Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 1,003 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by susweel:
I posted this in the Fitzpatrick thread but it should probably go here.


It would be an epic mistake if the Niners signed Alex to any long term deal. While he has improved from a bottom 5 qb in the league to maybe the15th or 16th best QB in the NFL. Niners still need to upgrade the position, we need someone who can be a superstar one day and not just a game manager.

So, you are saying his ceiling has been reached? Seems like you admit you might have been wrong on him in the past. Are you certain this time?
Originally posted by firehouse538:
He's 27, improving, and gaining confidence. Not to mention Kaep needs time (rewatched the bucs game and he ran into the running back twice on handoffs). I could see a 3-5 year deal at a friendly 6-9 million range after the season, especially due to the weak free agency class and no opportunity to draft a franchise quarterback in the 20's range.

How do you know it wasn't the Rb's fault? just sayin.
Originally posted by susweel:
I posted this in the Fitzpatrick thread but it should probably go here.


It would be an epic mistake if the Niners signed Alex to any long term deal. While he has improved from a bottom 5 qb in the league to maybe the15th or 16th best QB in the NFL. Niners still need to upgrade the position, we need someone who can be a superstar one day and not just a game manager.

You still don't get it. Perhaps you never will.

The 49ers style of offense does not require a 'superstar' QB. It requires a QB to manage games and minimize mistakes. This is not a Pats/Packers/Lions style of offense that needs 40-50 pass attempts per game to be successful. Alex would not fit well with that style of offense which IMO, the NFL will transition out of in due time. That vertical style of offense is far to dependant on the quarterback position. And how often does a 'superstar' QB come along? It is far easier to have a manager type QB and find yourself an elite runningback, which we already have.
I'd like to see Alex get extended as soon as possible if only because it might get more expensive the longer the season goes. I'd like to see him her long term, but not necessarily as the starter. He's proven he can manage the game, so if Kaep or someone else improves and takes his job, I'd love to keep him as the backup.

Wil that happen tho? No chance in hell. LOL!!

He'll want better money, the team won't give it to him early, and if he plays well and won't have a starters job here, he'll go elswhere.

So basically, nevermind....
i say at season's end give him another 1 year deal, then in year 3 kaepernick is ready to start
Originally posted by Marvin49:
I'd like to see Alex get extended as soon as possible if only because it might get more expensive the longer the season goes. I'd like to see him her long term, but not necessarily as the starter. He's proven he can manage the game, so if Kaep or someone else improves and takes his job, I'd love to keep him as the backup.

Wil that happen tho? No chance in hell. LOL!!

He'll want better money, the team won't give it to him early, and if he plays well and won't have a starters job here, he'll go elswhere.

So basically, nevermind....

if he gets extended before the seasons over it will be because the team approaches him with a deal, not the other way around imo. If they offer him a fair deal, he'll take it. Really doubt he wants to go to another team and abandon the coach who was instrumental in resurrecting his career.
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,638
Originally posted by oldman9er:
I can see Alex going for a 3 year, 27 mil type of arrangement at this rate.

The money is good to make up for the shorter contract... and Alex doesn't have to feel overly committed to the organization if things somehow go downhill. Ideal situation for SF and Alex... good money to see if he can keep it up and improve further... not a back-breaker if they want to move on in 2-3 years. And if things go well and he's staring at contract talks at 30 years of age? He can still get another deal cooking, if he wants to play for a handful more years after that.

Start there and build in some incentives including options for additional years.

Frankly, if Smith has the kind of season it looks like he may have, I don't see anything less than a 5 year deal.
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Originally posted by susweel:
I posted this in the Fitzpatrick thread but it should probably go here.


It would be an epic mistake if the Niners signed Alex to any long term deal. While he has improved from a bottom 5 qb in the league to maybe the15th or 16th best QB in the NFL. Niners still need to upgrade the position, we need someone who can be a superstar one day and not just a game manager.

You still don't get it. Perhaps you never will.

