49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 786 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
No QB can be comfortable when his teammates are not contributing consistently over the course of a game or season. WRs out, OLine consistently inconsistent, and his receivers near the lead in dropped balls indicate that he can't count on his team mates on every play. They are all learning the system and learning each other...if they can stay healthy for a stretch. Now Rachal is out and Snyder in, Morgan out and Edwards in (I hope!), the musical chairs continue.

Smith is a very good athlete. He is graceful, fast and quick with a decent to good throwing motion. When he is comfortable, meaning his line is blocking and his receivers are where they are suppose to be, he is very fluid in his movements. We see this several times a game but not consistently because the other variables are not happening.

I have very high expectations for Smith and always have had. Whether he can meet these expectations is an unknown but his intelligence, athleticism and work ethic lead me to believe he will do so this year or next.

Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by ninertico:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
One thought I have been mulling over is that Smith is not totally comfortable in the new system and yet is succeeding. Could mean he will become a truely fine QB by the end of the season or next year. He is still not at full speed with his decision-making, which accounts for some of the limited YAC and high passes. He may begin to throw more Ints along with more TDs, which is OK by me as long as they continue to win. Walsh and Montana did not start winning until the third year, Harbaugh is doing it in year one...but without the comfort level of players knowing the system inside and out. Just a cautionary note. Does there have to be a hiccup?

The OLine seems to be jelling a bit more and Edwards is back (I hope at full speed). So, with the D being one of the two best in the NFL and the offense improving each week, it just seems possible...shhh...I know, don't jinx it.

Don't care how many TDs Smith throws unless the team wins. We do not need a gunslinger, just a good old fashion WCO QB.

What makes you say he's uncomfortable? I also disagree on his decision making process, it's been there. He can't be awesome every game like he was against TB. I think he truly knows this offense. Now, does he know it all. Oh hell nah, but what he does know works. He stayed back to practice more, like that.

Uncomfortable? Hmmmm....maybe...trying to find another word to describe what you're saying.

Anyone? Bueller?

No QB can be comfortable when his teammates are not contributing consistently over the course of a game or season. WRs out, OLine consistently inconsistent, and his receivers near the lead in dropped balls indicate that he can't count on his team mates on every play. They are all learning the system and learning each other...if they can stay healthy for a stretch. Now Rachal is out and Snyder in, Morgan out and Edwards in (I hope!), the musical chairs continue.

Smith is a very good athlete. He is graceful, fast and quick with a decent to good throwing motion. When he is comfortable, meaning his line is blocking and his receivers are where they are suppose to be, he is very fluid in his movements. We see this several times a game but not consistently because the other variables are not happening.

I have very high expectations for Smith and always have had. Whether he can meet these expectations is an unknown but his intelligence, athleticism and work ethic lead me to believe he will do so this year or next.

This is what I was trying to say but you said it way better than how I tried to explain it.
Just voted for Aaron Rodgers, Drew Brees and Alex Smith on my Pro Bowl ballot.

Too bad Alex won't play since he'll be in the Superbowl.
Originally posted by gamechanger:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by ninertico:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
One thought I have been mulling over is that Smith is not totally comfortable in the new system and yet is succeeding. Could mean he will become a truely fine QB by the end of the season or next year. He is still not at full speed with his decision-making, which accounts for some of the limited YAC and high passes. He may begin to throw more Ints along with more TDs, which is OK by me as long as they continue to win. Walsh and Montana did not start winning until the third year, Harbaugh is doing it in year one...but without the comfort level of players knowing the system inside and out. Just a cautionary note. Does there have to be a hiccup?

The OLine seems to be jelling a bit more and Edwards is back (I hope at full speed). So, with the D being one of the two best in the NFL and the offense improving each week, it just seems possible...shhh...I know, don't jinx it.

Don't care how many TDs Smith throws unless the team wins. We do not need a gunslinger, just a good old fashion WCO QB.

What makes you say he's uncomfortable? I also disagree on his decision making process, it's been there. He can't be awesome every game like he was against TB. I think he truly knows this offense. Now, does he know it all. Oh hell nah, but what he does know works. He stayed back to practice more, like that.

Uncomfortable? Hmmmm....maybe...trying to find another word to describe what you're saying.

Anyone? Bueller?

No QB can be comfortable when his teammates are not contributing consistently over the course of a game or season. WRs out, OLine consistently inconsistent, and his receivers near the lead in dropped balls indicate that he can't count on his team mates on every play. They are all learning the system and learning each other...if they can stay healthy for a stretch. Now Rachal is out and Snyder in, Morgan out and Edwards in (I hope!), the musical chairs continue.

Smith is a very good athlete. He is graceful, fast and quick with a decent to good throwing motion. When he is comfortable, meaning his line is blocking and his receivers are where they are suppose to be, he is very fluid in his movements. We see this several times a game but not consistently because the other variables are not happening.

I have very high expectations for Smith and always have had. Whether he can meet these expectations is an unknown but his intelligence, athleticism and work ethic lead me to believe he will do so this year or next.

This is what I was trying to say but you said it way better than how I tried to explain it.

one detrimental thing i noticed during the Lions game was that he's locking that front leg again. On the INT and even the TD pass to Walker. Other than that his footwork is night and day compared to previous seasons. Hopefully he's working on the leg-lock issue.
Originally posted by schmons:
Originally posted by YungAce:
Originally posted by Method:
Originally posted by YungAce:
if alex throws for 5 tds this sunday, i will buy his jersey

If he throws for 5 td's I'll also buy his jersey.

twinsies

if alex throws for 5 td's i will finally wear my alex smith jersey ive had since his rookie year.....

no! you have to buy a new one
Originally posted by gamechanger:
This is what I was trying to say but you said it way better than how I tried to explain it.


Thank you, I've been saying this in one way or another for three and a half years here, so I should be getting better at expressing my point of view...just like Alex is improving as a QB!
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Oct 27, 2011 at 7:28 AM ]
KNBR
http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/vault/article/magazine/MAG1191408/index.htm
These 3 comebacks on the road. I never thought Smith is that type of player, since they drafted him. He had them before in a few games, but never consider him with that type of mentality. He's proving that he's careful and capable in those situations. And possibility in the near future, above average qb when it comes to comeback drives.
Originally posted by Joecool:
Alex has done everything he's needed to do. He's had a few mishaps but what QB doesn't which is why Alex's overall stats show his consistency this year at playing well than showing his inconsistency in prior years at playing not so well.


excellent point. his better has only gottena little better here and there IMO, BUT he has very significantly reduced both the frequency and severity of his mistakes. great observtion!! he will continue to improve his big play ability as the ENTIRE O gets a better feel for each other IN THE CONTEXT OF THIS OFFENSE and for what each other are thinking at any given moment on any given play depending on what the D is doing, and it will be instantaneous. to me i think that is when those near big plays down the field, will start yielding more success.
This thread has gotten kind of boring now that most of the alex haters are MIA...........
Originally posted by aTx49er:
This thread has gotten kind of boring now that most of the alex haters are MIA...........

MIA? more like converted to lovers
Originally posted by aTx49er:
This thread has gotten kind of boring now that most of the alex haters are MIA...........



  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by aTx49er:
This thread has gotten kind of boring now that most of the alex haters are MIA...........

MIA? more like converted to lovers

As an ex-hater, I wouldn't say converted lover but rather a 100% supporter. Not a blind supporter but he's gained my confidence.
I still think he's a bit inconsistent and a little too conservative at times, but he's
Getting the job done and that's all good in my book.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by aTx49er:
This thread has gotten kind of boring now that most of the alex haters are MIA...........

MIA? more like converted to lovers

As an ex-hater, I wouldn't say converted lover but rather a 100% supporter. Not a blind supporter but he's gained my confidence.
I still think he's a bit inconsistent and a little too conservative at times, but he's
Getting the job done and that's all good in my book.

THIS. What frustrated me about Smith is that we as fans never asked him for much. All I ever wanted him to be was average. So when the bar was set that low and he still missed it, year in and year out, it pissed me off a great deal.

I always factored in the subpar coaching, but still felt that it just wasn't there for him.

What Harbaugh has done with him is truly dumbfouding. The biggest issue he had was consistency and a penchant for crippling mistakes.

In just a very short time, Harbaugh has pulled a 180 in those departments with him.

Both men deserve a heap of credit for this current turnaround, but clearly the scale leans in favor of coaching. The reason being evident in the fact that Harbaugh and his staff haven't just improved Smith... they've improved every position.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone