49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 609 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by ktate14:
Alex seems like a guy that will be better in his 30's but[/b] that might not be saying much[b]...for me ..I may have had some moments of frustration with Smith...you may find a post here and there over the yrs where I may of lost my mind...lol...I gurantee it's not more than 5 though that's for sure...Most of my posts were in support of Smith and I always tried to stay away from the negative with him...nowadays I just want him to take care of the football...that's all i ask for!...I'm no longer looking for the prolific stats, 300 yard game, 4 TD's etc etc...just take care of the football and the rest will fall into place.....

Damn with faint praise, much?

Smith has had some good games and shown signs of getting it together over the years, but this is inarguably the best he has been. Whilst Detroit was a tough place for the entire O, they did what was needed. Other than that he has looked composed and, on occasions when he has been flushed out of the pocket, damn good. Several of his passes, on the move with defenders breathing down his neck, would not have disgraced any 49er QB in history.

And this improvement I put down to good coaching. Not only of him, but of the line and the rest of the O. And, I think, a reaction to the team just being a better place to play. But if it is largely the coaching, the impact has only just started. I agree that he will probably continue to improve into his 30's, many quarterbacks do. But your comment I emboldened seems odd for someone who claims to be a supporter. Harbaugh understands quarterbacks, and I have every confidence that he will bring out the best in Smith, given the time.

And you just want him to take care of the football? Havent you noticed he is one of the safest QB's in the NFL? And the team is not set up right now for 300 yard games. Wait till Braylon is back and healthy and working at last in tandem with Crabtree. No guarantees, but that will be the time to watch out. But as long as the wins keep coming, I shant mind much.
Let's go Alex.
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,637
An interesting story is emerging from Buffalo where the Bills have put together a deal for Ryan Fitzpatrick that will pay him $10MILLION a year for 6 years with $24MILLION guaranteed.

We can be sure that Alex's agent is watching closely. If Smith continues to play as he has and the 49ers get to the NFC Championship game, the Fitzpatrick deal will be the benchmark for the negotiations for an extension for Alex. Who saw that coming?
Originally posted by dj43:
An interesting story is emerging from Buffalo where the Bills have put together a deal for Ryan Fitzpatrick that will pay him $10MILLION a year for 6 years with $24MILLION guaranteed.

We can be sure that Alex's agent is watching closely. If Smith continues to play as he has and the 49ers get to the NFC Championship game, the Fitzpatrick deal will be the benchmark for the negotiations for an extension for Alex. Who saw that coming?

No didn't see that coming for Fritzpatrick...

Originally posted by 190836:
Alex Smith can be a good qb, but can he win a SB?

Don't see why not. He's played well with pressure in his face. He's made clutch drives to help us win... even in games where little was going right and frustration was building. He's helped us come back from larger deficits when needed.

I don't know that this team can win in a shoot-out THIS YEAR with the elite QBs like Rodgers or Brees... but I think we can get to where they are in the coming seasons. If Alex can be an 82 QBR with Singletary? Then he can be a 90+ QBR with Harbaugh... check... So if Alex can be a 90+ QBR in year one of Harbaugh? Hmmm... about that year 2... and then 3? etc.
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,637
Originally posted by oldman9er:
Originally posted by 190836:
Alex Smith can be a good qb, but can he win a SB?

Don't see why not. He's played well with pressure in his face. He's made clutch drives to help us win... even in games where little was going right and frustration was building. He's helped us come back from larger deficits when needed.

I don't know that this team can win in a shoot-out THIS YEAR with the elite QBs like Rodgers or Brees... but I think we can get to where they are in the coming seasons. If Alex can be an 82 QBR with Singletary? Then he can be a 90+ QBR with Harbaugh... check... So if Alex can be a 90+ QBR in year one of Harbaugh? Hmmm... about that year 2... and then 3? etc.

The great strength of this team is that it has the ability to pound the ball against good defenses. Rodgers and Brees can't turn it into a track meet if they are not on the field. With the strength of this defense and the ability to run the ball, I see no reason that the 49ers cannot play with those teams if Edwards and Crabtree stay healthy.
Originally posted by oldman9er:
Originally posted by 190836:
Alex Smith can be a good qb, but can he win a SB?

Don't see why not. He's played well with pressure in his face. He's made clutch drives to help us win... even in games where little was going right and frustration was building. He's helped us come back from larger deficits when needed.

I don't know that this team can win in a shoot-out THIS YEAR with the elite QBs like Rodgers or Brees... but I think we can get to where they are in the coming seasons. If Alex can be an 82 QBR with Singletary? Then he can be a 90+ QBR with Harbaugh... check... So if Alex can be a 90+ QBR in year one of Harbaugh? Hmmm... about that year 2... and then 3? etc.

i can see him thriving in the playoffs, alex has always been good in high pressure situations
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
I posted this in the Fitzpatrick thread but it should probably go here.


It would be an epic mistake if the Niners signed Alex to any long term deal. While he has improved from a bottom 5 qb in the league to maybe the15th or 16th best QB in the NFL. Niners still need to upgrade the position, we need someone who can be a superstar one day and not just a game manager.
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by dj43:
An interesting story is emerging from Buffalo where the Bills have put together a deal for Ryan Fitzpatrick that will pay him $10MILLION a year for 6 years with $24MILLION guaranteed.

We can be sure that Alex's agent is watching closely. If Smith continues to play as he has and the 49ers get to the NFC Championship game, the Fitzpatrick deal will be the benchmark for the negotiations for an extension for Alex. Who saw that coming?

No didn't see that coming for Fritzpatrick...


The difference will be that Fitz had two good years in a row. Alex should get a new deal, but not for that much.
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by dj43:
An interesting story is emerging from Buffalo where the Bills have put together a deal for Ryan Fitzpatrick that will pay him $10MILLION a year for 6 years with $24MILLION guaranteed.

We can be sure that Alex's agent is watching closely. If Smith continues to play as he has and the 49ers get to the NFC Championship game, the Fitzpatrick deal will be the benchmark for the negotiations for an extension for Alex. Who saw that coming?

No didn't see that coming for Fritzpatrick...


The difference will be that Fitz had two good years in a row. Alex should get a new deal, but not for that much.

alex will probably get a one or two year deal because the niners are gonna wanna see him do it for a little while before they extend him long term
  • Jcool
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 44,549
Originally posted by susweel:
I posted this in the Fitzpatrick thread but it should probably go here.


It would be an epic mistake if the Niners signed Alex to any long term deal. While he has improved from a bottom 5 qb in the league to maybe the15th or 16th best QB in the NFL. Niners still need to upgrade the position, we need someone who can be a superstar one day and not just a game manager.

He was never that bad.
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
Originally posted by hondakillerzx:
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by dj43:
An interesting story is emerging from Buffalo where the Bills have put together a deal for Ryan Fitzpatrick that will pay him $10MILLION a year for 6 years with $24MILLION guaranteed.

We can be sure that Alex's agent is watching closely. If Smith continues to play as he has and the 49ers get to the NFC Championship game, the Fitzpatrick deal will be the benchmark for the negotiations for an extension for Alex. Who saw that coming?

No didn't see that coming for Fritzpatrick...


The difference will be that Fitz had two good years in a row. Alex should get a new deal, but not for that much.

alex will probably get a one or two year deal because the niners are gonna wanna see him do it for a little while before they extend him long term

I'd be cool with a 1 or 2 year deal. Im not sure if he would go for it.
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,637
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by hondakillerzx:
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by dj43:
An interesting story is emerging from Buffalo where the Bills have put together a deal for Ryan Fitzpatrick that will pay him $10MILLION a year for 6 years with $24MILLION guaranteed.

We can be sure that Alex's agent is watching closely. If Smith continues to play as he has and the 49ers get to the NFC Championship game, the Fitzpatrick deal will be the benchmark for the negotiations for an extension for Alex. Who saw that coming?

No didn't see that coming for Fritzpatrick...


The difference will be that Fitz had two good years in a row. Alex should get a new deal, but not for that much.

alex will probably get a one or two year deal because the niners are gonna wanna see him do it for a little while before they extend him long term

I'd be cool with a 1 or 2 year deal. Im not sure if he would go for it.

He won't have to worry. If they reach the NFC Championship game the FO won't embarrass themselves by offering so little.
Originally posted by susweel:
I posted this in the Fitzpatrick thread but it should probably go here.


It would be an epic mistake if the Niners signed Alex to any long term deal. While he has improved from a bottom 5 qb in the league to maybe the15th or 16th best QB in the NFL. Niners still need to upgrade the position, we need someone who can be a superstar one day and not just a game manager.

It would not be an epic mistake, or a mistake of any proportion, to sign Alex to a longer contract. This would give management the time to decide if he is a superstar in the making and if not, to find, prepare and develop a superstar.

It would be vastly stupid to let him go before we had established his ceiling and idiotic to wave him out without a replacement of greater ability. And where is the "epic mistake" in paying a competent game manager (if that is as good as he can be) to lead the team while the QBOTF is, as Rodgers did at Green Bay, learning his job?

Undercover hater now?
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by hondakillerzx:
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by dj43:
An interesting story is emerging from Buffalo where the Bills have put together a deal for Ryan Fitzpatrick that will pay him $10MILLION a year for 6 years with $24MILLION guaranteed.

We can be sure that Alex's agent is watching closely. If Smith continues to play as he has and the 49ers get to the NFC Championship game, the Fitzpatrick deal will be the benchmark for the negotiations for an extension for Alex. Who saw that coming?

No didn't see that coming for Fritzpatrick...


The difference will be that Fitz had two good years in a row. Alex should get a new deal, but not for that much.

alex will probably get a one or two year deal because the niners are gonna wanna see him do it for a little while before they extend him long term

I'd be cool with a 1 or 2 year deal. Im not sure if he would go for it.

i think he would, alex isnt hurting for money, hes still a young guy and he can get a bigger contract later if he proves he can get better and stay better. plus he has a young family so i dont think he would want to move them. just seems like a really loyal guy. that article with urban meyer talks about alex being very loyal as well.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone