49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 871 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by BHulman:
Originally posted by susweel:
He's not even throwing for 200 yards a game.

I wonder what the team's record would be if he was?

haha exactly.

even tho we've only played six games we'd be 10-0 already. I'm so tired of the passing yards argument. Hell, it's not even an argument. It's BS.
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Originally posted by BHulman:
Originally posted by susweel:
He's not even throwing for 200 yards a game.

I wonder what the team's record would be if he was?

haha exactly.

even tho we've only played six games we'd be 10-0 already. I'm so tired of the passing yards argument. Hell, it's not even an argument. It's BS.

Its always been kind of a shifting argument. For awhile it was only about wins but now that the wins are coming it seems to be more about stats. Its confusing.
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
I believe the 49er offense is hand-cuffed because of Alex Smith. Harbaugh does not trust Alex to explore the PLAY-BOOK. Harbaugh will turn off Alex once Keapernick or Tolzein is ready. STAY TUNED FOR 2012 !

and you know this how? It's what you want to believe, does not mean it is fact.
So everyone of your 11,027 post have been based on fact ? Not one has been what you want to believe?
One thing I've been thinking is our run game is like what he had at stanfurd. But is our pass game? And if not why not
Originally posted by toeknee:
One thing I've been thinking is our run game is like what he had at stanfurd. But is our pass game? And if not why not

Yeah our pass game is pretty similar. These people wanting 4 WR sets are just unrealistic. And he has a better RB and more physical OL than he's ever had before, so his running game is really doing well. At Stanford they had 3-4 really good TEs, bigger targets than we have now. We have 2 really good TEs. Luck's first year at Stanford and the year they had Gerhart was pretty similar to this.
Originally posted by toeknee:
One thing I've been thinking is our run game is like what he had at stanfurd. But is our pass game? And if not why not

In 09 Luck threw for about 2,600 yards and in 10 he threw for over 3,300. He threw about 100 more passes in 10 than he did in 09. Luck's completion percentage jumped to 71% in 2010 from 57% in 2009. Gerhart was the star in 09 rushing for over 1,800 yards. I tend to think that Harbaugh's offense is something that evolves out of the power running game. It will be interesting to see what happens with the O over the last 10 games.
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
I believe the 49er offense is hand-cuffed because of Alex Smith. Harbaugh does not trust Alex to explore the PLAY-BOOK. Harbaugh will turn off Alex once Keapernick or Tolzein is ready. STAY TUNED FOR 2012 !

and you know this how? It's what you want to believe, does not mean it is fact.
So everyone of your 11,027 post have been based on fact ? Not one has been what you want to believe?

I didn't say that.

Answer the question.

How do you know Harbaugh doesn't trust Smith with the playbook? You seem dead set that it's true. I'm just wondering how you came to this conclusion. Did you sit in on a coach's meeting or something? Or is it your bias toward Alex that is fueling what you believe?
Originally posted by BHulman:
Originally posted by toeknee:
One thing I've been thinking is our run game is like what he had at stanfurd. But is our pass game? And if not why not

In 09 Luck threw for about 2,600 yards and in 10 he threw for over 3,300. He threw about 100 more passes in 10 than he did in 09. Luck's completion percentage jumped to 71% in 2010 from 57% in 2009. Gerhart was the star in 09 rushing for over 1,800 yards. I tend to think that Harbaugh's offense is something that evolves out of the power running game. It will be interesting to see what happens with the O over the last 10 games.
very true and i think the passing game will open up more as the season goes on. crabtree is pretty much the only legit WR threat we've had since morgan got hurt. once braylon comes back itll ad a whole new dimension to our offense and i expect even greater gains in the ground game since defenses have to account for braylon being a deep threat.
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by gold49digger:
Originally posted by HessianDud:
People are bagging on Smith, but at this rate these will be his numbers:

3,000 yards
21 TDs
5 INTS
64% completion
7 YPA
95 rating

That would be a fantastic season. And, since that would be a fantastic season, why the hell do people have a problem with his performance thus far?

because he is not throwing for 400 yards a game.


He's not even throwing for 200 yards a game.

when he had to, he threw for almost 200 yards in 1 quarter (vs Eagles)
Originally posted by hofer36:
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by gold49digger:
Originally posted by HessianDud:
People are bagging on Smith, but at this rate these will be his numbers:

3,000 yards
21 TDs
5 INTS
64% completion
7 YPA
95 rating

That would be a fantastic season. And, since that would be a fantastic season, why the hell do people have a problem with his performance thus far?

because he is not throwing for 400 yards a game.


He's not even throwing for 200 yards a game.

when he had to, he threw for almost 200 yards in 1 quarter (vs Eagles)

He needs to do that over four quarters
Originally posted by hofer36:
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by gold49digger:
Originally posted by HessianDud:
People are bagging on Smith, but at this rate these will be his numbers:

3,000 yards
21 TDs
5 INTS
64% completion
7 YPA
95 rating

That would be a fantastic season. And, since that would be a fantastic season, why the hell do people have a problem with his performance thus far?

because he is not throwing for 400 yards a game.


He's not even throwing for 200 yards a game.

when he had to, he threw for almost 200 yards in 1 quarter (vs Eagles)
I wanna see him do that over four quarters
Originally posted by hofer36:
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by gold49digger:
Originally posted by HessianDud:
People are bagging on Smith, but at this rate these will be his numbers:

3,000 yards
21 TDs
5 INTS
64% completion
7 YPA
95 rating

That would be a fantastic season. And, since that would be a fantastic season, why the hell do people have a problem with his performance thus far?

because he is not throwing for 400 yards a game.


He's not even throwing for 200 yards a game.

when he had to, he threw for almost 200 yards in 1 quarter (vs Eagles)

He needs to do that over four quarters
He does not need to do that. When they will ask him he will deliver.

I'm not upset with his play...I just feel like at some point he's going to have to make more plays for us to win games

Don't even care who said it, but this? Give me a break. He has already had to put together drives to win games... and has.

He's making the throws... but what is he supposed to do? Catch the ball for the receivers also? Let's face it... sometimes our guys can make catches, but other times, they just look like they don't belong in the NFL. I mean, what kind of pro TE/WR are you when you (Walker) can't even turn your hands the proper way to catch a wide open TD pass? What good is 4.3 speed when you (Ginn) can't track and adjust to a deep ball? SF is without question in the top 10 for dropped passes this season. What happened to you (VD) that you're no longer breaking single tackles by DBs? So it's pretty clear that our playmakers need to improve their playmaking. This Jekyll and Hyde routine gets annoying.
Originally posted by oldman9er:
Quote:

I'm not upset with his play...I just feel like at some point he's going to have to make more plays for us to win games

Don't even care who said it, but this? Give me a break. He has already had to put together drives to win games... and has.

He's making the throws... but what is he supposed to do? Catch the ball for the receivers also? Let's face it... sometimes our guys can make catches, but other times, they just look like they don't belong in the NFL. I mean, what kind of pro TE/WR are you when you (Walker) can't even turn your hands the proper way to catch a wide open TD pass? What good is 4.3 speed when you (Ginn) can't track and adjust to a deep ball? SF is without question in the top 10 for dropped passes this season. What happened to you (VD) that you're no longer breaking single tackles by DBs? So it's pretty clear that our playmakers need to improve their playmaking. This Jekyll and Hyde routine gets annoying.

I hope Braylon cures some of the drop problems we've been having but his track record isn't too assuring. I think Crabtree is good but he and Alex need to get their chemistry/timing together. These 2 guys have consistently been inconsistent. So far with the job the coaches have done this issue with the passing game should go away. The one thing that remains to be true is that this team is getting better and better each day. If we don't see a dramatic improvement after the bye I will be very surprised.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone