribute to a good running game, and an efficient passing game. Conversely, the 49ers style of defense forces a team to be one-dimensional, and when you have a pass rush like the 49ers are in the midst of developing, that one dimension is difficult to maintain: turnovers are eventually forced.

You are overrating the Lions I dont think they are that good. Shut down a team like the Packers, Saints and Pats and then you can say our defense can shut down elite passing teams. Much of the Lions success is throwing the ball up to Johnson, you stop that and you stop them.

Ya and much of the Pats offense is Brady to Welker. You're proving my point. Stop that one dimension, and you stop that one team. The 49ers exposed the Lions and drew the blueprint of how to beat them.

Well your saying that in order for Alex to take us to the super bowl we must have an elite defense capable of shutting down elite offenses and an elite special teams unit. Im saying if we had an elite QB it would cover up for so many other weak areas in the team. Its very hard to keep an elite defense or special teams unit together year in and year out. A franchise QB would stabilize the position for a decade at least.

Well that may be true, but if you're using the quarterback position to mask defensive deficiencies, you better have one hell of a backup because you're mortgaging an awful lot on one player. Just look at the Colts. If Brady were to go down, I doubt the Pats would win another game all year. At least if Alex were to go down (god forbid), we'd have a chance because we have an elite running game and a great defense. We would just need someone to "manage" the game. You see where I'm going with this?
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
Originally posted by jreff22:
You have an over-reliance on the position. The entire team needs to be good to win at a high level. A great QB can mask issues on a team but at what price? Look at the Colts without Manning they are garbage, right now Alex has masked nothing and the team is playing great on all sides of the ball. I would rather have a well rounded team then a reliance on a single player.

Well then by that argument we can easily replace him with a hand full guys around league and get the same production, right ?
Originally posted by jreff22:
You have an over-reliance on the position. The entire team needs to be good to win at a high level. A great QB can mask issues on a team but at what price? Look at the Colts without Manning they are garbage, right now Alex has masked nothing and the team is playing great on all sides of the ball. I would rather have a well rounded team then a reliance on a single player.

Lol exactly.....you read my mind....almost word for word.
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by jreff22:
You have an over-reliance on the position. The entire team needs to be good to win at a high level. A great QB can mask issues on a team but at what price? Look at the Colts without Manning they are garbage, right now Alex has masked nothing and the team is playing great on all sides of the ball. I would rather have a well rounded team then a reliance on a single player.

Well then by that argument we can easily replace him with a hand full guys around league and get the same production, right ?



THATS THE POINT!!!! But there are no guys from around the league that could fill in with the same production, that I'm aware of. But even less when it comes to Brady, Rodgers, or Manning.
[ Edited by AXEGRINDER on Oct 28, 2011 at 6:46 PM ]
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by jreff22:
You have an over-reliance on the position. The entire team needs to be good to win at a high level. A great QB can mask issues on a team but at what price? Look at the Colts without Manning they are garbage, right now Alex has masked nothing and the team is playing great on all sides of the ball. I would rather have a well rounded team then a reliance on a single player.

Well then by that argument we can easily replace him with a hand full guys around league and get the same production, right ?

How many guys are available right now that would be an upgrade?

You don't give him enough credit for what he has done. Remember short offseason, injured WR's and bad OL play to start the season.
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:


THATS THE POINT!!!!

lol Why not ?? If the rest of the team is so strong and we only need an average player to manage the game. right ?
Originally posted by jreff22:
How many guys are available right now that would be an upgrade?

You don't give him enough credit for what he has done. Remember short offseason, injured WR's and bad OL play to start the season.

I am giving him credit for his clean play, but your saying the rest of our team is so strong that we dont need an elite QB. So replacing him should not be that hard.
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:


THATS THE POINT!!!!

lol Why not ?? If the rest of the team is so strong and we only need an average player to manage the game. right ?
Originally posted by jreff22:
How many guys are available right now that would be an upgrade?

You don't give him enough credit for what he has done. Remember short offseason, injured WR's and bad OL play to start the season.

I am giving him credit for his clean play, but your saying the rest of our team is so strong that we dont need an elite QB. So replacing him should not be that hard.

Then why the f**k would you want to replace him? You think elite qbs grow on trees?
At the same time people. Alex is much better. but not good enough. we are still 27th in the league in 3rd down eff. normal passing downs. This will be the # 1 reason why we wont go far in the playoffs. Right now we give up too many possesions to the other team. We have an excellent D but they can and will get tired. Then we will lose and all the Boo Birds will start to come out. Aex has to get better there. The good thing is as a team we are scoring 27 pts a game. That will keep us in games. Otherwise we keep him long enough to get kap ready to play.
Why dont we just enjoy this run and not spew hate right now. Our team is Winning and will most likely win 12 games this yr. Really excited for Sunday!!!!
I'm now convinced that you either don't understand, don't want to understand, or are f**kin around. You are easily the most biased poster on this entire board. Unwarranted I might add. But whatever, wallow in ignorance. I tried.

All good though.
If you guys can find me a team as consistent as the Colts over the past decade I'd like to see them. This post isn't meant to be anti Alex but I really think some of you guys are off your rocker.

You don't want to be built around a franchise quarterback? Seriously. Indianapolis has made the playoffs for the last 7 years. Peyton Manning has had 1 injury in 14 years and that's enough reason for you guys to not want to build around a quarterback. Trust me on this one not having franchise quarterback will ruin more seasons than that. See Baltimore and their 4 missed playoff births despite having a top 6 defense practically every year.
[ Edited by tjd808185 on Oct 28, 2011 at 6:59 PM ]
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:


THATS THE POINT!!!!

lol Why not ?? If the rest of the team is so strong and we only need an average player to manage the game. right ?
Originally posted by jreff22:
How many guys are available right now that would be an upgrade?

You don't give him enough credit for what he has done. Remember short offseason, injured WR's and bad OL play to start the season.

I am giving him credit for his clean play, but your saying the rest of our team is so strong that we dont need an elite QB. So replacing him should not be that hard.

Why would you want to replace him? What has he done to garner consideration for replacement?
Originally posted by tjd808185:
If you guys can find me a team as consistent as the Colts over the past decade I'd like to see them. This post isn't meant to be anti Alex but I really think some of you guys are off your rocker.

You don't want to be built around a franchise quarterback? Seriously. Indianapolis has made the playoffs for the last 7 years. Peyton Manning has had 1 injury in 14 years and that's enough reason for you guys to not want to build around a quarterback. Trust me on this one not having franchise quarterback will ruin more seasons than that. See Baltimore and their 4 missed playoff births despite having a top 6 defense practically every year.
Its not that we don't want a franchise QB, its that Alex is doing what is needed to win and almost be 6-0. Whimsically replacing him for another QB might not give the results everybody is expecting.
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
I'm now convinced that you either don't understand, don't want to understand, or are f**kin around. You are easily the most biased poster on this entire board. Unwarranted I might add. But whatever, wallow in ignorance. I tried.

All good though.

Man you just because you got pwned. But its all good man, one love.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone