Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 555 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by NinerPrideinNJ:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by aTx49er:
This thread has gotten kind of boring now that most of the alex haters are MIA...........

MIA? more like converted to lovers

As an ex-hater, I wouldn't say converted lover but rather a 100% supporter. Not a blind supporter but he's gained my confidence.
I still think he's a bit inconsistent and a little too conservative at times, but he's
Getting the job done and that's all good in my book.

THIS. What frustrated me about Smith is that we as fans never asked him for much. All I ever wanted him to be was average. So when the bar was set that low and he still missed it, year in and year out, it pissed me off a great deal.

I always factored in the subpar coaching, but still felt that it just wasn't there for him.

What Harbaugh has done with him is truly dumbfouding. The biggest issue he had was consistency and a penchant for crippling mistakes.

In just a very short time, Harbaugh has pulled a 180 in those departments with him.

Both men deserve a heap of credit for this current turnaround, but clearly the scale leans in favor of coaching. The reason being evident in the fact that Harbaugh and his staff haven't just improved Smith... they've improved every position.


Harbaugh has helped Smith immeasurably but it has been, for the most part, through the system and giving Smith an offense that is a Hummer rather than an Edsel. Next they have to go from the Hummer to a high performance sports model...Porsche or Lamborghini. No matter how skilled a driver you just can't win a race in a poorly built car. He has helped Smith recapture some mechanics as well but that would be for naught with last year's offense.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by aTx49er:
This thread has gotten kind of boring now that most of the alex haters are MIA...........

MIA? more like converted to lovers

As an ex-hater, I wouldn't say converted lover but rather a 100% supporter. Not a blind supporter but he's gained my confidence.
I still think he's a bit inconsistent and a little too conservative at times, but he's
Getting the job done and that's all good in my book.

Getting the job done not good enough for Shaj and Sus. Not pretty enough for them....
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by aTx49er:
This thread has gotten kind of boring now that most of the alex haters are MIA...........

MIA? more like converted to lovers

As an ex-hater, I wouldn't say converted lover but rather a 100% supporter. Not a blind supporter but he's gained my confidence.
I still think he's a bit inconsistent and a little too conservative at times, but he's
Getting the job done and that's all good in my book.

Getting the job done not good enough for Shaj and Sus. Not pretty enough for them....

Don't worry once Alex throws an INT to lose a game, they will all be back in full force. Hopefully that doesn't happen, and we all continue to get along!
Originally posted by TT49ers:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by aTx49er:
This thread has gotten kind of boring now that most of the alex haters are MIA...........

MIA? more like converted to lovers

As an ex-hater, I wouldn't say converted lover but rather a 100% supporter. Not a blind supporter but he's gained my confidence.
I still think he's a bit inconsistent and a little too conservative at times, but he's
Getting the job done and that's all good in my book.

Getting the job done not good enough for Shaj and Sus. Not pretty enough for them....

Don't worry once Alex throws an INT to lose a game, they will all be back in full force. Hopefully that doesn't happen, and we all continue to get along!

Some of the haters came back out after the Detroit game. OMG he has thrown 2 INT"s this season he sucks! His passes are to high! He is reverting to his old self! His mechanics are off!
Will be interesting to see if the extra work during the bye will help Alex or not. I hope Braylon is able to play, I want to see him catch his first and second TD of the season against his old team (Be nice to see Crabtree catch his first TD of the season as well). I am expecting Alex to have the same type of game against Browns as he did against the Bucs.
I just realized that neither Crabtree nor Edwards have a TD this season.
Originally posted by backontop:
I just realized that neither Crabtree nor Edwards have a TD this season.

Both of them missed several games this season. Crabtree had two TDs nullified because the officials flagged him as running out-of-bound. I'm expecting to score a TD real soon.
Originally posted by fastforward:
Originally posted by backontop:
I just realized that neither Crabtree nor Edwards have a TD this season.

Both of them missed several games this season. Crabtree had two TDs nullified because the officials flagged him as running out-of-bound. I'm expecting to score a TD real soon.


I know the situations, I've watched the games.
Originally posted by backontop:
Originally posted by fastforward:
Originally posted by backontop:
I just realized that neither Crabtree nor Edwards have a TD this season.

Both of them missed several games this season. Crabtree had two TDs nullified because the officials flagged him as running out-of-bound. I'm expecting to score a TD real soon.


I know the situations, I've watched the games.


hes due for one this sunday
Alex seems like a guy that will be better in his 30's but that might not be saying much...for me ..I may have had some moments of frustration with Smith...you may find a post here and there over the yrs where I may of lost my mind...lol...I gurantee it's not more than 5 though that's for sure...Most of my posts were in support of Smith and I always tried to stay away from the negative with him...nowadays I just want him to take care of the football...that's all i ask for!...I'm no longer looking for the prolific stats, 300 yard game, 4 TD's etc etc...just take care of the football and the rest will fall into place.....
[ Edited by ktate14 on Oct 28, 2011 at 8:12 AM ]
Urban Meyer talks Alex Smith, Harbaugh and the QB's recent success

I caught up with Meyer, who is now a college football analyst at ESPN, to revisit his 2005 comments and to talk about Smith's resurgence.

Why do things seem to be different this year with Alex?

UM: "I follow the NFL a lot with Alex, Tim (Tebow) and other players. It's amazing to me in the NFL that if you're on a really bad team - bad offense, bad defense, bad kicking game - then it's the QB's fault. Because I told Alex. Alex was like my son. I was real close to Alex. I watched coordinator after coordinator come out of there. The defense was ranked near the bottom every year. It's a really bad team. And all of a sudden, it's, 'Well, Alex can't play.' And I'm thinking, 'What are you talking about? Alex certainly can play.' It's the same thing with Tim. So QBs, they get far too much credit and far too much blame. The best thing about Alex right now - he's on a really good team with a really good coaching staff, and he's a member of a team. I give so much credit to that. I don't know the whole situation, but they're playing really good football."

http://blogs.sacbee.com/49ers/archives/2011/10/urban-meyer-talks-alex-smith-harbaugh-and-the-qbs-recent-success.html#ixzz1c5irhRGR
  • Nes49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 6,105
Originally posted by oldman9er:
Urban Meyer talks Alex Smith, Harbaugh and the QB's recent success

I caught up with Meyer, who is now a college football analyst at ESPN, to revisit his 2005 comments and to talk about Smith's resurgence.

Why do things seem to be different this year with Alex?

UM: "I follow the NFL a lot with Alex, Tim (Tebow) and other players. It's amazing to me in the NFL that if you're on a really bad team - bad offense, bad defense, bad kicking game - then it's the QB's fault. Because I told Alex. Alex was like my son. I was real close to Alex. I watched coordinator after coordinator come out of there. The defense was ranked near the bottom every year. It's a really bad team. And all of a sudden, it's, 'Well, Alex can't play.' And I'm thinking, 'What are you talking about? Alex certainly can play.' It's the same thing with Tim. So QBs, they get far too much credit and far too much blame. The best thing about Alex right now - he's on a really good team with a really good coaching staff, and he's a member of a team. I give so much credit to that. I don't know the whole situation, but they're playing really good football."

http://blogs.sacbee.com/49ers/archives/2011/10/urban-meyer-talks-alex-smith-harbaugh-and-the-qbs-recent-success.html#ixzz1c5irhRGR

U beat me to it oldman9er.
Originally posted by oldman9er:
Urban Meyer talks Alex Smith, Harbaugh and the QB's recent success

I caught up with Meyer, who is now a college football analyst at ESPN, to revisit his 2005 comments and to talk about Smith's resurgence.

Why do things seem to be different this year with Alex?

UM: "I follow the NFL a lot with Alex, Tim (Tebow) and other players. It's amazing to me in the NFL that if you're on a really bad team - bad offense, bad defense, bad kicking game - then it's the QB's fault. Because I told Alex. Alex was like my son. I was real close to Alex. I watched coordinator after coordinator come out of there. The defense was ranked near the bottom every year. It's a really bad team. And all of a sudden, it's, 'Well, Alex can't play.' And I'm thinking, 'What are you talking about? Alex certainly can play.' It's the same thing with Tim. So QBs, they get far too much credit and far too much blame. The best thing about Alex right now - he's on a really good team with a really good coaching staff, and he's a member of a team. I give so much credit to that. I don't know the whole situation, but they're playing really good football."

http://blogs.sacbee.com/49ers/archives/2011/10/urban-meyer-talks-alex-smith-harbaugh-and-the-qbs-recent-success.html#ixzz1c5irhRGR

Meyer validated what most Niners fans have realized about the Alex Smith situation and suffered through the bad coaching, the bad team, and the unreasonable blame on Smith. Writing him off as another no talent #1 pick. And some of the ravingly dumbest posts ever to be made regarding a player playing within the context of a sorry a** team for 7 years.

I have always said the guy can play qb. He just needed some coaching and better talent at the skill positions.
  • 190836
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 11,972
Alex Smith can be a good qb, but can he win a SB?
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone