49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 983 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by hondakillerzx:
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by dj43:
An interesting story is emerging from Buffalo where the Bills have put together a deal for Ryan Fitzpatrick that will pay him $10MILLION a year for 6 years with $24MILLION guaranteed.

We can be sure that Alex's agent is watching closely. If Smith continues to play as he has and the 49ers get to the NFC Championship game, the Fitzpatrick deal will be the benchmark for the negotiations for an extension for Alex. Who saw that coming?

No didn't see that coming for Fritzpatrick...


The difference will be that Fitz had two good years in a row. Alex should get a new deal, but not for that much.

alex will probably get a one or two year deal because the niners are gonna wanna see him do it for a little while before they extend him long term

I'd be cool with a 1 or 2 year deal. Im not sure if he would go for it.

He'd be stupid to not go for it. He finally has the right coach, right staff, right offense, players (well except a true #1 WR), etc. He is winning the fans over. It's a win win situation for him. He wouldn't have to compete either.

The only other place I see him possibly going is Oakland. The raiders don't have any picks (LOL) really so unless Carson really pans out...Alex would be a great option.
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
Originally posted by LambdaChi49:
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by hondakillerzx:
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by dj43:
An interesting story is emerging from Buffalo where the Bills have put together a deal for Ryan Fitzpatrick that will pay him $10MILLION a year for 6 years with $24MILLION guaranteed.

We can be sure that Alex's agent is watching closely. If Smith continues to play as he has and the 49ers get to the NFC Championship game, the Fitzpatrick deal will be the benchmark for the negotiations for an extension for Alex. Who saw that coming?

No didn't see that coming for Fritzpatrick...


The difference will be that Fitz had two good years in a row. Alex should get a new deal, but not for that much.

alex will probably get a one or two year deal because the niners are gonna wanna see him do it for a little while before they extend him long term

I'd be cool with a 1 or 2 year deal. Im not sure if he would go for it.

He'd be stupid to not go for it. He finally has the right coach, right staff, right offense, players (well except a true #1 WR), etc. He is winning the fans over. It's a win win situation for him. He wouldn't have to compete either.

The only other place I see him possibly going is Oakland. The raiders don't have any picks (LOL) really so unless Carson really pans out...Alex would be a great option.


This next contract would probably be his last big chance at another big pay day. Im sure his agent and Alex would like to have the long term security of a 5 year deal.
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
The difference will be that Fitz had two good years in a row. Alex should get a new deal, but not for that much.

Smith had better QB rating than Fitzpatrick last year, and their winning records weren't that much different (Smith: 3-7, Fitzpatrick 4-9)
I can see Alex going for a 3 year, 27 mil type of arrangement at this rate.

The money is good to make up for the shorter contract... and Alex doesn't have to feel overly committed to the organization if things somehow go downhill. Ideal situation for SF and Alex... good money to see if he can keep it up and improve further... not a back-breaker if they want to move on in 2-3 years. And if things go well and he's staring at contract talks at 30 years of age? He can still get another deal cooking, if he wants to play for a handful more years after that.
  • Nes49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 6,105
Isn't it too soon to talk extension?
I think if the team continued to win this year and next, Smith most likely will not want to go any where else if he isn't starting on a good team. He had 7 years of bad and the ridiculous. I don't think he wants to revisit that on another team no matter how good the money.
[ Edited by qnnhan7 on Oct 28, 2011 at 1:48 PM ]
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by hondakillerzx:
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by dj43:
An interesting story is emerging from Buffalo where the Bills have put together a deal for Ryan Fitzpatrick that will pay him $10MILLION a year for 6 years with $24MILLION guaranteed.

We can be sure that Alex's agent is watching closely. If Smith continues to play as he has and the 49ers get to the NFC Championship game, the Fitzpatrick deal will be the benchmark for the negotiations for an extension for Alex. Who saw that coming?

No didn't see that coming for Fritzpatrick...


The difference will be that Fitz had two good years in a row. Alex should get a new deal, but not for that much.

alex will probably get a one or two year deal because the niners are gonna wanna see him do it for a little while before they extend him long term

I'd be cool with a 1 or 2 year deal. Im not sure if he would go for it.

If he continues as is or looks better has the whole offense continues to develop I can't see him taking just a one-year deal. I think Alex has shown it is not all about the money and I believe he will want to stay in S.F. but they will have to do better than a one-year contract. Maybe a two year deal but I think three is more realistic.
Originally posted by fastforward:
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
The difference will be that Fitz had two good years in a row. Alex should get a new deal, but not for that much.

Smith had better QB rating than Fitzpatrick last year, and their winning records weren't that much different (Smith: 3-7, Fitzpatrick 4-9)

Yes, by .3 ... But that doesn't reflect the sheer numbers Fitz put up: 3000 yards, 23 TDs - 15 INTs.

Smith only played in 11 games and had 14 TD. Fitzpatrick only played in 13 and had those numbers.
Originally posted by Nes49:
Isn't it too soon to talk extension?

This, and too soon to be talking playoffs but people keep doing it.

All I keep saying is remember teh Josh Mcdaniels broncos...
Originally posted by Nes49:
Isn't it too soon to talk extension?

It wasn't too soon for Fitzpatrick apparently.
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Yes, by .3 ... But that doesn't reflect the sheer numbers Fitz put up: 3000 yards, 23 TDs - 15 INTs.

Smith only played in 11 games and had 14 TD. Fitzpatrick only played in 13 and had those numbers.

Different offensive systems. Smith's YPA was actually higher than Fitzpatrick.
[ Edited by fastforward on Oct 28, 2011 at 2:19 PM ]
He's 27, improving, and gaining confidence. Not to mention Kaep needs time (rewatched the bucs game and he ran into the running back twice on handoffs). I could see a 3-5 year deal at a friendly 6-9 million range after the season, especially due to the weak free agency class and no opportunity to draft a franchise quarterback in the 20's range.
  • Nes49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 6,105
Originally posted by firehouse538:
He's 27, improving, and gaining confidence. Not to mention Kaep needs time (rewatched the bucs game and he ran into the running back twice on handoffs). I could see a 3-5 year deal at a friendly 6-9 million range after the season, especially due to the weak free agency class and no opportunity to draft a franchise quarterback in the 20's range.

That's right, he's was hella young when we drafted him. I believe he was the 2nd youngest player evef drafted.
Originally posted by susweel:
I posted this in the Fitzpatrick thread but it should probably go here.


It would be an epic mistake if the Niners signed Alex to any long term deal. While he has improved from a bottom 5 qb in the league to maybe the15th or 16th best QB in the NFL. Niners still need to upgrade the position, we need someone who can be a superstar one day and not just a game manager.

so you want a "brett favre?" a media darling gunslinger who played foooooreeeeevvvvveeeeerrrr on some really really talented teams. how many superbowl rings does he have to show for it? A QBs JOB ABOVE ALL ELSE IS TO MANAGE THE GAME!!!! dont risk big plays when all you need is some small, smart ones to seal the victory. tony romo is a *STAR* with glitz and glam. alex is a game manager. look who has the better record
one thing that nobody has mentioned so far is how much the other players on offense want to play FOR ALEX and want to see him succeed. it is that TEAM element that makes a winner much more than any statistical measure. of all the missteps this organization has made with alex, the biggest one BY FAR would be to offer him a one or two year deal. I say a 5 year deal, structured somewhat similar to gore's deal, that is franchise friendly, incentive-laden with pretty decent but not outrageous guaranteed money. Alex would go for it because he believes in himself and his ability to play well and EARN those incentives. IF he didnt play well alex is not the kind of guy who would care that he didnt earn "that much money." he doesnt want to be "given" a large contract, but he would love to buy into some security and stability with a great coach and great team like he finally has in SF. this is what he has been waiting his ENTIRE CAREER for. Anything reasonable, plus incentives, he will take. but a 1 or 2 year deal if we reach the playoffs would be a total insult and athletes do have some pride.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone