49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 926 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by YungAce:
Originally posted by Method:
Originally posted by YungAce:
if alex throws for 5 tds this sunday, i will buy his jersey

If he throws for 5 td's I'll also buy his jersey.

twinsies

if alex throws for 5 td's i will finally wear my alex smith jersey ive had since his rookie year.....
[ Edited by schmons on Oct 26, 2011 at 12:51 AM ]
One thought I have been mulling over is that Smith is not totally comfortable in the new system and yet is succeeding. Could mean he will become a truely fine QB by the end of the season or next year. He is still not at full speed with his decision-making, which accounts for some of the limited YAC and high passes. He may begin to throw more Ints along with more TDs, which is OK by me as long as they continue to win. Walsh and Montana did not start winning until the third year, Harbaugh is doing it in year one...but without the comfort level of players knowing the system inside and out. Just a cautionary note. Does there have to be a hiccup?

The OLine seems to be jelling a bit more and Edwards is back (I hope at full speed). So, with the D being one of the two best in the NFL and the offense improving each week, it just seems possible...shhh...I know, don't jinx it.

Don't care how many TDs Smith throws unless the team wins. We do not need a gunslinger, just a good old fashion WCO QB.
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Oct 26, 2011 at 6:12 AM ]
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
and Edwards is back (I hope at full speed).

Braylon Edwards (knee surgery) returned to practice Tuesday, as expected. Edwards is on track to return to game action after running short, intermediate and deep routes at top speed in practice.

rotoworld


  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,637
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
One thought I have been mulling over is that Smith is not totally comfortable in the new system and yet is succeeding. Could mean he will become a truely fine QB by the end of the season or next year. He is still not at full speed with his decision-making, which accounts for some of the limited YAC and high passes. He may begin to throw more Ints along with more TDs, which is OK by me as long as they continue to win. Walsh and Montana did not start winning until the third year, Harbaugh is doing it in year one...but without the comfort level of players knowing the system inside and out. Just a cautionary note. Does there have to be a hiccup?

The OLine seems to be jelling a bit more and Edwards is back (I hope at full speed). So, with the D being one of the two best in the NFL and the offense improving each week, it just seems possible...shhh...I know, don't jinx it.

Don't care how many TDs Smith throws unless the team wins. We do not need a gunslinger, just a good old fashion WCO QB.

I fully expect that with the return of Edwards along with an increased chemistry and timing between Crabtree and Smith, the passing game will open up more.

When you really stop to consider, the 49er receiving corp has been very limited without Edwards and now Morgan, and with Crabtree having no time in TC/PS at all. It is not unlike Smith working with a bunch of guys just off the waiver wire.

All that having been said, it is beginning to look more and more like what Harbaugh truly wants is a team where the rushing yards are consistently greater than the passing yards. Look at his history with Stanford and "the greatest college QB of all time."
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
One thought I have been mulling over is that Smith is not totally comfortable in the new system and yet is succeeding. Could mean he will become a truely fine QB by the end of the season or next year. He is still not at full speed with his decision-making, which accounts for some of the limited YAC and high passes. He may begin to throw more Ints along with more TDs, which is OK by me as long as they continue to win. Walsh and Montana did not start winning until the third year, Harbaugh is doing it in year one...but without the comfort level of players knowing the system inside and out. Just a cautionary note. Does there have to be a hiccup?

The OLine seems to be jelling a bit more and Edwards is back (I hope at full speed). So, with the D being one of the two best in the NFL and the offense improving each week, it just seems possible...shhh...I know, don't jinx it.

Don't care how many TDs Smith throws unless the team wins. We do not need a gunslinger, just a good old fashion WCO QB.

What makes you say he's uncomfortable? I also disagree on his decision making process, it's been there. He can't be awesome every game like he was against TB. I think he truly knows this offense. Now, does he know it all. Oh hell nah, but what he does know works. He stayed back to practice more, like that.

Uncomfortable? Hmmmm....maybe...trying to find another word to describe what you're saying.