The 49ers style of offense does not require a 'superstar' QB. It requires a QB to manage games and minimize mistakes. This is not a Pats/Packers/Lions style of offense that needs 40-50 pass attempts per game to be successful. Alex would not fit well with that style of offense which IMO, the NFL will transition out of in due time. That vertical style of offense is far to dependant on the quarterback position. And how often does a 'superstar' QB come along? It is far easier to have a manager type QB and find yourself an elite runningback, which we already have.

The NFL is a passing league now and its getting harder and harder for strong shutdown style of defenses to emerge. The name of the game is scoring points thru the passing game. Just at look at the recent super bowl winners and most have had good passing games with good QBs. The last true "game manager" of a QB to win the super bowl was Tampa Bay with Brad Johnson and that was 2002. The game is changing and running the ball and defense only gets you so far these days. Elite QBs is what wins super bowls and thats what I would ultimately like to see again is the San Francisco 49ers win more super bowls. I have nothing against Alex and I hope he continues to get better but Im not sure if he can ever reach that elite status.
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Originally posted by susweel:
I posted this in the Fitzpatrick thread but it should probably go here.


It would be an epic mistake if the Niners signed Alex to any long term deal. While he has improved from a bottom 5 qb in the league to maybe the15th or 16th best QB in the NFL. Niners still need to upgrade the position, we need someone who can be a superstar one day and not just a game manager.

You still don't get it. Perhaps you never will.

The 49ers style of offense does not require a 'superstar' QB. It requires a QB to manage games and minimize mistakes. This is not a Pats/Packers/Lions style of offense that needs 40-50 pass attempts per game to be successful. Alex would not fit well with that style of offense which IMO, the NFL will transition out of in due time. That vertical style of offense is far to dependant on the quarterback position. And how often does a 'superstar' QB come along? It is far easier to have a manager type QB and find yourself an elite runningback, which we already have.

The NFL is a passing league now and its getting harder and harder for strong shutdown style of defenses to emerge. The name of the game is scoring points thru the passing game. Just at look at the recent super bowl winners and most have had good passing games with good QBs. The last true "game manager" of a QB to win the super bowl was Tampa Bay with Brad Johnson and that was 2002. The game is changing and running the ball and defense only gets you so far these days. Elite QBs is what wins super bowls and thats what I would ultimately like to see again is the San Francisco 49ers win more super bowls. I have nothing against Alex and I hope he continues to get better but Im not sure if he can ever reach that elite status.

Just look at what we did to the Lions. That is the future of the NFL imho. A theory behind your comment is that in the last few superbowls, high passing offenses have thrown over bigger, older style defenses that are mainly designed to stop the run. Now, teams are starting to draft smaller, quicker defenses to compete with the vertical passing game. The problem is that when you have a balanced offense like the 49ers have, those smaller defenses are overmatched and confused, tribute to a good running game, and an efficient passing game. Conversely, the 49ers style of defense forces a team to be one-dimensional, and when you have a pass rush like the 49ers are in the midst of developing, that one dimension is difficult to maintain: turnovers are eventually forced.
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,638
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Originally posted by susweel:
I posted this in the Fitzpatrick thread but it should probably go here.


It would be an epic mistake if the Niners signed Alex to any long term deal. While he has improved from a bottom 5 qb in the league to maybe the15th or 16th best QB in the NFL. Niners still need to upgrade the position, we need someone who can be a superstar one day and not just a game manager.

You still don't get it. Perhaps you never will.

The 49ers style of offense does not require a 'superstar' QB. It requires a QB to manage games and minimize mistakes. This is not a Pats/Packers/Lions style of offense that needs 40-50 pass attempts per game to be successful. Alex would not fit well with that style of offense which IMO, the NFL will transition out of in due time. That vertical style of offense is far to dependant on the quarterback position. And how often does a 'superstar' QB come along? It is far easier to have a manager type QB and find yourself an elite runningback, which we already have.

The NFL is a passing league now and its getting harder and harder for strong shutdown style of defenses to emerge. The name of the game is scoring points thru the passing game. Just at look at the recent super bowl winners and most have had good passing games with good QBs. The last true "game manager" of a QB to win the super bowl was Tampa Bay with Brad Johnson and that was 2002. The game is changing and running the ball and defense only gets you so far these days. Elite QBs is what wins super bowls and thats what I would ultimately like to see again is the San Francisco 49ers win more super bowls. I have nothing against Alex and I hope he continues to get better but Im not sure if he can ever reach that elite status.

Just look at what we did to the Lions. That is the future of the NFL imho. A theory behind your comment is that in the last few superbowls, high passing offenses have thrown over bigger, older style defenses that are mainly designed to stop the run. Now, teams are starting to draft smaller, quicker defenses to compete with the vertical passing game. The problem is that when you have a balanced offense like the 49ers have, those smaller defenses are overmatched and confused, tribute to a good running game, and an efficient passing game. Conversely, the 49ers style of defense forces a team to be one-dimensional, and when you have a pass rush like the 49ers are in the midst of developing, that one dimension is difficult to maintain: turnovers are eventually forced.
The NFL is a monkey-see-monkey-do league. It HAS evolved to largely a passing league but there is also nothing as certain as change. The light, quicker pass defense system are vulnerable to a heavy duty running game such as Harbaugh has brought. So while I am not suggesting that is where the league is going but it is something that is unique to SF. If Gore and Hunter stay healthy, with Dixon to carry the laundry sometimes as well, we may be seeing something that could move the needle. If that happens, it will open up the passing game a lot more readily than a lot of people may think.
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Just look at what we did to the Lions. That is the future of the NFL imho. A theory behind your comment is that in the last few superbowls, high passing offenses have thrown over bigger, older style defenses that are mainly designed to stop the run. Now, teams are starting to draft smaller, quicker defenses to compete with the vertical passing game. The problem is that when you have a balanced offense like the 49ers have, those smaller defenses are overmatched and confused, tribute to a good running game, and an efficient passing game. Conversely, the 49ers style of defense forces a team to be one-dimensional, and when you have a pass rush like the 49ers are in the midst of developing, that one dimension is difficult to maintain: turnovers are eventually forced.

You are overrating the Lions I dont think they are that good. Shut down a team like the Packers, Saints and Pats and then you can say our defense can shut down elite passing teams. Much of the Lions success is throwing the ball up to Johnson, you stop that and you stop them.
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Just look at what we did to the Lions. That is the future of the NFL imho. A theory behind your comment is that in the last few superbowls, high passing offenses have thrown over bigger, older style defenses that are mainly designed to stop the run. Now, teams are starting to draft smaller, quicker defenses to compete with the vertical passing game. The problem is that when you have a balanced offense like the 49ers have, those smaller defenses are overmatched and confused, tribute to a good running game, and an efficient passing game. Conversely, the 49ers style of defense forces a team to be one-dimensional, and when you have a pass rush like the 49ers are in the midst of developing, that one dimension is difficult to maintain: turnovers are eventually forced.

You are overrating the Lions I dont think they are that good. Shut down a team like the Packers, Saints and Pats and then you can say our defense can shut down elite passing teams. Much of the Lions success is throwing the ball up to Johnson, you stop that and you stop them.

Ya and much of the Pats offense is Brady to Welker. You're proving my point. Stop that one dimension, and you stop that one team. The 49ers exposed the Lions and drew the blueprint of how to beat them.

We haven't played the Pats or the Packers yet, but I would think they would have a tougher time game planning against us. The 49ers have more facets to worry about. But we shall see, right?
[ Edited by AXEGRINDER on Oct 28, 2011 at 6:27 PM ]
Originally posted by dj43:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Originally posted by susweel:
I posted this in the Fitzpatrick thread but it should probably go here.


It would be an epic mistake if the Niners signed Alex to any long term deal. While he has improved from a bottom 5 qb in the league to maybe the15th or 16th best QB in the NFL. Niners still need to upgrade the position, we need someone who can be a superstar one day and not just a game manager.

You still don't get it. Perhaps you never will.

The 49ers style of offense does not require a 'superstar' QB. It requires a QB to manage games and minimize mistakes. This is not a Pats/Packers/Lions style of offense that needs 40-50 pass attempts per game to be successful. Alex would not fit well with that style of offense which IMO, the NFL will transition out of in due time. That vertical style of offense is far to dependant on the quarterback position. And how often does a 'superstar' QB come along? It is far easier to have a manager type QB and find yourself an elite runningback, which we already have.

The NFL is a passing league now and its getting harder and harder for strong shutdown style of defenses to emerge. The name of the game is scoring points thru the passing game. Just at look at the recent super bowl winners and most have had good passing games with good QBs. The last true "game manager" of a QB to win the super bowl was Tampa Bay with Brad Johnson and that was 2002. The game is changing and running the ball and defense only gets you so far these days. Elite QBs is what wins super bowls and thats what I would ultimately like to see again is the San Francisco 49ers win more super bowls. I have nothing against Alex and I hope he continues to get better but Im not sure if he can ever reach that elite status.

Just look at what we did to the Lions. That is the future of the NFL imho. A theory behind your comment is that in the last few superbowls, high passing offenses have thrown over bigger, older style defenses that are mainly designed to stop the run. Now, teams are starting to draft smaller, quicker defenses to compete with the vertical passing game. The problem is that when you have a balanced offense like the 49ers have, those smaller defenses are overmatched and confused, tribute to a good running game, and an efficient passing game. Conversely, the 49ers style of defense forces a team to be one-dimensional, and when you have a pass rush like the 49ers are in the midst of developing, that one dimension is difficult to maintain: turnovers are eventually forced.
The NFL is a monkey-see-monkey-do league. It HAS evolved to largely a passing league but there is also nothing as certain as change. The light, quicker pass defense system are vulnerable to a heavy duty running game such as Harbaugh has brought. So while I am not suggesting that is where the league is going but it is something that is unique to SF. If Gore and Hunter stay healthy, with Dixon to carry the laundry sometimes as well, we may be seeing something that could move the needle. If that happens, it will open up the passing game a lot more readily than a lot of people may think.

The West Coast Offense was also unique to SF at one time. Look how that turned out.
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Just look at what we did to the Lions. That is the future of the NFL imho. A theory behind your comment is that in the last few superbowls, high passing offenses have thrown over bigger, older style defenses that are mainly designed to stop the run. Now, teams are starting to draft smaller, quicker defenses to compete with the vertical passing game. The problem is that when you have a balanced offense like the 49ers have, those smaller defenses are overmatched and confused, tribute to a good running game, and an efficient passing game. Conversely, the 49ers style of defense forces a team to be one-dimensional, and when you have a pass rush like the 49ers are in the midst of developing, that one dimension is difficult to maintain: turnovers are eventually forced.

You are overrating the Lions I dont think they are that good. Shut down a team like the Packers, Saints and Pats and then you can say our defense can shut down elite passing teams. Much of the Lions success is throwing the ball up to Johnson, you stop that and you stop them.


The QB decision is Jim's to make and he decided on Kap, for now I will assume he is the new prince.
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Just look at what we did to the Lions. That is the future of the NFL imho. A theory behind your comment is that in the last few superbowls, high passing offenses have thrown over bigger, older style defenses that are mainly designed to stop the run. Now, teams are starting to draft smaller, quicker defenses to compete with the vertical passing game. The problem is that when you have a balanced offense like the 49ers have, those smaller defenses are overmatched and confused, tribute to a good running game, and an efficient passing game. Conversely, the 49ers style of defense forces a team to be one-dimensional, and when you have a pass rush like the 49ers are in the midst of developing, that one dimension is difficult to maintain: turnovers are eventually forced.

You are overrating the Lions I dont think they are that good. Shut down a team like the Packers, Saints and Pats and then you can say our defense can shut down elite passing teams. Much of the Lions success is throwing the ball up to Johnson, you stop that and you stop them.

Ya and much of the Pats offense is Brady to Welker. You're proving my point. Stop that one dimension, and you stop that one team. The 49ers exposed the Lions and drew the blueprint of how to beat them.

Well your saying that in order for Alex to take us to the super bowl we must have an elite defense capable of shutting down elite offenses and an elite special teams unit. Im saying if we had an elite QB it would cover up for so many other weak areas in the team. Its very hard to keep an elite defense or special teams unit together year in and year out. A franchise QB would stabilize the position for a decade at least.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone