Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Originally posted by susweel:
I posted this in the Fitzpatrick thread but it should probably go here.
It would be an epic mistake if the Niners signed Alex to any long term deal. While he has improved from a bottom 5 qb in the league to maybe the15th or 16th best QB in the NFL. Niners still need to upgrade the position, we need someone who can be a superstar one day and not just a game manager.
You still don't get it. Perhaps you never will.
The 49ers style of offense does not require a 'superstar' QB. It requires a QB to manage games and minimize mistakes. This is not a Pats/Packers/Lions style of offense that needs 40-50 pass attempts per game to be successful. Alex would not fit well with that style of offense which IMO, the NFL will transition out of in due time. That vertical style of offense is far to dependant on the quarterback position. And how often does a 'superstar' QB come along? It is far easier to have a manager type QB and find yourself an elite runningback, which we already have. 
The NFL is a passing league now and its getting harder and harder for strong shutdown style of defenses to emerge. The name of the game is scoring points thru the passing game. Just at look at the recent super bowl winners and most have had good passing games with good QBs. The last true "game manager" of a QB to win the super bowl was Tampa Bay with Brad Johnson and that was 2002. The game is changing and running the ball and defense only gets you so far these days. Elite QBs is what wins super bowls and thats what I would ultimately like to see again is the San Francisco 49ers win more super bowls. I have nothing against Alex and I hope he continues to get better but Im not sure if he can ever reach that elite status.
Just look at what we did to the Lions. That is the future of the NFL imho. A theory behind your comment is that in the last few superbowls, high passing offenses have thrown over bigger, older style defenses that are mainly designed to stop the run. Now, teams are starting to draft smaller, quicker defenses to compete with the vertical passing game. The problem is that when you have a balanced offense like the 49ers have, those smaller defenses are overmatched and confused, tribute to a good running game,
and an efficient passing game. Conversely, the 49ers style of defense forces a team to be one-dimensional, and when you have a pass rush like the 49ers are in the midst of developing, that one dimension is difficult to maintain: turnovers are eventually forced.