Anyone? Bueller?
Smith is a 7 year vet, so he has seen and thrown all the routes and the particular that goes along with them. And I don't see Harbaugh installing anything major in the passing game compare to the running game. So Smith just by the nature of his previous playing experience should know how to handle Harbaugh's passing offense. He has shown that very well in the games so far. The problem that I've seen so far is the in and out of the receivers starting lineup this year. That trust between the qb and his receivers are needed to get the decision making a fraction faster. His receiver may not look like they are open in that initial look, but with confidence and trust, he may throw it to that spot, where his receiver will get that little extra step on his defender to catch it. Or if the receiver is covered, the qb has enough trust to throw it up high for his guy to go for a jump ball. And yeah, that doesn't look good on his accuracy, but that's one way of getting the ball to his receivers too. Essentially, my guy gets a chance at a jump ball but there's no way it gets intercepted.

Can't wait to see Braylon and Crabtree on the field on a consistent basis. Throw in VD and Walker. Gore, Hunter, and Miller underneath. Then we need one more guy to step up at WR. 300yds pass, 300yds running. Freak'n 600yds a game offense!!!
[ Edited by qnnhan7 on Oct 26, 2011 at 9:34 AM ]
Originally posted by ninertico:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
One thought I have been mulling over is that Smith is not totally comfortable in the new system and yet is succeeding. Could mean he will become a truely fine QB by the end of the season or next year. He is still not at full speed with his decision-making, which accounts for some of the limited YAC and high passes. He may begin to throw more Ints along with more TDs, which is OK by me as long as they continue to win. Walsh and Montana did not start winning until the third year, Harbaugh is doing it in year one...but without the comfort level of players knowing the system inside and out. Just a cautionary note. Does there have to be a hiccup?

The OLine seems to be jelling a bit more and Edwards is back (I hope at full speed). So, with the D being one of the two best in the NFL and the offense improving each week, it just seems possible...shhh...I know, don't jinx it.

Don't care how many TDs Smith throws unless the team wins. We do not need a gunslinger, just a good old fashion WCO QB.

What makes you say he's uncomfortable? I also disagree on his decision making process, it's been there. He can't be awesome every game like he was against TB. I think he truly knows this offense. Now, does he know it all. Oh hell nah, but what he does know works. He stayed back to practice more, like that.

Uncomfortable? Hmmmm....maybe...trying to find another word to describe what you're saying.

Anyone? Bueller?

I think he becomes uncomfortable when his line doesn't do too well early. Like in the Lions game, he got hit quick and turned the ball over. This also accounts for his decision making because his internal clock becomes quicker and forces him to make a quick decision, which may not always be the best one. I think once he trusts his OL to do their job like they did against the Bucs, we won't see too many games like the Detroit one.
Originally posted by gamechanger:
I think he becomes uncomfortable when his line doesn't do too well early. Like in the Lions game, he got hit quick and turned the ball over. This also accounts for his decision making because his internal clock becomes quicker and forces him to make a quick decision, which may not always be the best one. I think once he trusts his OL to do their job like they did against the Bucs, we won't see too many games like the Detroit one.

I disagree. It's any given game sometimes good sometimes bad. The Lions game was an overall bad game for Smith with the strip sack and the INT. Still, he was clutch when needed.

Any good pressure on any good QB is going to make them alternate what they had in plan.

Alex has proven that when the pocket collapses, he can make plays like the one against Philly connecting with Hunter. I think there was one in the Lions' game, too.

I think instead of Alex's feeling uncomfortable, I believe the appropriate word is that he's feeling "pressure". The more pressure, the more he has to rely on those instincts. Sometimes he succeeds like the pass to Vernon Davis against Dallas where that ball bounces into Alex's hands, rolls right and chucks it into the endzone. PI called instead of the catch, but success nonetheless. Or the opposite, where Alex throws the ball high and it's picked off by the Lions.

Again, sometimes bad...

...most of the time, good.
Originally posted by ninertico:
What makes you say he's uncomfortable? I also disagree on his decision making process, it's been there. He can't be awesome every game like he was against TB. I think he truly knows this offense. Now, does he know it all. Oh hell nah, but what he does know works. He stayed back to practice more, like that.

Uncomfortable? Hmmmm....maybe...trying to find another word to describe what you're saying.

Anyone? Bueller?

I think at times... times where penalties have us in 3rd and longs... times where he isn't allowed to get into a rhythm with constant disruptions of various forms... that he looks a bit like he's over-thinking things. When things are pretty smooth, so is he... and he gets passes out accurately and quickly. When multiple things are ugly and... off... he can over-think and look uncomfortable.
The way I see it, on any given week, ANY team can win. With us, I mean Smith has only thrown for 2 int's and I think 8 td's. Some continue to wonder and say when is he gonna do this or that, but in my eyes, he already has. A lot say its the running game only thats carrying us, but had it not been for Smith throwing whatever yardage he did, or whatever TD's he has then we wouldnt of won, even with Gore's 100+ yards.

When needed to come back in about 3 games, it wasnt the running game that got us back, but the passing game.When asked to put the game on his back and bring us back he did, perform in the clutch for us, and we won. Not too mention, no one has even mentioned the yearly omen it seems that we never have all of our starters on offense in at the same time.

I want the game where we have Crabs, Edwards, Morgan, Ginn and maybe Williams, then we can talk about the numbers that people like.I think we have to start to look at Smith as we do any other NFL qb. Gonna have some good games, and some bad, this past weekend the avg qb seemed to have Smith type Qb numbers, 1 or 2 td's maybe just under 200 passing yards, maybe 1 or 2 int's. But if they win, no one is worrying about the stats. They got the W.

We have to let go of that 6 or 7 year. Because if you cant see, we arent any resemblence of any past teams. We have the team now, that i always wanted. Where at any given time any phase of the game can take over and make a difference. Running game not working, we got the pass, pass not working we got the run game. Defense not working, we got special teams, Special teams failing, defense gets turnovers. This is the closest aspect to a complete team we have had in a long time.

Every week, some of us make the other teams players into bigger figures than they are. Now in the beginning, some of the best cb's in the league, (beat the Eagles). High powered offense especially good in the 4th qt, (beat Tampa). Then the dirtiest, and most beastly and confusing line in the league w/ Suh (beat the Lions).

It's still too early, but i think we CAN WIN every game, and Smith has to continue to do what he does and help lead us to a win, because it's not just the defense, or Gore, or even Smith and the WR's. It's the team. And if everyone on the team has everyone's back then just as long as they play to their full potential, we can beat anyone.
Originally posted by ninertico:
Originally posted by gamechanger:
I think he becomes uncomfortable when his line doesn't do too well early. Like in the Lions game, he got hit quick and turned the ball over. This also accounts for his decision making because his internal clock becomes quicker and forces him to make a quick decision, which may not always be the best one. I think once he trusts his OL to do their job like they did against the Bucs, we won't see too many games like the Detroit one.

I disagree. It's any given game sometimes good sometimes bad. The Lions game was an overall bad game for Smith with the strip sack and the INT. Still, he was clutch when needed.

Any good pressure on any good QB is going to make them alternate what they had in plan.

Alex has proven that when the pocket collapses, he can make plays like the one against Philly connecting with Hunter. I think there was one in the Lions' game, too.

I think instead of Alex's feeling uncomfortable, I believe the appropriate word is that he's feeling "pressure". The more pressure, the more he has to rely on those instincts. Sometimes he succeeds like the pass to Vernon Davis against Dallas where that ball bounces into Alex's hands, rolls right and chucks it into the endzone. PI called instead of the catch, but success nonetheless. Or the opposite, where Alex throws the ball high and it's picked off by the Lions.

Again, sometimes bad...

...most of the time, good.

Sack-challenged
Originally posted by ninertico:
Originally posted by gamechanger:
I think he becomes uncomfortable when his line doesn't do too well early. Like in the Lions game, he got hit quick and turned the ball over. This also accounts for his decision making because his internal clock becomes quicker and forces him to make a quick decision, which may not always be the best one. I think once he trusts his OL to do their job like they did against the Bucs, we won't see too many games like the Detroit one.

I disagree. It's any given game sometimes good sometimes bad. The Lions game was an overall bad game for Smith with the strip sack and the INT. Still, he was clutch when needed.

Any good pressure on any good QB is going to make them alternate what they had in plan.

Alex has proven that when the pocket collapses, he can make plays like the one against Philly connecting with Hunter. I think there was one in the Lions' game, too.

I think instead of Alex's feeling uncomfortable, I believe the appropriate word is that he's feeling "pressure". The more pressure, the more he has to rely on those instincts. Sometimes he succeeds like the pass to Vernon Davis against Dallas where that ball bounces into Alex's hands, rolls right and chucks it into the endzone. PI called instead of the catch, but success nonetheless. Or the opposite, where Alex throws the ball high and it's picked off by the Lions.

Again, sometimes bad...

...most of the time, good.

The most impressive one to me was vs Tampa when a play broke down, he bought time by rolling LEFT, motioned delanie to go deep and he let a SPIRAL go to the corner of the endzone. Delanie ended up turning inside on accident cuz he was on different page, but GUARANTEED that talked about it later and there's a MUCH BETTER chance next time it's a TD
Originally posted by 9erHIGH:
Originally posted by ninertico:
Originally posted by gamechanger:
I think he becomes uncomfortable when his line doesn't do too well early. Like in the Lions game, he got hit quick and turned the ball over. This also accounts for his decision making because his internal clock becomes quicker and forces him to make a quick decision, which may not always be the best one. I think once he trusts his OL to do their job like they did against the Bucs, we won't see too many games like the Detroit one.

I disagree. It's any given game sometimes good sometimes bad. The Lions game was an overall bad game for Smith with the strip sack and the INT. Still, he was clutch when needed.

Any good pressure on any good QB is going to make them alternate what they had in plan.

Alex has proven that when the pocket collapses, he can make plays like the one against Philly connecting with Hunter. I think there was one in the Lions' game, too.

I think instead of Alex's feeling uncomfortable, I believe the appropriate word is that he's feeling "pressure". The more pressure, the more he has to rely on those instincts. Sometimes he succeeds like the pass to Vernon Davis against Dallas where that ball bounces into Alex's hands, rolls right and chucks it into the endzone. PI called instead of the catch, but success nonetheless. Or the opposite, where Alex throws the ball high and it's picked off by the Lions.

Again, sometimes bad...

...most of the time, good.

The most impressive one to me was vs Tampa when a play broke down, he bought time by rolling LEFT, motioned delanie to go deep and he let a SPIRAL go to the corner of the endzone. Delanie ended up turning inside on accident cuz he was on different page, but GUARANTEED that talked about it later and there's a MUCH BETTER chance next time it's a TD

He did the same thing in the Detroit game with Ginn, had Ginn not stumbled the pass was on the money.
Alex has done everything he's needed to do. He's had a few mishaps but what QB doesn't which is why Alex's overall stats show his consistency this year at playing well than showing his inconsistency in prior years at playing not so well.
Originally posted by ninertico:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
One thought I have been mulling over is that Smith is not totally comfortable in the new system and yet is succeeding. Could mean he will become a truely fine QB by the end of the season or next year. He is still not at full speed with his decision-making, which accounts for some of the limited YAC and high passes. He may begin to throw more Ints along with more TDs, which is OK by me as long as they continue to win. Walsh and Montana did not start winning until the third year, Harbaugh is doing it in year one...but without the comfort level of players knowing the system inside and out. Just a cautionary note. Does there have to be a hiccup?

The OLine seems to be jelling a bit more and Edwards is back (I hope at full speed). So, with the D being one of the two best in the NFL and the offense improving each week, it just seems possible...shhh...I know, don't jinx it.

Don't care how many TDs Smith throws unless the team wins. We do not need a gunslinger, just a good old fashion WCO QB.

What makes you say he's uncomfortable? I also disagree on his decision making process, it's been there. He can't be awesome every game like he was against TB. I think he truly knows this offense. Now, does he know it all. Oh hell nah, but what he does know works. He stayed back to practice more, like that.

Uncomfortable? Hmmmm....maybe...trying to find another word to describe what you're saying.

Anyone? Bueller?

No QB can be comfortable when his teammates are not contributing consistently over the course of a game or season. WRs out, OLine consistently inconsistent, and his receivers near the lead in dropped balls indicate that he can't count on his team mates on every play. They are all learning the system and learning each other...if they can stay healthy for a stretch. Now Rachal is out and Snyder in, Morgan out and Edwards in (I hope!), the musical chairs continue.

Smith is a very good athlete. He is graceful, fast and quick with a decent to good throwing motion. When he is comfortable, meaning his line is blocking and his receivers are where they are suppose to be, he is very fluid in his movements. We see this several times a game but not consistently because the other variables are not happening.

I have very high expectations for Smith and always have had. Whether he can meet these expectations is an unknown but his intelligence, athleticism and work ethic lead me to believe he will do so this year or next.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone